I jailed him because I believed he was scum, and no one else did, so if I was right, good chance he'd be making the scum kill and I'd block it, and if I was wrong, good chance he'd be the target of the scum kill and I'd protect him. Seemed like the best choice all around.
Didn't jail anyone N2.
I'm aware that this wouldn't have stopped rofl getting an innocent result if he was a Hider, and for that reason, I wasn't going to do this counterclaim thing until I spotted this here:
which is clearly specifically crumbing the Vanilla Cop role. Points for consistency.roflcopter wrote:i don't like the return to the vp baltar wagon. i think he's telling the truth about his role.
I'm also aware that I could have been targeted by a Mafia Roleblocker on N1, and that this would have allowed rofl to get his result. However, for this to be true, you have to also believe that the scum did not decide to block rofl on N2, despite him having very obviously softclaimed an investigative role, and there being no other power roles exposed. That seems very unlikely to me.
Of course, if rofl is scum, you have to also believe that Yos is scum and rofl felt the need to protect him at all costs when he really wasn't in all that much danger, or that rofl decided to stake his survival on the hope that townYos is not a power role. The latter would be ridiculously stupid, so I'm discounting that and assuming the former. My theory is that rofl and Yos are Mafia Lovers, because I can't seeing him being that desperate to keep Yos alive if they weren't.
So, yeah, I don't have 100% damning evidence that rofl is scum, if I did, I would have just gone ahead and said so without waiting for a claim from him first. If you really think that necessitates a lynch on me, then I guess go ahead, but I don't believe that what I've done here has hurt the town.
By the way, we're not lynching rofl today. It would clearly be a better idea to lynch Yos, because he is definitely scum if rofl is scum, and on the off chance that rofl is actually telling the truth, we'd be lynching a vanilla rather than a cop.