Just a theory as to why Excedrin was killed. He was on to something as far as the 3rd vote theory goes, or he was on the right track to catching scum. Its not much, but its something.
So you think that Messiah is scum?
Here's my preliminary thoughts: If you look at the voting record, you'll notice that Excedrin was not voting for XScorp. He was voting for NAW. Now, there are two things that could have happened. Either NAW, being scum and being worried that someone was on to him, pegged the most active pursuer of a case against him and got lucky, or someone was talking when they shouldn't have. I mean, really. What are the odds of nailing the Doc on Night One?
But that aside
and #### you mafia.
And I quote from the Mafiascum Wiki article "Finding Mafia":
Gloating (any form of "complaining" about how bad the previous night was, how the doctor/cop was killed, etc.) Similar to "congratulating the doctor".
I've seen it a few times myself, but not that often. This would be more evidence to NAW being worried.
In addition, NAW was saying earlier that people need to stick their heads out for the Town if necessary. While he did brush that off, I think it's kinda odd that he say that.
As for PP, I would agree with Messiah--PP hasn't been very active. I don't think the jumping all over the place would be a scum-mark, since I've done the same thing a few times, but I'm having a hard time getting a read off of him/her. It's somewhat similar to what Adam's been doing, but Adam's been more active, just more enigmatic.
Overall, I think that NAW and/or PP might be scum.
Men are like colonies of bacteria. The more heat you apply, the faster they grow.
We can't see the demons that lurk in the dark...That's why humans are weak.