As promissed, a scumlist ftw.
Prob Town
charter - gut, meta arguments, agressive charter is town charter.
roflcopter - gut, meta arguments, usual town rolf.
elvis_knits - gut, meta arguments, also agressive elvis is town elvis.
Ojanen - gut, solid reasoning, feels transparent.
Neutral
Thesp - solid reasoning yesterday, havent heard much of him today, needs to post more.
SerialClergyman - tbh I skipped some of his posts (the majority are a tl/dr debate with yos). Possible rolefishin, will need to iso him.
PookyTheMagicalBear - needs to post more. alexhans felt kinda relaxed yesterday.
iamausername - doesnt scream scum, doesnt scream town, needs to post more.
VP Baltar - solid points overall but something of his tone doesnt sit well with me, will need to iso him.
Xylthixlm - usual difficult to read Xyl. Majority of his posts are meh.
Yosarian2 - yos is always hard to read. as i said, some of his posts feel scummy but he comes back with a potent protown point.
zu_Faul - same with iam, doesnt scream scum but doesnt scream town, needs to post more.
Prob scum
Kmd4390 - gut, meta arguments (i dont remember kmdtown being ironic), elvisvote early is terrible, elvisunvote is odd. backs up his yos hate with yos meta that I still dont get.
ekiM - baltar case feels good. meta arguments, i dont think ive ever seen miketown being so humurous. his last elvis debate feels forced and i agree that his reads lack substance, something off in what Ive seen of mike in other games.
I really dont understand the serial case. Anyone?
Willing to vote kmd but also interested in the mike momentum and competing wagons.
Vote: Mike.
Call me Tajo.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=12894
Coming summer 2010: Tajo's Starcraft Mafia.
Tajo's MagictheGathering Mafia