yabbaguy wrote:@Crazy: Your PLBPLA, for Hero, you just say "I don't get what you're talking about." There have been several points made, at one time or another, from several players, about Hero, including my own PLBPLA. If you don't see the merit in them, truly you'll be able to pick some of them out and point out their flaws.
I strongly believe that emotional reactions are not scum-tells, and that's the main part of the Hero case.
Ignoring that, there are quite a few players that are scummier than Hero.
yabbaguy wrote:@Hero-302: Emotional responses tend to come from when you've exhausted all your logic attacks and are resorting to emotion to get your point across. Often, scum find themselves running out of good logic because they know they're wrong, so this is more often than not a scumtell.
I've never heard that before, and I disagree completely. Townies are more likely to get frustrated if people don't listen to their cases, while scum often have an "as long as it's not me" plan in their head.
However, all of this is trumped, simply because this setup is open and has multiple scum-teams,
everybody
has the ability to honestly scum-hunt. Scum don't have to make up fake cases here, because there
is
scum out there that you don't know, no matter what your role is.
Noramp wrote:
I would like to clear something up, I never meant to suggest that I was defending Falko, Hero. I was arguing that Flava was trying to push a bad case, since then Falko has played really poorly and has become a lot more suspicious in my eyes. The main issue with Falko in my eyes isnt the lurking, however, that is a big deal but its his backtracking over Flavas question. I personally felt his first answer was sufficient, obviously not everyone felt the same but then he went and changed his mind two more times and then disappeared. This is very scummy.
That's bogus. It was Flava that was making the big deal about the question, not falko. Should he have just ignored Flava?
The big deal that makes Falko scummy is the lurking, but that's it.
Flava wrote:I haven't dismissed anything.
I only said that a Falko/Hero scumteam is more likely than Falko/Ceph.
And I've given plenty of reasoning against you. OMGUS wasn't one of my points, so I don't see why you feel the need to defend against that.
You put Cephrir in your town-pile simply because of falko's random vote. I think something like that is too arbitrary to be
mentioned
at this point.
OP wrote:Because it makes more sense for town to lynch scum first, not werewolves.
Ugh, not this again. Lynch anybody that you think is scum; that's it. Mastin is just overexaggerating his scum-hunting ability... there's absolutely nothing saying that he's right about the mafia team.
**
Noramp's contradiction that Zazie pointed out looks solid... I have to look at that some more later. If it is a true contradiction, then I am absolutely 100% happy with lynching Noramp.