Yes. And he obviously was, or this game would be over.
As far as Phily versus Kmd:
IH: Voted for Shin early, was replaced before he really said anything of note (other than "Random bandwagons are often pushed by townies)
ZazieR: Kept the pressure up on Shin, kept her vote on Shin the whole time, povided pretty good analysis at the end of Day 1. Also had this:
ZazieR wrote:I also want to hear from a ZEEnon's replacement first. Especially as ZEEnon had a chainsaw defence against Empking.
This was at the tail end of D1 - it seems a little odd for scum to never unvote her buddy on replacing in and then bring up a tell on her other buddy (and roleblocker to boot).
PhilyEc: Is the main problem with this chain, as he's done nothing but sling mud with ac1983fan and Tuber, two all-but-confirmed townies. His posts have been short and sort of confused.
I think his tiff toward the end of the day with GIEFF about the quote pyramid is revealing, and his declaration that "ac is a better lynch than Shin" wasn't very well supported. He'd been voting for BlakAdder/me at that point, and had been for most of the day. His Shin vote post looks like someone who's realizing a lynch is inevitable and either wants to make sure we get the deadline lynch in or is giving up on a scumbuddy.
Kmd wrote:Reasonably scummy. Not a power role. I'm V/LA starting tomorrow.
Unvote, Vote Shin
Was then extremely absent for most/all of D2, only dropping in to admit he couldn't really remember why he thought ac was a better lynch. The "Slicey kill seems weird to me too" thing was unnecessary by the time he posted it, and could constitute hand-wringing.
Yeah, Kmd, I do always think you're scum, but this time you feel like the better option.
Vote: Kmd4390
.