Open 118 - Follow The Cop ... Or Not (Game Over) before 748

[Tuberkulos]

You could explain why your vote is on me. Is it purely because I unvoted Shin just to hammer him in my very next post?

What do you think of the people playing so far? Who looks scummy and why? Who looks town and why? State where you stand.

vote: Shadow Knight

[Empking]

Tuber: Why is SK scummy?

[Shadow Knight]

@Tuber- I'm voting you mostly because I agree with GIEFF's case against you. I also feel that either ac or grandi/zeenon is your scum-buddy.

[PhilyEc]

If you don't have a read on zazier and kmd, why do you think they are scum? It's odd you had enough time to go through every single one of ac's post, yet can't provide a single reason for suspecting anyone else.

Bumping this question.

FoS Shadow Knight

for jumping into defenses so quickly.

Zazier for lurking the hell out of this game but not others, and Grandi for regurgitating my case, accusing me of not posting content, analyzing just me in her first post, insulting me somewhat, and for the scummy behavior of ZEEnon. But, for now, vote:Zazier.

But didnt I replace Zazier?

(Currently: Considering if Tuber is scum or not)

[Shadow Knight]

@Phily- Huh? I wasn't aware that I was defending anything by answering a question.

[ac1983fan]

Zazier for lurking the hell out of this game but not others, and Grandi for regurgitating my case, accusing me of not posting content, analyzing just me in her first post, insulting me somewhat, and for the scummy behavior of ZEEnon. But, for now, vote:Zazier.

But didnt I replace Zazier?

Oh shit.
My bad...

unvote

/I is dumb

vote:grandi

[PhilyEc]

@Phily- Huh? I wasn't aware that I was defending anything by answering a question.

You werent defending yourself, look back over the area I was talking about before you conclude that.

Its fine to defend yourself, but to defend other players suggests you know their alignment/role and think questioning them isnt necessary =\

[GIEFF]

Grandi has posted 68 times in other games since his last post here.

unvote

Vote Grandi

[PhilyEc]

Zazier for lurking the hell out of this game but not others, and Grandi for regurgitating my case, accusing me of not posting content, analyzing just me in her first post, insulting me somewhat, and for the scummy behavior of ZEEnon. But, for now, vote:Zazier.

But didnt I replace Zazier?

Oh shit.
My bad...

unvote

/I is dumb

vote:grandi

Quick switch O_o Any reasons?

[Shadow Knight]

@Phily- Oh, I see. I misunderstood which question/answer you were talking about. I thought you meant Tuber's question about why I'm voting him and who I think is scummy/townie. You meant the question where I answered/clarified (I think) the question about not getting a read. Again, that wasn't defending anyone per se, I was actually hoping I'd get a "yes, that's what I meant" post to avoid confusion.

[DraketheFake]

I think Grandi is a good play for today. I like ac1983fan's Post 503 a lot, and nothing Grandi has done makes me forget the way ZEEnon played yesterday.

Shadow Knight concerns me as well. His posts yesterday were completely relegated to short one-liners, and to come in today, say "I like GIEFF's case against Tuber," and then say "I think Tuber is scum with one of ac/Grandi" sounds pretty similar to what Grandi tried to come in and do, just with somebody nobody else would have tried to vote.

FoS: Shadow Knight

for the moment.

Sorry I've been AWOL lately, and access will be spotty until next Tuesday as I take a graduate school tour in Cali. Remember that Grandi is at L-1.

[ac1983fan]

Zazier for lurking the hell out of this game but not others, and Grandi for regurgitating my case, accusing me of not posting content, analyzing just me in her first post, insulting me somewhat, and for the scummy behavior of ZEEnon. But, for now, vote:Zazier.

But didnt I replace Zazier?

Oh shit.
My bad...

unvote

/I is dumb

vote:grandi

Quick switch O_o Any reasons?

For the reasons I've already specified regarding grandi. Also the fact that you have replaced Zazier.

[GIEFF]

Why does the fact that Phily replaced Zazier make you unvote Zazier and vote Grandi?

[Nameless]

You Are The Vote Counter. During The Day Phase, You May PM The Mod To Count The Votes. You May Not Post Anything But Numbers, Usernames And "Vote". You Win When No Voters Are Left To Be Counted.

Grandi: 4 (DraketheFake, Empking, ac1983fan, GIEFF)
ac1983fan: 1 (Grandi)
Shadow Knight: 1 (Tuberkulos)
Tuberkulos: 1 (Shadow Knight)
Not Voting: 2 (PhilyEc, Kmd4390)

[ac1983fan]

Why does the fact that Phily replaced Zazier make you unvote Zazier and vote Grandi?

Because I haven't really been able to read on Phily, and I didn't realize, at the time of my initial vote, that zazier had been replaced.

[Tuberkulos]

@Tuber- I'm voting you mostly because I agree with GIEFF's case against you. I also feel that either ac or grandi/zeenon is your scum-buddy.

I do. You've said you unvoted Shin because you wanted others to perceive you as willing to vote ac. I don't see why a pro-town player would worry about that, and I think that if you really preferred a Shin lynch to an ac lynch, there should be no need to unvote.

And even if your true objective for unvoting WAS what you say it is (i.e. showing everybody that you are willing to lynch ac), unvoting failed to achieve this objective. The only way to show you are willing to vote ac is to ACTUALLY VOTE AC. And you did not look all that willing to consider the ac lynch, considering your very next post after your unvote was the hammer.

And although you did hammer, at that point it was clear that Shin was going to be the lynch choice no matter what, so it doesn't mean all that much.

Is this the case you are refering to? How do you feel about the fact that GIEFF himself doesn't vote me because of this?

Tuber: Why is SK scummy?

Because he doesn't do much, and at the moment he relies on a very weak case for voting me. If I hadn't cared much for Shinnen during D1 and suddenly came in and hammered her (or claimed that I would, because I suddenly found her scummy), then I would understand. But oh wait, that's ac we are talking about now... I did more than just hammer her and my hammer didn't really mean much at all anyway, she were going to be lynched no matter. I just wanted to end the dragging.

Not only does SK act scummy, he is also acting like a moron.

Unvote

Grandi, it's time for you to claim.

[Shadow Knight]

@Tuber- yep, that'd be the one. I'm ok with it if GIEFF feels that another player warrants his attention. *I* think *you* warrant *my* attention. Personally, I can add to his case on you that you seem to be overreacting to a single vote, as well as using a personal attack. I also enjoyed the unvote (presumably to prove to Grandi that you're willing to vote him, right?)

[Tuberkulos]

@Tuber- yep, that'd be the one. I'm ok with it if GIEFF feels that another player warrants his attention. *I* think *you* warrant *my* attention. Personally, I can add to his case on you that you seem to be overreacting to a single vote, as well as using a personal attack.

The amount of votes (in this case just one) does not matter, but the case they rely on.

I also enjoyed the unvote

(presumably to prove to Grandi that you're willing to vote him, right?)

That's right. I'll follow GIEFF's example this time.

vote: Grandi

[GIEFF]

[GIEFF]

Why would you say it's time for Grandi to claim and then hammer before he gets the chance to do so?

[Shadow Knight]

Because Tuber is scum. This will either get me an MVP or LVP depending on the outcome. I'm praying the tracker reads this and listens to me. I'm the cop. I got guilty on Tuber last night and there is absolutely no reason why the doc would have protected me last night. I deliberately gave him no reason to think I was town yesterday with my short posts.

@Tracker- don't bother watching Tuber or me tonight. I'll be dead or roleblocked and Tuber is confirmed scum. Find the other scum (praying you don't get roleblocked and you're not Grandi). You have a 1 in 5 chance to find scum.

[GIEFF]

I think that was a good move, SK; your night-ability for scum is an excellent trade, especially if Tuber is the RB.

Why did you investigate Tuber?

[Shadow Knight]

EBWODP- If the doc wants to get fancy, he can protect me tonight, but that means the scum could ignore me and fire into the crowd hoping to get the tracker. My advice is do not protect me as that means they have to use either the roleblock or the kill on me, giving the tracker a better chance to survive and come up with scum for the win.

[GIEFF]

I think a WIFOM-plan is best; doc on SK with 50% probability, and on another random person with 50% probability. SK will likely be role-blocked , but if he doesn't die, we have a confirmed townie, which is valuable.

And if he is NOT roleblocked, NOT killed, and the doc is NOT on him, we can get another cleared, althought this is not likely.

[Shadow Knight]

Gut hunch. I breadcrumbed it in my first post today. Capital letters bolded...

OK

.

T

he internet seems to be back

U

p.

B

ummer about slicey.

I

'm

S

till glad we hit

SCUM

yesterday though. more to come.