Ok, I think its time to draw a line between being newbie and playing poorly. At first I though afatchic was a newbie because I played with him in a newbie game (he was a newbie) not much ago. Now we know he isnt that newbie. But do you agree that he is playing poorly?Artem wrote:I don't buy the "I don't know how to read experienced players" card. This is not your first game here either. I'm sure that not everybody you've played with in the past was a newbie. You want to appear as if you've nailed afatchic and Juls, but having troubles with me and Crazy, because we're somehow more experienced. Just an FYI, afatchic played more games than me. I'm yet to complete my first ten games.
There is a big difference with you, Crazy and Juls. Any of you, as scum, have more probabilities of tricking me than afatchic. For obvious reasons. Thats why I cant decide with such facility if you are scum or not. Geez, this game isnt that easy.
Yes but they have more probabilities of sucking at it than an experienced scum.Artem wrote:Besides, newb-scum also understand the concept of "scum to win shouldnt act as scum, scum should act as town."
What about Juls distancing from Crazy, specially knowing that she has been going all-attack mode against afatchic but not of his another suspects?Artem wrote:I just really can't see a mafia making it. I've been very careful not to drop any hints that I suspect Crazy. Why would a mafia come out and start accusing my accuser, when it's not even clear what my stance on them is? It doesn't make sense from a buddying perspective, but it does make sense from a scum-hunting perspective, because Crazy's arguments have been far-reaching.
I suspect everyone that jumped against afatchic. I assume one scum was aggressive (Juls) and the other is trying to be subtle. Thats why its hard to decide between you and Crazy. There is some subtle defending of Juls in some posts. Im not too sure about that arguments that have been far-reaching. Could you point me to them?Artem wrote:In turn, will you tell me why you suspect Crazy? Since I think that you two are buddies, I'd like to see you spend sometime describing your thoughts about him.