Veiled Committee Mafia: List Mods Edition [game over]

[DragonEater70]

I'm in fact here.
going to ISO dive Nurse like I said I was planning to do several days ago.

[DragonEater70]

27 - this can be easily faked, so I'm indifferent to it. In general if there's a Miller claim should they be Role-Copped if there's one?

31 - I'm in the camp that thinks mass-claiming in general, early on, is usually not a good idea.

61 - Thing is, is her fakeclaiming as Town a reliable Towntell in current games?

Was that even what was said?

93 - *stares in confusion*

101 - OK why?

133 - PR hunting?

Why do you think so?

135 - I don't think I agree with fast responses earning Townleans. Wanna fight about it?

138 -

Caught up to 178. Not really getting any gut feels currently.

Just a heads-up: I really struggle on Day 1 because I've got no tangible evidence to work with, so the game starts for me on Day 2. Feel free to

pester

ask me about it.[/b]

Questioned some things in

this color

. Personally I feel like this post should robably be seen as scummy for basically havong no real opinions or reads expressed in it, but I did like Nurse's sincerity about not having reads (in green text) so I'm just slightly TRing this post.

[DragonEater70]

204 - Good question.

220 - VOTE: Anix

225 - Your post doesn't make much sense, let alone justification.

At this point I'm getting slight Townvibes off dragoneater. Slight.

245 - I agree here about not PR hunting.

253 - OK, why?

255 - *places pin in case Anix flips Scum*

269 - *places another pin*

272 - I wouldn't discount the possibility.

280 - Didn't he site-flake?

298 - Not sure how to read this. How does that make him look Scum, but I do agree on the statement regarding Bingle.

322 - You want players to massclaim but don't see the point in it? Please clarify this.

328 - Activity. Is. Not. Indicative. Of. Alignment.

337 - You say you want to consider a massclaim Day 1 but your role won't be part of it? Come on, man.

344 - Is this Mathblade?

353 - Sauce?

UNVOTE: Anix - I don't know what to make of this feud with Koba.

355 - You don't think it more possible it could be Anix/Koba distancing? Can't tell if the aggression is legit or not.

If I had to guess there might be one Scum within the Anix-STD-Koba love triangle.

Caught up to 380.

Another interesting post. It's been said countless times that it's easy to scumread AniX, but I did actually like that vote there.
I also liked the frustration regarding thinking that activity is AI, though I do want to clarify that here specifically I was townreading most active players so the lurkers were scum by literal PoE.
I also like the fact that Nurse questions Bingle's sr of StD.
So I'd say this post has earned Nurse 2-3 townpoints in my eyes.

[DragonEater70]

404 -

435 - I don't think I agree with "this trait Town, this trait Scum." Game's more complex than that.

436 - This isn't a subtle signal to look at low-activity members, is it?

The arguing between Anix and Koba is legit giving me a headache.

450 - I'm opposed to massclaim because we lose the element of surprise and Scum will just lie about their roles.

499 -

+1

521 - How exactly?

534 - Activity. Is. Not. Indicative. Of. Alignment.

538 - Really? Seems opportunistic to me.

540 - Also opportunistic.

544 - Also opportunistic.

551 - I see you've got a similar posting style this game.

559 - Why this?

561 - What exactly is your reason for voting Koba?

566 - It does raise an eyebrow, to be honest.

593 - Someone gets it.

PROBABLY TOWN?

TOWNLEAN?

Aureal, Skygazer, AniX

NEED MORE INFO

Save The Dragons, DragonEater70, Ranger, Theta Alpine, KatyKimFanClub, Ircher, Bingle, camelCasedSnivy, JasonWazza

SCUMLEAN?

DkKoba, Alisae, Cook, Doctor Drew

PROBABLY SCUM?

And the reason I've got those four in Scumlean is because Koba's vote based on my first TWO posts is utter rubbish. I'm freaking busy, Bro. I'm on MY clock, not yours. And the three votes in rapid-succession after Koba's reeks of opportunism. Activity is not indicative of alignment, and you look like you're trying to jump on an easy target. Aureal seems like she's trying to solve the game, and her being wary does give off some Townvibes to me. Skygazer seems more Townish, actually understanding that a nurse might be extremely busy, instead of trying to use it as an opportunity to score an easy lim. AniX I've never played with before, but he does seem like he's trying to solve the game in his own way, which seems to be more in the mechanical sense. The others I haven't gotten enough information from either way to suss them out: again, I STRUGGLE during Day 1 in general because we have literally NOTHING.

I agree that at least one person on Nurse's wagon was probably scum. I also have no clue why the hell Koba said this:

nurse be like, we can't have townies collaborating in this thread, you're all scum

When they were apparently SRing Drew?

if i had to gth solve rn - nurse/ircher/drew/wazza ? jury on anix is still out tho - hoping to see a development past trying to only purely talk mechs and discuss stances too.

VOTE: DkKoba

[DragonEater70]

For real for real.

[DragonEater70]

Also is anyone ever planning to vote Ircher or Drew? What's up with that?

[DragonEater70]

Also I better catch up on the last 10-20 pages, but that will be later.

[Ranger]

Where is the trolling and sly humor?

Here.

I didn't expect open wolfing such as this from you tbh

Funny, I didn't expect you to lie about my posts, tbh.

Funny, since you lied about mine....tbh.

Considering my iso has no commentary about your posts beyond calling disingenuous posts what they are, that'd be quite the feat. I'm fairly certain I've told no lies about your posts. You on the other hand are blatantly making things up about mine.

[Ranger]

Also is anyone ever planning to vote Ircher or Drew? What's up with that?

I'm likely never moving my vote off Doctor Drew, realistically speaking.

I

might

move to Theta Alpine or Cook.

I'm not going anywhere else, honestly.

[Ranger]

As a reminder; soonest I've the time and access would be about 12 hours from now.

As previously stated, I'm completely unavailable tomorrow. So if I can't find the time today, it'll be on Wednesday.


I'll say 1308 isn't quite true; I'd vote anyone I'd be okay with eliminating today, if need be. Since I don't want to vote Alisae and I only have four scumreads, those three are the players I'm okay eliminating rn. Obviously, this could change. For now, it hasn't.

[Ranger]

{DragonEater70, DKKoba}
{Bingle, AniX}
{Save The Dragons, Aureal}
{Random Nurse}
{KatyKimFanClub}
{Skygazer}
{camelCasedSnivy}
{Ircher}
{Alisae}
{Cook}
{Theta Alpine}
{Doctor Drew}

Random Nurse - Ircher tiers may be stale and need adjusting, will take a better look when properly catching up.

[DragonEater70]

Also is anyone ever planning to vote Ircher or Drew? What's up with that?

I'm likely never moving my vote off Doctor Drew, realistically speaking.

I

might

move to Theta Alpine or Cook.

I'm not going anywhere else, honestly.

Yeah I meant anyone besides you. There's like 2 votes on Dre and I think we're 16 players so am not sure what's up with the biggest wagon havobg 2 votes.

But I guess I can at least do my part.
VOTE: Drew

[DragonEater70]

Having*

[DragonEater70]

Is Jingle = JasonWazza btw? Cause I see jason ain't getting prodded for some reason and Jingle isn't on the playerlist.

[DkKoba]

404 -

435 - I don't think I agree with "this trait Town, this trait Scum." Game's more complex than that.

436 - This isn't a subtle signal to look at low-activity members, is it?

The arguing between Anix and Koba is legit giving me a headache.

450 - I'm opposed to massclaim because we lose the element of surprise and Scum will just lie about their roles.

499 -

+1

521 - How exactly?

534 - Activity. Is. Not. Indicative. Of. Alignment.

538 - Really? Seems opportunistic to me.

540 - Also opportunistic.

544 - Also opportunistic.

551 - I see you've got a similar posting style this game.

559 - Why this?

561 - What exactly is your reason for voting Koba?

566 - It does raise an eyebrow, to be honest.

593 - Someone gets it.

PROBABLY TOWN?

TOWNLEAN?

Aureal, Skygazer, AniX

NEED MORE INFO

Save The Dragons, DragonEater70, Ranger, Theta Alpine, KatyKimFanClub, Ircher, Bingle, camelCasedSnivy, JasonWazza

SCUMLEAN?

DkKoba, Alisae, Cook, Doctor Drew

PROBABLY SCUM?

And the reason I've got those four in Scumlean is because Koba's vote based on my first TWO posts is utter rubbish. I'm freaking busy, Bro. I'm on MY clock, not yours. And the three votes in rapid-succession after Koba's reeks of opportunism. Activity is not indicative of alignment, and you look like you're trying to jump on an easy target. Aureal seems like she's trying to solve the game, and her being wary does give off some Townvibes to me. Skygazer seems more Townish, actually understanding that a nurse might be extremely busy, instead of trying to use it as an opportunity to score an easy lim. AniX I've never played with before, but he does seem like he's trying to solve the game in his own way, which seems to be more in the mechanical sense. The others I haven't gotten enough information from either way to suss them out: again, I STRUGGLE during Day 1 in general because we have literally NOTHING.

I agree that at least one person on Nurse's wagon was probably scum. I also have no clue why the hell Koba said this:

nurse be like, we can't have townies collaborating in this thread, you're all scum

When they were apparently SRing Drew?

if i had to gth solve rn - nurse/ircher/drew/wazza ? jury on anix is still out tho - hoping to see a development past trying to only purely talk mechs and discuss stances too.

VOTE: DkKoba

I reevaluated bc my reason to find Drew town was bad when I dove their iso

[camelCasedSnivy]

Is Jingle = JasonWazza btw? Cause I see jason ain't getting prodded for some reason and Jingle isn't on the playerlist.

It was a Bingle altslip

[Doctor Drew]

Where is the trolling and sly humor?

Here.

I didn't expect open wolfing such as this from you tbh

Funny, I didn't expect you to lie about my posts, tbh.

Funny, since you lied about mine....tbh.

Considering my iso has no commentary about your posts beyond calling disingenuous posts what they are, that'd be quite the feat. I'm fairly certain I've told no lies about your posts. You on the other hand are blatantly making things up about mine.

Blatantly making things up about my posts is EXACTLY what you are doing.

[Bingle]

27 - this can be easily faked, so I'm indifferent to it. In general if there's a Miller claim should they be Role-Copped if there's one?

31 - I'm in the camp that thinks mass-claiming in general, early on, is usually not a good idea.

61 - Thing is, is her fakeclaiming as Town a reliable Towntell in current games?

Was that even what was said?

93 - *stares in confusion*

101 - OK why?

133 - PR hunting?

Why do you think so?

135 - I don't think I agree with fast responses earning Townleans. Wanna fight about it?

138 -

Caught up to 178. Not really getting any gut feels currently.

Just a heads-up: I really struggle on Day 1 because I've got no tangible evidence to work with, so the game starts for me on Day 2. Feel free to

pester

ask me about it.[/b]

Questioned some things in

this color

. Personally I feel like this post should robably be seen as scummy for basically havong no real opinions or reads expressed in it, but I did like Nurse's sincerity about not having reads (in green text) so I'm just slightly TRing this post.

General PSA, be careful when using alternative colors in your posts. The blue is unreadable on maf silver.

[Bingle]

Is Jingle = JasonWazza btw? Cause I see jason ain't getting prodded for some reason and Jingle isn't on the playerlist.

It was a Bingle altslip

Aye. Just in case anyone else is confused, Jingle is my main and I do things like setup reviews, modding, and MD from that account. Bingle is solely for playing the game of mafia.

[Bingle]

Where is the trolling and sly humor?

Here.

I didn't expect open wolfing such as this from you tbh

Funny, I didn't expect you to lie about my posts, tbh.

Funny, since you lied about mine....tbh.

Considering my iso has no commentary about your posts beyond calling disingenuous posts what they are, that'd be quite the feat. I'm fairly certain I've told no lies about your posts. You on the other hand are blatantly making things up about mine.

Blatantly making things up about my posts is EXACTLY what you are doing.

This he said/she said is anti town in that it’s just causing thread bloat. If you have actual posts that were lies point them out. If not, we get it you’re 1v1ing.

[Bingle]

Also is anyone ever planning to vote Ircher or Drew? What's up with that?

I'm likely never moving my vote off Doctor Drew, realistically speaking.

I

might

move to Theta Alpine or Cook.

I'm not going anywhere else, honestly.

Yeah I meant anyone besides you. There's like 2 votes on Dre and I think we're 16 players so am not sure what's up with the biggest wagon havobg 2 votes.

But I guess I can at least do my part.
VOTE: Drew

I don’t tend to vote at all in the midst of unresolved massclaim, but so far Koba is probably the best vote, mechanically speaking.

[Doctor Drew]

Where is the trolling and sly humor?

Here.

I didn't expect open wolfing such as this from you tbh

Funny, I didn't expect you to lie about my posts, tbh.

Funny, since you lied about mine....tbh.

Considering my iso has no commentary about your posts beyond calling disingenuous posts what they are, that'd be quite the feat. I'm fairly certain I've told no lies about your posts. You on the other hand are blatantly making things up about mine.

Blatantly making things up about my posts is EXACTLY what you are doing.

This he said/she said is anti town in that it’s just causing thread bloat. If you have actual posts that were lies point them out. If not, we get it you’re 1v1ing.

Gotcha my bad, just frustrated with her. Later on when I have time I will. Also still waiting for her to explain me being disingenuous.

[Bingle]

idk about bingles claim ngl

You don't know what about it? You think it's fake?

yea

Why? It’s actually pretty confirmable, I’d know it was pretty confirmable, and I was basically the first person to actually massclaim. I can understand thinking it looks like scum, but thinking it’s made up requires expecting me to be really bad at mechanics.

[camelCasedSnivy]

I can understand thinking it looks like scum

there you go

but thinking it’s made up requires expecting me to be really bad at mechanics.

how again?

[DragonEater70]

Is Jingle = JasonWazza btw? Cause I see jason ain't getting prodded for some reason and Jingle isn't on the playerlist.

It was a Bingle altslip

Ah. So what's up with JasonWazza?