Veiled Committee Mafia: List Mods Edition [game over]

[Cook]

are you suggesting a ranger push, drew

[Ranger]

Where is the trolling and sly humor?

Here.

[Doctor Drew]

are you suggesting a ranger push, drew

I am.

I just know she likes to get a bit cheeky as town, she isn't dumb by any stretch......but struggle to find the towny angle she has going on here.

VOTE: Ranger

But we should talk about this more in the PT Cook.

[Doctor Drew]

Where is the trolling and sly humor?

Here.

I didn't expect open wolfing such as this from you tbh

[Cook]

are you suggesting a ranger push, drew

I am.

I just know she likes to get a bit cheeky as town, she isn't dumb by any stretch......but struggle to find the towny angle she has going on here.

VOTE: Ranger

But we should talk about this more in the PT Cook.

if you've got the hood i'll bring the cookies

do you want a chef hat

[Doctor Drew]

are you suggesting a ranger push, drew

I am.

I just know she likes to get a bit cheeky as town, she isn't dumb by any stretch......but struggle to find the towny angle she has going on here.

VOTE: Ranger

But we should talk about this more in the PT Cook.

if you've got the hood i'll bring the cookies

do you want a chef hat

Unfortunately no hood, but i will take the hat!

[Theta Alpine]

yeah i would not expect to see any prelinked neighbors or such

[AniX]

I am happy to fully claim. I'd prefer not to do it if there is any interest in killing me to reveal game elements though, as to lock people into their roles BEFORE my game elements get revealed.

If there is no interest in this, I'll fullclaim gladly though.

[xyzzy]

votecount 1.07

oh, pog, this continental breakfast has grape nuts

3 players voting for Doctor Drew (Ranger, DkKoba, Random Nurse)
1 player voting for DkKoba (Ircher)
2 players voting for Bingle (Save The Dragons, camelCasedSnivy)
1 player voting for Random Nurse (KatyKimFanClub)
1 player voting for AniX (Alisae)
1 player voting for Alisae (Aureal)
1 player voting for camelCasedSnivy (Bingle)
1 player voting for Ircher (DragonEater70)
1 player voting for Theta Alpine (Cook)
1 player voting for DragonEater70 (AniX)
1 player voting for Ranger (Doctor Drew)

3 players not voting (JasonWazza, Theta Alpine, Skygazer)

with 17 votes, it takes 9 to eliminate.

mod notes: prodding Random Nurse.

[camelCasedSnivy]

pre game neighborizer trust

[Theta Alpine]

I am happy to fully claim. I'd prefer not to do it if there is any interest in killing me to reveal game elements though, as to lock people into their roles BEFORE my game elements get revealed.

If there is no interest in this, I'll fullclaim gladly though.

if rangers guess is correct then scum might have easy access to fake claims from the listmods in the unused town roles that were made

but we do not know that for sure so
i will let other people discuss

[Bingle]

Does deathstumpizer target and if you used it at night could you be tracked?

[Bingle]

It occurs to me only now I've made a mistake in promoting massclaim; I'm beginning to suspect the scum have access to a list of all the roles not used as fakeclaims. I don't think the listmods submitted roles providing nearly no benefit to scum as exclusively the pool of scum roles. The scum roles I'd expect would be roles providing tangible benefit to scum, yet not explicitly only scum. (Think roleblocker, rolecop. Arson fits this as an example. Most claims don't.)

No?

The case you're describing (where scum has a massive amount of extra setup information to the tune of 7 potential roles) actually gives us more incentive to claim. Scum would be able to guess the rough shape of the opposing forces from the unused roles, but we would be playing largely in the dark. Doing this forces them to commit to fakeclaims before their knowledge base becomes even larger than it already is in that case.

The downside is almost certainly in the potential for redirection style roles if it exists, where our investigations and vigs can be sent to twiddle their thumbs in uselessness and shame.

[Bingle]

If there is no interest in this, I'll fullclaim gladly though.

It seems like a very not a good idea to me.

[Bingle]

Drew, how do you feel about me saying you feel like the fire game but with less oomph?

[Ranger]

Where is the trolling and sly humor?

Here.

I didn't expect open wolfing such as this from you tbh

Funny, I didn't expect you to lie about my posts, tbh.

[Theta Alpine]

i would assume i can be tracked yeah

though
my ability does have a time component to when it can be used so it might not actually be playing by normal phase rules

as in it might resolve immediately on being sent even if i send it at night
rather then being resolved at day start if i use it at night


hmmm maybe i should ask the mod then
that might actually prevent me from being redirected or such as well

[Theta Alpine]

though desperate in this situation only becomes an investigative ability if we have a janitor so

[Theta Alpine]

or i guess uh
i can target koba if they get limmed if we had any doubts there about alignment
i currently do not suspect that will be needed though

[Cook]

yeah koba is pretty much town in my book

[KatyKimFanClub]

It occurs to me only now I've made a mistake in promoting massclaim; I'm beginning to suspect the scum have access to a list of all the roles not used as fakeclaims. I don't think the listmods submitted roles providing nearly no benefit to scum as exclusively the pool of scum roles. The scum roles I'd expect would be roles providing tangible benefit to scum, yet not explicitly only scum. (Think roleblocker, rolecop. Arson fits this as an example. Most claims don't.)

No?

The case you're describing (where scum has a massive amount of extra setup information to the tune of 7 potential roles) actually gives us more incentive to claim. Scum would be able to guess the rough shape of the opposing forces from the unused roles, but we would be playing largely in the dark. Doing this forces them to commit to fakeclaims before their knowledge base becomes even larger than it already is in that case.

The downside is almost certainly in the potential for redirection style roles if it exists, where our investigations and vigs can be sent to twiddle their thumbs in uselessness and shame.

I also doubt we were going to win a setup where scum have a list of possible town roles.

[Cook]

typically you need a counterbalancing thing for that

[Cook]

maybe that factor's in the unclaimed roles

[DragonEater70]

btw I have yet to form a read on Nurse, I saw they made some catchup posts earlier. I will look at them some time later today.
cya all later.

Just quoting this post so I know where I need to start my catchup from as I take a deep dive into some ISOs

[Cook]

have fun