Xyl's Relative Chaos - Game over!

[Xylthixlm]

Vote Count

DrippingGoofball -

4

(Vi, DoomCow, dahill1, Natirasha)
tubby216 -

3

(SpyreX, ZazieR, CoheedCambria09)
DoomCow -

2

(hasdgfas, tubby216)
dahill1 -

2

(animorpherv1, DrippingGoofball)
CoheedCambria09 -

1

(Korts)
Korts -

1

(Crazy)

Not voting: MafiaSSK, farside22

With 15 alive, it will take 8 to lynch. The deadline for day 1 will be Saturday, December 6.

Prods have been sent out.

[hasdgfas]

and yet you're voting for dahill even though he made perfectly clear that you were one of his suspects. Why?

What, you think there's only one scum in this game?

no, it's that I think you're voting for dahill based off of a false premise. What about dahill makes you think he's a better place for your vote than tubby?

has, do you think you're vote on DoomCow is well placed at the moment, and if so, why?

Yes. DoomCow hasn't done anything in terms of moving the game forward. He'll come in and say something, but not give much reasoning behind it. First off, there was the vote for tubby saying that he "didn't like the last post of his". He's not really saying anything there. Voting Vi for the obviously fake PR is also bad, especially ditching it quickly and going right back to tubby.

Also note the end of post 179, where he says there's nothing to analyze on Day 1. I'd like to hear an explanation for that. There is no pro-town reason I can think of that can explain why posting some analysis on Day 1 is bad.

[dahill1]

Yes. DoomCow hasn't done anything in terms of moving the game forward. He'll come in and say something, but not give much reasoning behind it. First off, there was the vote for tubby saying that he "didn't like the last post of his". He's not really saying anything there. Voting Vi for the obviously fake PR is also bad, especially ditching it quickly and going right back to tubby.

Also note the end of post 179, where he says there's nothing to analyze on Day 1. I'd like to hear an explanation for that. There is no pro-town reason I can think of that can explain why posting some analysis on Day 1 is bad.

fair enough. didn't even see that last point you made so thanks for putting that out there

[tubby216]

i'm sorry i was away emergancy tripp,, give me a few to catch up

[MafiaSSK]

Sorry for not reading before I posted that. I was low on time.

[ZazieR]

Mod-Did you mean that or do you post that in every prod?

Back ontopic.

I've seen DoomCow posting like that. But I don't like the votehops and the reasons used for them.

CC should explain why he voted and it would be nice if he could give his thoughts about the other players.

Natirasha, Can you give us some quotes why you see your number 1 as most scumiest? If it has to do with gut, just quote this post.

I still don't know if Korts actually meant the attack against Tubby or not. When I looked over his posts, they seemed like he really saw him as scummy. But you never know what Korts will do in his games.

SSK, I'm waiting on your PBPA. But perhaps you could give a PBPA of the player you see as scummiest.

[CoheedCambria09]

Zaz, I didn;t really have a reason for voting, thats why in the post that held the tubby vote it said something along the lines of, so to be chaotic. I voted on the person with the largest bandwagon. Pretty much it. I have to pay more attention to this game and then more posts will be coming.

[tubby216]

i'm still a lil lost here,

but DGB, did u want a wagon on u for disscussion purposes?

wat is the case on DGB??

spyrex is there anything you would like me to answer?? or would you rater just see me lynched??


doomcow, thank you for your explin ation thats all i wanted,,

unvote

mafia ssk still waiting for your pbp i would guess its coming soon??

to all i appologize i wasn't expecting to have to leave for three days

vote U S Army

for lack of notice wit their gawd damn orders and their infinate exersices in futility,,,,

unvote

[DrippingGoofball]

I change my mind. Tubby is town.

[Korts]

I owe this game some attention and a big post. Unfortunately I also owe the chemistry department the minutes of some experiment for tomorrow. The weekend, I promise, will go towards catching up with this game among others.

[DoomCow]

First off, there was the vote for tubby saying that he "didn't like the last post of his". He's not really saying anything there.

Actually, I'm saying there that I think that post (the vote for crazy defending Tubby) is giving me an anti-town vibe. That plus the suspicion he allready had was enough for me to vote (and keep voting for now) him.

Voting Vi for the obviously fake PR is also bad, especially ditching it quickly and going right back to tubby.

I've defended myself enough from this. fake pr is lying to town and thus anti town. No matter what reasoning it might be. The vote switch back was because Vi admitted to having a fake pr in post 51. Still not liking it, but willing to go with it for now.

Also note the end of post 179, where he says there's nothing to analyze on Day 1. I'd like to hear an explanation for that. There is no pro-town reason I can think of that can explain why posting some analysis on Day 1 is bad.

I'm not saying that posting analysis on day 1 is bad, I'm just saying I won't do any analysis on day 1. Since I like some reference to go by.

And yes, been prodded...

[farside22]

Hi all. I took the day off to catch up on sleep. Just letting you know I didn't forget about you.

[animorpherv1]

Hi all. I took the day off to catch up on sleep. Just letting you know I didn't forget about you.

I abstain from posting untill farside rereads.

[Korts]

Hi all. I took the day off to catch up on sleep. Just letting you know I didn't forget about you.

I abstain from posting untill farside rereads.

Whoa. and since when have you been contributing more than farside?

[hasdgfas]

Hi all. I took the day off to catch up on sleep. Just letting you know I didn't forget about you.

I abstain from posting untill farside rereads.

A) This is a post
B) You need to contribute more than farside does anyway

[Natirasha]

A bad newb move that the only recourse is negative for the town is a bad newb scum move still.

I seriously did. Not a newb tell this time.

Looks like Tubby's the main suspcious person. Will get working on a PBPA of him.

? If it has to do with gut, just quote this post.

[dahill1]

Zaz, I didn;t really have a reason for voting, thats why in the post that held the tubby vote it said something along the lines of, so to be chaotic. I voted on the person with the largest bandwagon. Pretty much it. I have to pay more attention to this game and then more posts will be coming.

unvote vote CC

this post made me want to switch my vote back
i can't see how people aren't voting for CC after reading that

[dahill1]

Voting Vi for the obviously fake PR is also bad, especially ditching it quickly and going right back to tubby.

I've defended myself enough from this. fake pr is lying to town and thus anti town. No matter what reasoning it might be. The vote switch back was because Vi admitted to having a fake pr in post 51. Still not liking it, but willing to go with it for now.

is it scummy though?

I'm not saying that posting analysis on day 1 is bad, I'm just saying I won't do any analysis on day 1. Since I like some reference to go by.

what do you mean by this? wouldn't a Day 1 analysis give you even better of a reference?

Hi all. I took the day off to catch up on sleep. Just letting you know I didn't forget about you.

I abstain from posting untill farside rereads.

why? also you haven't been posting that much anyway and this seems like an excuse to not post even more.

FoS: animorph

gaaah..so many scummy people in this game!! i wish i was like a quadruple voter!

SSK, are you done with the reread yet? seriously, it's been awhile and you still haven't made a PBPA like you said

[Vi]

Hi all. I took the day off to catch up on sleep. Just letting you know I didn't forget about you.

I abstain from posting untill farside rereads.

Whoa. and since when have you been contributing more than farside?

Justified burn, ohhhh~

-----

@Natirasha: I see what you're getting at. *adds SSK to my list of people not to forget*

-----

gaaah..so many scummy people in this game!!

this

i wish i was like a quadruple voter!

You set your sights too low. I always want to be an unlimited dayvig

[farside22]

Hi all. I took the day off to catch up on sleep. Just letting you know I didn't forget about you.

I abstain from posting untill farside rereads.

I didn't even know you were in the game.
Tomorrow no holds bar comments will be made.
DGB hows' the BW going since last we spoke?

[Vi]

Unvote: DrippingGoofball

Vote: farside22

(L-7)
Go on, keep pushing that reread back.

[farside22]

Unvote: DrippingGoofball

Vote: farside22

(L-7)
Go on, keep pushing that reread back.

Can I? That would be awesome. Oh wait you are being sarcastic.
Your voting for me for being behind? That's weird.

[hasdgfas]

Unvote: DrippingGoofball

Vote: farside22

(L-7)
Go on, keep pushing that reread back.

This is a terrible vote. Please explain.

[farside22]

Pages 1- 6

Start of the game everyone starts with votes against people.
Korts: Post 9 what do you mean too much filth comment?
Korts: Post 13 why point this out?
tubby: Post 18 why would you think never mind state this comment?
Korts: Post 19 how is that role fishing?
Korts: Post 22. I don't see it.
Korts: Post 23 then why bring it up in the first place?
CC: Post 29 no random vote? Why unvote what does your vote mean if it just sits there?
cc post 31: Why worry what or who the vote is for at this point? This just doensn't make sense.
(I can see why Korts saw CC and not the others. CC was the last one to post and just unvote.
SpyreX: Post 44 Korts brought up the comment in the first place. He is almost asking people to speculate.
Tubby: Post 47 I really don't like the fact that he regurgates the same thing that Crazy just stated 2 post back.
Kort: Post 52 I agree. Enough said.
CC: Post 56 how about a reason why with that vote.
spyrex: Post 57 seems like jumping the gun because of one comment. Jumping on scum tells early is scummy.
(still don't understand how Zazie figured out Nat's code there. I'm missing it)
Crazy: post 64: It is my experinece the newb scum follow people because they have no clue what else to do.
animoph: Post 67 is the computer fixed? If so explain vote on Crazy.
tubby : post 76 although scum do this I really have a bad taste in my mouth with the more following someone else lead here.
TheInternet: Post 77: What? Is there a post restriction or something I missed that causes you this confusion?
animophr: Post 79 please try again and use quotes this time on what you are talking about.
doomcow: Post 81: retype or better reasoning. The post and reason's sloppy.
doomcow: Post 88: No, just no. If scum wanted to fake a PR they would keep it up.
doomcow: post 90 I roll my eyes
mafiassk: post 102 why would Vi be modkill for having fun?
animohp: Post 106 lets try and scum hunt at this point. K?
Crazy : post 107 Newbie scum clueless more then newbie town. Follows those who make sense to look more town. Easiest thing for scum newbs that don't know any better do.
tubby: Post 108 I have to love the poker annology. Try reading things and come up with what you note looks scummy instead of following what others say are scummy.
theinternet: post 120 well if you don't like that case who do you see as scummy (wait dahil replaced right?)
SpreX: post 121 I really don't think Tubby was PR hunting.
DGB: Post 122 out of everything going on why focus on a fake PR?
spryx: post 128: Oh come on did that actually happen? Did anyone say oh yea maybe it is power roles. (fluff)
tubby: post 136 please read the game and make points on each person and what they say or don't say that looks scummy.
DBG: Post 137 really day one silliness doesn't have in the first 2 pages in any game you have been in right?
zazie post 140: I really don't see what you brought up is a case against Tubby. It seems very weak reason
Tubby: post 143 I couple of people called out Korts so don't act like its all against you. Meh I say you tried but it is far reaching conclusion case on Korts in my view.
Korts: post 144: Why SpreX and not Doomcow?

[farside22]

By the way cow after seeing you do your reviews like this I have to say it is much easier way to do it then what I did before.