Pages 5-Current
Post 105 - Vi: Can you see Korts's vote from his perspective and how he may feel it's justified?
Post 107 - Crazy: Woah, the "he's a newbie" defense. Also, you may do certain things as scum, but that doesn't mean everyone does the same. Can he not be newbie scum?
Post 108 - tubby: Ah, I see now. tubby, if you made a big case with reasoning against Korts, it would not be considered OMGUS(by me at least), because it's a case. Not just voting for them. This post seems sincere to me.
Post 122 - DGB: Anything else?
Post 127 - Vi: Aw, thanks. I appreciate it. Didn't know I had that kind of reputation.
Post 135 - SSK: Why do you not play games that you've signed up for?
Post 136 - tubby: Ok, this looks a bit bad after pressure has slightly lessened up on you, now you're not talking. I'm not a big fan of this.
Post 137 - DGB: Maybe, but have they done anything else scummy? After all, both were obviously fake PRs.
Post 143 - tubby: If you're town, why are you putting the hypothetical out there that says "if I flip scum"?
Post 144 - Korts: ALERT! ALERT! PAGE ARGUMENT SIGHTED!
Post 149 - DoomCow: Wow, what a wonderful noncommital post.
Post 151 - DoomCow: Why do you think he's the option?
Post 159 - Korts: No, we can totally talk about it here, since we can't talk about it out of game. Why push this conversation to the side when it could have bearing on the game?
Post 162 - Internet: Can you please post something regarding the game?
Post 166 - Crazy: I think it's perfectly valid. Why don't you?
Post 167 - Crazy: This is blatant WIFOM. Scum could totally do something scummy so people claim it's too scummy to be scum.
Post 170 - DGB: I don't believe not scumhunting is a town tell.
Thoughts:
DBG needs to actually scumhunt instead of pretending to. Slight scumminess at this point.
SSK needs to post or be replaced. I'd prefer the latter. neutral.
Crazy feels off to me. I also think his defense of tubby is a little bit too strong. Medium Scumminess
DoomCow: Hasn't posted any analysis. Just information. I(and tarhalindur) find that scummy. High scumminess.
spyrex: I don't know about him. May need to reread him.
CC: Needs to post more. I haven't seen much from him.
Korts: Seems a bit off to me, especially that page argument from him in post 144. I really didn't like that.
zazier seems really quiet to me. I've seen her post more often than this. Why haven't you said much?
morph: The fake PR just seems like it was there because Vi did it. He also hasn't given any contribution to the game, but has posted enough that it doesn't look like he's lurking. Explanation for his vote on Crazy seems like distancing. High scumminess.
vote: DoomCow
FoS: morph, Crazy