Mini 697: Prisoner's Dilemma Mafia {Game Over!}

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Welcome to Mini 697: Prisoner's Dilemma Mafia

Current Game Status: Game Over! Go to page 16 starting with Post 375 for ending and postgame.

Still could be imprisoned and interrogated

The Central Scrutinizer (replacing humscunter D1)
springlullaby
Seraphim
orangepenguin
Knight of Cydonia (replacing DragonsofSummer N2)
icemanE
RedCoyote

Killed in one way or another

Crazy, Protown Vanilla Townie, killed Night 1

Albert B. Rampage, Protown FBI Agent, killed Night 2
TonyMontana, Protown Vanilla Townie, killed Night 2
CarnCarn, Protown Vanilla Townie, executed Day 3

SlySly, Mafia Goon, executed Day 3

Notable Game Milestones

Prison Count #1
Prison Count #2
Prison Count #3
Prison Count #4
Prison Count #5 and End of Day 1
Start of Day 2
Prison Count #6
Prison Count #7
Prison Count #8
Prison Count #9
Prison Count #10
Prison Count #11 and End of Day 2
Start of Day 3
Prison Count #12
Prison Count #13
Prison Count #14 and End of Day 3

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

MM’s Rules (Stolen and Modified from Mr. Flay):

• Votes should be in bold for them to count, like this:
  Send: MM
  . Unvotes should likewise be bolded (
  Unsend: MM
  ) so that I can spot them easier
• Nights usually will last up to 72 hours, but may be shorter or longer depending on circumstances.
• Dead men tell no tales. If you get killed, stop talking until the game is over.
• Do not discuss this game with other players outside of this thread, unless your role PM specifically stated you could do so.
• Do not directly quote any PMs you receive; this holds true for any future messages you receive from me as well.
• If you see something you don't understand,
  ASK!
  If you have any questions feel free to PM me directly.
• I will prod players for being inactive for over 72 hours, and then possibly replace at my discretion.
• Treat this game as a commitment; if you're going to be gone for a significant period of time,
  let us know
  . I will replace severely inactive players, but your fellow players may choose to lynch you themselves first.
• Any action which would be illegal to
  actually do
  is also illegal to
  fake
  (for example, posting a
  made-up
  PM that shows a Cop result of guilty/innocent).
• Have fun; don't be an ass;
  participate
  !
• All my decisions are final. I also reserve the power to modify the rules when needed.

You are a vanilla townie. You only have the power to vote to send people to prison each day. You win with the town when all antitown forces are eliminated.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

[mrow]Prisoner's Dilemma[col]Player X Says No[col]Player X Says YesPlayer Y Says No[col]Both X and Y chooses one of these: daycop investigation, doc protection (may self-protect), 50% daykill next day.[col]X gets double vote next day and chooses one of either daycop investigation, doc protection (may self-protect), or next-day Prisoner Immunity. Y executed instantaneouslyPlayer Y Says Yes[col]X executed instantaneously. Y gets double vote next day and chooses one of either daycop investigation, doc protection (may self-protect), or next-day Prisoner Immunity.[col]X and Y play sudden-death rock-paper-scissors. Loser is executed instantaneously and winner survives. If tied, both are executed instantaneously.

Special Rules (add “unless specified otherwise” to end of each rule):

1. Each day lasts maximum 3 weeks.
2. Each player has two votes to vote on two different players to be sent to prison. Both votes cannot be used on same player. Players should use the tags

Send: MM

and

Unsend: MM

. I will reluctantly accept bolded votes and unvotes.
3. At end of each day, whichever two players has the most votes gets sent to prison for interrogation during the night. If a majority of votes is reached for two players before deadline, the day ends early. Tiebreaker is whoever reached a certain number of votes first.
4. While in prison, the two players will be asked the question: “Is the other player mafia?” The results are shown above.
5. While imprisoned, those players cannot target others and cannot be targeted by others.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

All roles have now been sent. The game will now move into the Pregame Phase. Players may post to confirm and talk about anything not game-related. Day 1 will begin approximately 48 hours from this post.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Oh man, sorry mod missed that.

Do you have a copy of what I posted though, because I'll be loath to retype all that.

Sorry as soon as I read the first couple of sentences in that post I edited out the whole thing.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

I count 12 confirms... can we start yet?

Day 1 will start in approximately 2 hours, just a little more patience

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

It is now officially Day 1!

With 12 alive, a majority would be 7.

The day will end at 6:30PM Eastern on Tuesday, November 18th, 2008.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #1

3 - CarnCarn (humscunter, Seraphim, CarnCarn)
2 - humscunter (TonyMontana, icemanE)

1 - TonyMontana (orangepenguin)
1 - springlullaby (CarnCarn)

Not Yet Voted:

TonyMontana (1)
Crazy (2)
Albert B. Rampage (2)
humscunter (1)
springlullaby (2)
Seraphim (1)
SlySly (2)
orangepenguin (1)
DragonsofSummer (2)
icemanE (1)
RedCoyote (2)

Remember the majority is 7 and the deadline is 6:30PM Eastern November 18th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Mod: Are there scum NKs?

Worth a shot.

I neither confirm nor deny whether there are scum NKs.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Mod: Is the doc protect benefit choice applicable for day, night or both?

The doc protection bonus from those PD scenarios can only be used during the night.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #2

4 - springlullaby (Seraphim, humscunter, SlySly, orangepenguin)
3 - TonyMontana (orangepenguin, RedCoyote, TonyMontana)
3 - Crazy (RedCoyote, DragonsofSummer, icemanE)

2 - orangepenguin (DragonsofSummer, icemanE)
1 - CarnCarn (Seraphim)
1 - Albert B. Rampage (TonyMontana)

Not Yet Voted:

Crazy (2)
Albert B. Rampage (2)
humscunter (1)
springlullaby (2)
SlySly (1)
CarnCarn (2)

Remember the majority is 7 and the deadline is 6:30PM Eastern November 18th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

mod-question: Is the "lynch" sealed on a person once we reach a majority on them, or can cotes be retracted as long as 2 people haven't reached majority?

The day only ends when there are two players who have reached majority at that time. So player X could have 8 votes and the next highest vote-getter could have 5 votes and the day would still continue, with voting and unvoting still available for everyone.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #3

6 - TonyMontana (orangepenguin, RedCoyote, TonyMontana, Crazy, CarnCarn, springlullaby)
5 - Crazy (RedCoyote, DragonsofSummer, icemanE, Crazy, Seraphim)
4 - orangepenguin (DragonsofSummer, icemanE, Seraphim, orangepenguin)

2 - springlullaby (humscunter, SlySly)
2 - Albert B. Rampage (TonyMontana, CarnCarn)
1 - humscunter (springlullaby)

Not Yet Voted:

Albert B. Rampage (2)
humscunter (1)
SlySly (1)

Remember the majority is 7 and the deadline is 6:30PM Eastern November 18th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Activity check - Those that could be prodded soon: DragonsofSummer, SlySly, Seraphim, Crazy

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #4

7 - Crazy (RedCoyote, DragonsofSummer, icemanE, Crazy, Seraphim, orangepenguin, CarnCarn)
4 - orangepenguin (DragonsofSummer, Seraphim, orangepenguin, springlullaby)

3 - TonyMontana (RedCoyote, Crazy, SlySly)
3 - springlullaby (humscunter, SlySly, springlullaby)
2 - SlySly (icemanE, CarnCarn)
1 - humscunter (TonyMontana)
1 - icemanE (TonyMontana)

Not Yet Voted:

Albert B. Rampage (2)
humscunter (1)

Remember the majority is 7 and the deadline is 6:30PM Eastern November 18th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Not Yet Voted:
Albert B. Rampage (2)
humscunter (1)

What does this mean? ABR has 2 votes?

ABR has 2 votes that have not been used yet.
humscunter has 1 vote that has not been used yet.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Activity check - DragonsofSummer has been prodded for inactivity of over 72 hours.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #5

7 - Crazy (RedCoyote, DragonsofSummer, icemanE, Crazy, Seraphim, orangepenguin, CarnCarn)
7 - orangepenguin (DragonsofSummer, Seraphim, orangepenguin, springlullaby, icemanE, Crazy, CarnCarn)

3 - springlullaby (humscunter, SlySly, springlullaby)
2 - TonyMontana (RedCoyote, SlySly)
1 - humscunter (TonyMontana)
1 - icemanE (TonyMontana)

Not Yet Voted:

Albert B. Rampage (2)
humscunter (1)

Remember the majority is 7 and the deadline is 6:30PM Eastern November 18th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Day 1 is over. The prisoners for tonight are

Crazy and orangepenguin

.

It is now Night 1. All choices are due 8:30PM Eastern Tuesday, November 4th, 2008 (U.S. Election Day). Any late choices could be subject to nullification or randomization.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Everyone wakes up and gathers at the center of town to start another day of discussing which two people should be sent to prison.

The Police Chief shows up as well and announces, "There has been a break-in last night at the prison. An unidentified suspect broke through various levels of security and managed to kill Crazy in one of the interrogation rooms. Nobody else was hurt. Orangepenguin was released from prison without completing the interrogation process."

He adds, "Well everyone, time for you to get back to work!"

Crazy, Protown Vanilla Townie, killed Night 1

It is now Day 2. With 11 alive, 6 is the majority! The deadline is 4:00PM Eastern on Monday, November 24th, 2008.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

5. While imprisoned, those players cannot target others and cannot be targeted by others.

I really don't think the mod would lie to us, despite what the Police Chief claims to have happened.

Mod: Did you lie to us?

^^Eh, we'll see where this goes^^

Note the "unless otherwise specified" clause in the parentheses after Special Rules.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #6

4 - SlySly (CarnCarn, springlullaby, TonyMontana, RedCoyote)
3 - orangepenguin (icemanE, orangepenguin, TonyMontana)

2 - springlullaby (icemanE, orangepenguin)
1 - Seraphim (CarnCarn)
1 - DragonsofSummer (springlullaby)
1 - CarnCarn (RedCoyote)

Not Yet Voted:

Albert B. Rampage (2)
humscunter (2)
Seraphim (2)
SlySly (2)
DragonsofSummer (2)

Remember the majority is 6 and the deadline is 4PM Eastern November 24th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #7

6 - orangepenguin (icemanE, orangepenguin, TonyMontana, DragonsofSummer, Seraphim, Albert B. Rampage)
5 - SlySly (CarnCarn, springlullaby, TonyMontana, RedCoyote, DragonsofSummer)
4 - springlullaby (icemanE, orangepenguin, Seraphim, Albert B. Rampage)

1 - Seraphim (CarnCarn)
1 - DragonsofSummer (springlullaby)
1 - CarnCarn (RedCoyote)

Not Yet Voted:

humscunter (2)
SlySly (2)

Remember the majority is 6 and the deadline is 4PM Eastern November 24th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #8

4 - orangepenguin (orangepenguin, TonyMontana, DragonsofSummer, Seraphim)
4 - SlySly (springlullaby, TonyMontana, DragonsofSummer, CarnCarn)
4 - CarnCarn (RedCoyote, SlySly, orangepenguin, Albert B. Rampage)

2 - springlullaby (Seraphim, SlySly)
1 - DragonsofSummer (springlullaby)
1 - Albert B. Rampage (RedCoyote)
1 - RedCoyote (CarnCarn)

Not Yet Voted:

humscunter (2)
Albert B. Rampage (1)
icemanE (2)

Remember the majority is 6 and the deadline is 4PM Eastern November 24th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

humscunter has been prodded for not yet posting since the start of Day 2.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Activity check:

Could be prodded soon: Seraphim

Could be replaced soon: humscunter

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #9

4 - orangepenguin (orangepenguin, TonyMontana, Seraphim, icemanE)
4 - SlySly (TonyMontana, DragonsofSummer, CarnCarn, icemanE)
4 - CarnCarn (RedCoyote, SlySly, orangepenguin, Albert B. Rampage)

2 - springlullaby (Seraphim, SlySly)
1 - Albert B. Rampage (RedCoyote)
1 - RedCoyote (CarnCarn)

Not Yet Voted:

humscunter (2)
Albert B. Rampage (1)
DragonsofSummer (1)
springlullaby (2)

Remember the majority is 6 and the deadline is 4PM Eastern November 24th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

[bMod:[/b]

...gets double vote next day...

Does this mean the player will get 4 votes, or does each of their 2 votes count double?

The latter is correct. Each of their 2 votes will count double.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

orangepenguin has been prodded for inactivity of over 72 hours.

I'm currently still searching for replacement for humscunter.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

The Central Scrutinizer replaces humscunter. Effective immediately. Let's welcome TCS to the game!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Albert B. Rampage, RedCoyote, springlullaby, and DragonsofSummer have been prodded for over 72 hours of inactivity.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Mod:
Rule 5 specify that while imprisoned, players can't be targeted by another.
Have you lied? Or are there exception to that rule?

I have not lied. The "unless specified otherwise" clause opens possibilities to exceptions to that rule and all other Special Rules.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #10

5 - SlySly (TonyMontana, DragonsofSummer, CarnCarn, icemanE, orangepenguin)
5 - CarnCarn (RedCoyote, SlySly, orangepenguin, Albert B. Rampage, TonyMontana)

2 - orangepenguin (Seraphim, CarnCarn)
2 - springlullaby (Seraphim, SlySly)
1 - Albert B. Rampage (RedCoyote)
1 - The Central Scrutinizer (Albert B. Rampage)

Not Yet Voted:

The Central Scrutinizer (2)
DragonsofSummer (1)
springlullaby (2)
icemanE (1)

Remember the majority is 6 and the deadline is 4PM Eastern November 24th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Mod: Are interrogation choices publicly revealed? e.g., if someone answers yes while the other answers no, is this published?

Cannot answer right now, but the next morning scene may shed some more light.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #11

6 - SlySly (TonyMontana, DragonsofSummer, CarnCarn, icemanE, orangepenguin, Albert B. Rampage)
6 - CarnCarn (RedCoyote, SlySly, orangepenguin, Albert B. Rampage, TonyMontana, icemanE)

2 - orangepenguin (Seraphim, CarnCarn)
2 - springlullaby (Seraphim, SlySly)
1 - Albert B. Rampage (RedCoyote)

Not Yet Voted:

The Central Scrutinizer (2)
DragonsofSummer (1)
springlullaby (2)

Remember the majority is 6 and the deadline is 4PM Eastern November 24th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Day 2 is over. The prisoners for tonight are

SlySly and CarnCarn

.

It is now Night 2. All choices are due 8:30PM Eastern Thursday, November 13th, 2008. Any late choices could be subject to nullification or randomization.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

DragonsofSummer notified me that he will have extremely limited access, so...

Knight of Cydonia replaces DragonsofSummer.

Let's welcome Knight of Cydonia to the game!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

The sun rises again as everyone goes back to the center of town for a third day debating which two people should be sent to prison. Except this time,

a lot

less number of people shows up...

The Police Chief is also present and announces, "The interrogation process resulted in both prisoners saying that the other is mafia. So we went to the rock-paper-scissors death match method earlier this morning. Both prisoners threw down scissors, which is a tie. Hence both have been executed."

He continues to say, "Last night there were also two people found dead at their respective houses. One was Albert B. Rampage and the other was TonyMontana. autopsy reports showed that ABR was killed by pistol fire while TM was killed by sniper fire."

He concludes, "Well everyone, time for you to get back to work!"

Albert B. Rampage, Protown FBI Agent, killed Night 2
TonyMontana, Protown Vanilla Townie, killed Night 2
CarnCarn, Protown Vanilla Townie, executed Day 3

SlySly, Mafia Goon, executed Day 3

You are an FBI agent. Once in the game, anytime during any day you may capture two players of your choice to be put into the Prisoner’s Dilemma via PM. The same special rules will apply to those prisoners as the prisoners being interrogated at night. The capturing will be publicly announced but your identity will not. The game will temporarily stop during the interrogation phase and the day will resume afterwards.

It is now Day 3. With 7 alive, 4 is the majority! The deadline is 5:00PM Eastern on Thursday, December 4th, 2008.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

orangepenguin has been prodded for not yet posting during Day 3

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #12

2 - Seraphim (Seraphim, RedCoyote)

Not Yet Voted:

The Central Scrutinizer (2)
Knight of Cydonia (2)
springlullaby (2)
icemanE (2)
orangepenguin (2)
Seraphim (1)
RedCoyote (1)

Remember the majority is 4 and the deadline is 5PM Eastern December 4th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #13

4 - Seraphim (Seraphim, RedCoyote, Knight of Cydonia, icemanE)
2 - icemanE (Knight of Cydonia, orangepenguin)

1 - springlullaby (RedCoyote)

Not Yet Voted:

The Central Scrutinizer (2)
springlullaby (2)
icemanE (1)
orangepenguin (1)
Seraphim (1)

Remember the majority is 4 and the deadline is 5PM Eastern December 4th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Prison Count #14

5 - Seraphim (Seraphim, RedCoyote, Knight of Cydonia, icemanE, orangepenguin)
4 - icemanE (Knight of Cydonia, orangepenguin, icemanE, Seraphim)

1 - springlullaby (RedCoyote)

Not Yet Voted:

The Central Scrutinizer (2)
springlullaby (2)

Remember the majority is 4 and the deadline is 5PM Eastern December 4th!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Day 3 is over. The prisoners for tonight are

Seraphim and icemanE

.

It is now Night 3. All choices are due 9:00AM Eastern Friday, November 21st, 2008. Any late choices could be subject to nullification or randomization.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

The sun seems to be shining much brighter on this 4th day, perhaps an omen to something great awaits the 4 people still present at the town center.

The Police Chief is back and says, "The interrogation process again resulted in both prisoners saying that the other is mafia. So we went to the rock-paper-scissors death match method again earlier this morning. Again both prisoners threw down scissors, which is a tie. Hence both have been executed."

He continues to say, "Last night there were also one person found dead in a neighborhood near the prison. The victim was orangepenguin. Autopsy reports showed that OP was killed by by sniper fire."

He concludes, "Well everyone, all evidence suggests that all evil forces have been eradicated here. Obviously I deserve all the credit..."

"Just kidding! It was all you guys!"

orangepenguin, Protown Master Interrogator, killed Night 3

Seraphim, Mafia Goon, executed Day 4
icemanE, Mafia Godfather, executed Day 4

The Central Scrutinizer, Protown Vanilla Townie, survives
springlullaby, Protown Vanilla Townie, survives
RedCoyote, Protown Vanilla Townie, survives
Knight of Cydonia, Protown 2-shot vigilante with 1-shot bulletproof vest, survives

Town wins!

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

SlySly, Seraphim, icemanE:

You 3 are the mafia group. icemanE is the Godfather and is immune to cop investigations. SlySly and Seraphim are Goons. Your group has the following abilities:

- Communicate to each other during nights and in the 48-hour pre-game period. This quicktopic thread below is recommended for doing so. A member in prison may not submit new messages, but may look at the quicktopic thread.

http://www.quicktopic.com/42/H/AEQDRXUsTLYg

- 3 nightkills - You only have 3 nightkills for the entire game. You may only use one nightkill per night. Any member not imprisoned may send in the nightkill.

- 1 Prison Escape Kit – If one of the group members is in prison, this may be used to avoid Prisoner’s Dilemma interrogation. If used the other player in prison would also be freed. The prison escape event and the prison escapist identity will be announced publicly the next day.

- 1 Prison Break-in Kit – This can be used one night to break into the prison and kill on one of the prisoners. This kill does not count towards the 3-nightkill-limit and you may use this kit and a nightkill on the same night. The other prisoner would be freed. The break-in will be publicly announced the next day, but not the identity of the break-in person.

- 1 Police Chief Imposter Kit – The group may use this on one of its members to become the sole decider of who gets sent to prison for the next day. So this is kind of like the king in a kingmaker game. You may use this for Day 1 if you PM me about your decision before the 48-hour pregame period is over.

Hint that might be helpful: there are fakeclaims available with these abilities.
You win with the mafia when all non-mafia forces are eliminated.

Please confirm on the game thread by clicking here. If you have any questions, please ask via PM.

DragonsofSummer

You are a 2-shot vigilante with a one-shot bulletproof vest. During each night, you may choose to use one shot to kill a target. You only have two total shots, so use them wisely. You are also protected from the first killer targetting you, but any kill targets afterwards will kill you.
You win with the town when all antitown forces are eliminated.
Please confirm on the game thread by clicking here. If you have any questions, please ask via PM.

Albert B. Rampage

You are an FBI agent. Once in the game, anytime during any day you may capture two players of your choice to be put into the Prisoner’s Dilemma via PM. The same special rules will apply to those prisoners as the prisoners being interrogated at night. The capturing will be publicly announced but your identity will not. The game will temporarily stop during the interrogation phase and the day will resume afterwards.
You win with the town when all antitown forces are eliminated.
Please confirm on the game thread by clicking here. If you have any questions, please ask via PM.

orangepenguin:

You are a master interrogator. Once during the game, you may use your amazing interrogation and brainwashing abilities to get whatever answers you want out of two prisoners in a Prisoner's Dilemma. So if you want both prisoners to survive, PM me "both X and Y say no", if you want one dead and one get abilities, PM me "X says yes Y says no", etc. If you are imprisoned, you may still use your ability.
You win with the town when all antitown forces are eliminated.

Please confirm on the game thread by clicking here. If you have any questions, please ask via PM.

humscunter; RedCoyote; Crazy; springlullaby; TonyMontana; CarnCarn:
You are a vanilla townie. You only have the power to vote to send people to prison each day.
You win with the town when all antitown forces are eliminated.

Please confirm on the game thread by clicking here. If you have any questions, please ask via PM.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Choices:

Night 1:
Crazy says "No"
orangepenguin uses ability, makes both himself and Crazy say "No", action nullified by Prison Break-in and ability returned to orangepenguin.
Seraphim uses nightkill #1 on DragonsofSummer. DoS bulletproof vest prevents the kill.
SlySly does Prison Break-in and kills Crazy

Night 2:
CarnCarn says "Yes"
SlySly says "Yes"
CarnCarn throws scissors
SlySly throws scissors
Seraphim uses nightkill #2 on TonyMontana
Knight of Cydonia uses shot #1 on Albert B. Rampage

Night 3:
orangepenguin uses ability to make icemanE and Seraphim say "Yes"
icemanE says "No", then manipulated by orangepenguin to say "Yes"
Seraphim says "No", then manipulated by orangepenguin to say "Yes"
icemanE throws scissors
Seraphim throws scissors
Knight of Cydonia uses shot #2 on orangepenguin
icemanE intends to use Super Police Chief kit on himself, this never materializes

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

CarnCarn asked me about sending two scum to prison (which I gave a non-answer response) and repeatly mentioned his speculation about it in this game. In the end CarnCarn was indeed onto something as orangepenguin used his ability in the perfect situation and resulted in the ideal scenario for the town.

That's my initial thoughts, I'll have more in the next couple of days.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Some more thoughts on the game:

The PD scenarios:
I wanted to make the scenarios such that a yes-no combination yields {100% guaranteed death, better reward}, a no-no combination yields {lesser reward, lesser reward}, and a yes-yes combination yields {lesser punishment, lesser punishment}. I had a difficult time deciding what to make the "lesser punishment", and in the end decided to make it so that it was 66.7% death for both prisoners, and 0% if both were scum and coordinated beforehand. I also considered the town-scum prisoner combo and made the "no" option more appealing to scum by having the "lesser reward" be almost as good, if not better, than the "better reward" because of the daykill.
If anyone has good ideas to improve the PD scenarios, I'd love to see it.

Setup:
I thought overall it was pretty balanced given the difficulty to balance a game like this. The town had the huge disadvantage of being very uninformed, but had 3 very powerful roles to balance it. The scum had huge advantages of being informed and having tools to escape death and manipulate the town, but was limited by the 3 nightkills.

Game Strategy:
Before the game I thought each side had an ideal strategy that would them good chances for victory:
Town - Nail 1 scum in a regular PD scenario or ABR's scenario, Nail 1 scum with vig kill, Nail 1 scum with orangepenguin's ability
Scum - Confuse and manipulate the town early with the break in and super police chief kits, start using nightkills on Night 2, save escape kit in endgame just in case.

General:
I enjoyed reading and modding the game. Great play all around. I was also pleased with the activity, it was moving so fast that the game finished in only a month! I will definitely consider running a larger theme game with a similar mechanic in the future.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

I have started working on the large theme game. Look for it in the near future!