Obv. Email him and tell him so.nonny wrote:also winslow should have that hat on in the comic lol
Scum usually have a pre-game discussion to plan strategy and the like, and I'm assuming this game was no different. If Lord Gurgi was scum with Mariyta and farside22 do you not think they would have planned this "Miller claim" strategy out? Do you think Mariyta was being earnest when she said she's "not familiar enough with the miller role to make a call" or do you think it was part of a pre-game discussion act?Mariyta, [b][url=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=1161148#1161148]in her Post 60[/url][/b], wrote:A) I like Steel Magnolias. It always makes me cry.
B) I'm not familiar enough with the miller role to make a call on whether Lord Gurgi is lying or not.
C)Vote Nonnybecause it's my God-given right.
So far the games I have played here, millers do know they are millers. However I just don't get why LG claimed so early. There was no need or pressure for such a claim
I'm just curious can you show me where the discusion on this was? I think I can think of the reason why claiming this early is good. I just wonder what was said exactly on this.
Farside was the first one to be really skeptical of the claim, and question it. Mirth asked for a counter claim which i saw as a joke, vivan asked if millers even knew they were millers.It seemed like there was likes of back and forth on the issue. Some people talk about when during the day to claim and others say it sets up for scum claiming it to save themselves.
However with the poster of uncle sam I feel like that would be something a person would see if they were recruiter. You know the army poster that says Uncle Sam wants you
Why? I feel the best thing to do with a miller claim is ignore it, it's all WIFOM. Why did you feel it so special that everyone must acknowledge it? You did that same thing with the request to be vig'd. You want everyone to know it. So either you just like the attention, or you think these actions make you look pro-town and want every one to comment on it and hopefully remember it.LG wrote: I certainly hope so Falcone, I'm suspicious of anyone who would ignore my claim, Why Faerie Lord though?
So his voting of farside started with a seemingly random joke vote? And he just kept on it because she didn't believe his claim and almost nothing else. When day 2 came we was back on like fire IIRC after falcone had already revoted per his reasons day1, LG mimic'd this but had no real strong reasons. Falcone had a whole case he brought back, LG even said "wow i agree fully with his case, it's better than mine"(paraphrasing, to lazy to look up direct quote) So I don't think LG gets any credit for farside being lynched as scum. I see it as perhaps distancing, busing, and planned. I now have no doubt in my mind.LG wrote:Vote: Farside22 Why are you man-hating so much? You have a kid!
Well...it's odd, and I have no idea WHY they'd bus a godfather so early, but I can't ignore the posts I've seen. Mari more likely had that response prepared, but I can't be sure since there was so little from her! Obviously if Gurgi IS scum then it would be more likely scripted :S. Is it possible they didn't talk this over first maybe? And honestly, why go after farside with no reasoning, claim there WAS reasoning, and be all "oops, my bad" and put together a little paragraph of random things about farside? I admit I don't feel good about what you dug up, but I don't feel good about leaving him alive given what I observed :S. And to me, it's really a toss up between Viv and Gurgi, favoring Gurgi :S.forbiddanlight, can you please respond to my Post 819? I realize you did a PBPA of Gurgi and everything but what do you think of the logic I used to gather that Lord Gurgi is likely innocent here? Also, what do you think of the early interactions between Gurgi, farside22, and Mariyta when Lord Gurgi claimed Miller? In particular, what do you think of this post:
I am working on this, I just had some free time after you posted the mariyta part found it interseting wanted to review what happened during the claim more. Once I get free time(most likely tomorrow mid morning after class) I will review vivian.incog wrote: I'd still like nonny to comment on Vivian as well
......IGMEOYI'd like more from Vivian, and I'd still like nonny to comment on Vivian as wellbefore anyone even thinks about hammering LG. I think Vivian was going to go more in-depth with stuff too, so I'd like to see that as well.
I was hoping to get some sort of reaction from Gurgi. If he's scum he didn't bite the bait, and if he's town, then he really is a Miller.elvis_knits wrote:2) All votes must be in bold. Like this:vote:rajrhcpfreakIf you plan on changing your vote, you mustunvotefirst. Otherwise I will not count your vote.
Heh. I still like a Vivian lynch.Lord Gurgi wrote:....What.
I hate you so much right now.
It's called a gambit. I sent a message to e_k mod to let her know that I did that purposely so if she did log on before Gurgi responded, she wouldn't count it.nonny wrote:That was a very stupid thing to do.....some mods would count it regardless of that stipulation.
Interesting. Well, we can't be sure Gurgi is not scum. Anywhere from observing that to being the kind of player who keeps you hanging to flip. But it was an interesting attempt :S.
It's called a gambit. I sent a message to e_k mod to let her know that I did that purposely so if she did log on before Gurgi responded, she wouldn't count it.
Like Farside and the self hammer.forbiddanlight wrote:Interesting. Well, we can't be sure Gurgi is not scum. Anywhere from observing that to being
It's called a gambit. I sent a message to e_k mod to let her know that I did that purposely so if she did log on before Gurgi responded, she wouldn't count it.the kind of player who keeps you hanging to flip. But it was an interesting attempt :S.
I don't think we are currently under a deadline. What's your rush?But yeah, what do we do now? We have to lynch someone.