Ok.
Well, at least we know Jebus and Zone are town. And now that two lesser roles are claimed out of the way, I think its safe to assume that anyone else trying to claim a minor recurring role should be scrutinized greatly.
So, looking back, thinking about it, I'm gonna go back to who I originally thought was scummy before anyone else, CallMeLiam. He said a few undermining things that really alerted my scumdar big time.
Liam wrote:I picked up the breadcrumb in that very first post of yours, and while I think it's a bit early to be claiming characters it's entirely possible that a Klingon could be pro or anti- town in this game. Not everyone who seems to be Klingon will necessarily be so, as I'm sure Martok can attest.
Here he is, trying to claim that Martok and Worf might not be town aligned, which is quite preposterous. And if he was a fan of the show, which he claimed, he would know that. Very scummy.
Liam wrote:I am, yes. The point is that when our villains are shapeshifters it's entirely possible that any of the cast can be scum
Now he's trying to drill home the changeling-paranoia factor, which would completely undermine town attempts and discerning claims, and would just make things very difficult if we're always assuming anyone could be a shapeshifter at any time. Personally, I think if there are shapeshifters, it'll be a nightaction, not some automatic role assumption before the game starts. Paranoia and confusion - thats what he's trying to instill in us, being the first to mention it and claiming several times he will not be taking roleclaims into consideration.
Liam wrote:Jebus, my vote was random but you're not doing anything that makes me want to remove it. It's way way too early to be talking about claims (Tim, this applies to you too) especially when (as previously mentioned) any character could be on either side. Hell, even Rom could be with the Dominion.
Even Rom could be with the Dominion? Are you kidding? Why would a shapeshifter impersonate ROM? Puh-lease. Here he is again, d1, trying to drill home more confusion tactics by saying that anyone could be with the dominion.
Liam wrote: To be honest I'd have no problem with D1 mass CC just to get it out of the way. Since I can't think of a DS9 character without a logical power role I also believe it wouldn't be too harmful for the town.
Here he is suggesting a d1 massclaim. Did anyone else notice this at the time? I think a d1 massclaim would be extremely foolish for the town. I cant believe I let that slide at the time. I think Light-kun noticed it too. Also, not a fan of metagaming.
So, that is why I'm going to
Vote: Liam