Might also be worth it to have a look at what Mariyta (dead Vagina hater) had to say about the other players.
PBPA: Mariyta
Post 60: Mentions that she can't make a call on Lord Gurgi's claim. Arbitrarily? votes nonny.
Post 90: Nothing.
Post 95: Filler.
Post 97: Responds to Lord Gurgi's pushing for answers to Mirth's question about LG's Miller claim. "Personally, you don't feel scummy to me."
Post 121: Mirth rocks <3. She placed a vote on Mariyta and wondered why Mariyta didn't even bother to respond to her vote.
Post 123: Again, nothing much. Just responding to Mirth.
Post 130: No substance again. She responds to farside22 though about the miller claim after farside votes for her and concludes with a joke to her.
Post 154: Another pretty terrible post that says absolutely nothing. Considers herself "a sheep".
Post 175: Noise.
Post 214: Mentions she gets town vibes from Mirth and ThAdmiral (both known town).
Post 240: Yay! A post about her feelings about people.
Mariyta wrote:Vivian
: I think the reason I felt she was scummy was an OMGUS thing. Seems to have a thing with clocks and ticking.
Mariyta (on known town) wrote:Darla
: She's never really serious about much. She's very non-committal (says the pot to the kettle).
Mariyta (on town) wrote:Spacecase
: Claimed Falcone was running the show, but looking at the posts, Falcone has posted very little in comparison to some others. Posts see fairly non-committal in most cases, trying to post just enough to seem helpful (sounds like me). Does the same thing Darla does with saying he'd vote LG, but gets no flack. Kept the male icon, even though men are icky.
Mariyta (on today's lynch) wrote:Farside
: Missed the difference between recruiter and recruit, even posted "recruit" in one of her posts; this could be a slightly scummy move, depending on how you look at it. Totally overreacted to Darla, but didn't say a word to Spacecase for doing the same thing; opportunistic vote, maybe? Spelled my name right, so that's a plus.
Mariyta (on claimed vig) wrote:FaerieLord
: Seems to have disappeared, very little contribution (oh, wait... me again.)
Mariyta wrote:xyzzy
: Um, yeah... two posts. Needs to be replaced.
Mariyta on LG (claimed Miller), nonny, Mirth (known town), Falcone (known town), ThAdmiral (known town) wrote:The rest of the people come across as pro-town to me, or else I don't get a good enough read to make anything of it.
She concludes with a vote for Spacecase (me).
Post 241: Immediately switches vote to FL. "Something just gnaws at me as scum trying to hide".
Post 244: Mentions she's still cool with her FL vote. Her next post she calls it "gut". Mirth questions her about whether it's right to lynch someone based on just gut. She says something like "welp, it's not the lynching vote now is it?"
Post 270: Mentions she doesn't like Spacecase (me) and says she gets a "meh" feeling about Falcone.
Post 286: Still cool with an FL lynch.
Post 296: FL correctly calls her out on that kettle, pot, black stuff. She agrees and says "at least she's trying". lol.
Post 300: Comments on Spacecase's (my) mason claim. Mentions partner should not come forward. Next post she says she's heard of this type of role before and quickly mentions that there's still a question of alignment.
Post 378: Gives her top three: FaerieLord, Spacecase (me), and Darla.
This actually makes me feel really good about FL.
Post 405: Switches vote to Darla.
Post 444: Questions Falcone's farside22 vote asking "if he had reasons before this?"
Seriously, he was only at farside22's neck for like the whole of Day 1.
Mentions she would like to hear from me.
Diverting attention from farside?
And nothing for the rest of Day 2 besides mentioning she thought ThAdmiral seemed townish.
I questioned her about this read because it didn't look like she even looked at my ThAdmiral-case. Her ThAdmiral town read looked somewhat contrived.
The Living's Thoughts on Mariyta
farside22
: After pushing pretty hard on DBE for the beginning of Day 1, farside22 ended up switching her vote to Mariyta in
Post 129 thereby adding a second vote in the face of Mirth's Mariyta pressure. She kept her vote there up until
Post 228 but didn't really push Mariyta in between the time that she placed her vote and her switch in vote. In fact, in post 228, she says a few bad things about Mariyta, mentions that her contribution is still bad but still chooses to switch her vote to DBE. She also chose to FoS xyzzy for only making two posts? Why not FoS Mariyta if you still had a problem with her? After that, she doesn't mention a thing about Mariyta for the rest of the day or in day 2.
Scummy for this and a myriad of other reasons. Today's lynch lol.
FaerieLord
: He first mentions Mariyta in
Post 265 listing her in his "scummy-ish" category. He goes on a number of times after that to reaffirm his Mariyta suspicions mentioning that he'd rather pursue a case on her during Day 2 because the deadline was too close to get a wagon switch and to test to see if her playstyle really does change from Day 1 and beyond. He's since claimed vig, he's claimed Mariyta as his kill, and so unless he's actually an SK or something, I'd say he's super vagina-ish.
Town.
forbiddanlight
: forbiddanlight actually mentioned a number of negative things about Mariyta in her game summaries. This portion in particular gives me a really good vibe about forbiddanlight actually:
forbiddanlight, in her 348, wrote:xyzzy: Post 171: OMG I said that!? Ugh, what the hell were you thinking!? Mariyta isn't pro town popping to say she has no opinion. That's SCUMMY! I'm sorry, but let it be known I EMPATHICALLY disagree with this, lol.
She genuinely seemed pissed about xyzzy's idea that Mariyta seemed pro-town. Her contribution to this game and heavy amount of scum-hunting leads me to believe she's definitely pro-vagina here. (plus she had good taste with the farside22-wagon and well... we were wrong about ThAdmiral but it sure felt right didn't it?)
Town.
Lord Gurgi
: Lord Gurgi actually included both Mariyta and farside22 in his scum list early in Day 1. He never gets around to vote for her but does seem to push her a few times throughout the day. At the end of the day, he includes Spacecase (me), farside22, and DBE on his condorcet list. And actually, now that I read this, why would you list DBE
and
farside22 on the same list? What would have been the hypothetical relationship between a farside22-scum and a DBE-scum? He's claimed miller since early on which is somewhat of a shady claim. Because of that, I'd have to list him as
Neutral leaning slightly town.
nonny
: I don't really see much mentioning of Mariyta from nonny during Day 1. She mentions that she agrees with a Mirth-post that mentions she's happy with her Mariyta-vote. She also mentions that Mariyta's play seems atypical from what she's used to from a previous game but at the end
of this post she only FoS's Spacecase (me) and DBE. nonny, why no Mariyta votes or FoS's despite mentioning her play seems off and agreeing with Mirth's thoughts on Mariyta? Also gives me silly flak for mentioning that I was happy with Mariyta's death. Silly, nonny.
Neutral leaning scummy.
Vivian Darkblaam
: NabNab kept on mentioning that "clock is ticking" stuff with respect to Mariyta throughout Day 1. He-she questioned Falcone about an opinions post that failed to include Mariyta also. I never saw any indication from this Russian cross-dresser of an FoS or vote in her direction though. Then again, he-she never did much FoS-ing or voting throughout Day 1 or Day 2. He-she directly opposed condorcet so he-she never provided a list to summarize his-her feelings. He-she also had negative comments about my predecessor's claim (mentioning it sounds cult-ish) but since I've replaced, he-she hasn't really given me much flak or questioned me further about it. Hmm. His-her early FoS of Falcone also seemed really off (an FoS for having a vollkan-like quality?).
Neutral to scummy.
Oh and what do we have so far?
Mirth - Tampon Doc
DBE - Vagina Townie
ThAdmiral - Vagina Townie
Falcone - Boob Mason
Mariyta - Vagina-Haters Mafia Goon
Incognito - Boob Mason
nonny - ???
farside22 - ???
forbiddanlight - ???
Vivian Darkblaam - ???
Lord Gurgi - Claimed Douchebag (Miller)
FaerieLord - Claimed Vigilante
I'd actually go out and venture a guess that we likely don't have anymore power roles with a Mason pair, a Doctor, a claimed Vig, and a claimed Miller so of the remaining townies, I'd probably think the rest are Vagina. So yeah, still very cool with a farside lynch.
Sorry for the verbosity.
