Mini Normal 2174 | Korean Pop Music | Mafia Wins!

[Trendall]

But then why also have Hopkirk then make up a thing about doctor enabler to protect derp? Like if they're both lying that's probably not sustainable so it's a waste of two mafia members.

If derp is mafia but then Hopkirk is actually a real doctor enabler then that is just a weird coincidence I guess.

But it seems more likely to me that they're both telling the truth.

[Trendall]

people were already unvoting the moment plus claimed. Plus would not have died had derp not cc'ed. But I also feel like its a huge gambit for scum to take.

Who else could town have conceivably got enough votes on though? Like I think most of the end of day one is ppl complaining that there are not enough ppl online.

[Noraa]

people were already unvoting the moment plus claimed. Plus would not have died had derp not cc'ed. But I also feel like its a huge gambit for scum to take.

to elaborate on this, think about it: what are the chances of mafia and town both having a doc? basically zero. So, derp being scum doc and plus being town doc is ruled out.
if derp is scum,
what are the chances of mafia goon(im assuming) cc'ing doc?
there are two cases:
enabler is town, the doc(goon) is scum. the chances of having two town docs without an enabler is ZERO. how would scum know town had an enabler to save them unless they were planning a 1v1 tradeoff but like why TF would u do that day 2? from scum perspective, 1 scum DNE 1 town.

enabler is scum, doc(goon) is scum. this is a huge gambit. If either flips red, the other is instantly dead. I highly doubt this is a gambit scums are willing to do.

Im more willing to believe that derp is town and hoppy is also town. This case makes the most sense.
Technically, a derp town, plus town, hoppy scum is possible but I think I like my TR on hoppy so eh.

[Noraa]

Uh so I fried my brain writing the above post. If it doesnt make sense, yeah sorry. It fried my brain over a few times thinking about it so .... yeah

[Noraa]

people were already unvoting the moment plus claimed. Plus would not have died had derp not cc'ed. But I also feel like its a huge gambit for scum to take.

Who else could town have conceivably got enough votes on though? Like I think most of the end of day one is ppl complaining that there are not enough ppl online.

honestly with how disconnected town was, we might've gotten a no lim. But I highly doubt plus would've died if derp didnt cc

[JohnnyFarrar]

dear derp is also having a really difficult time solving flubber

derp read ur iso but there isnt really much to think about it. i suppose it feels a bit like u are sheeping some reads but that doesnt necessarily mean ure a dirty scum
im getting the impression u still believe trendall is scum, so could u give ur good friend derp ur read on trendall?

Town and scum doc happens.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Dunno why that quoted

[nopointinactingup]

It's really convenient for you to say what you'd have done at end of day NP when you hadn't been online for 60 hours and were sitting on wagon that was clearly going nowhere. That way you aren't on the lethal (or there's no lethal) and you can claim you thought whatever you wanted at the time without having had to have done it. We lethaled 2 hours before deadline, where were you the two and a half days before that?

Anyone 'town' who didn't bother checking in the 24h before the lethal doesn't deserve to survive. This includes Flubber/NP and is part of my sus.

Well I did show up before the deadline only to find the lynch had gone through, though I'm sure 2 hours before the deadline was an overstatement .. though I concede the timing issue made it pretty difficult to lynch anyone else. It's been sometime since I'm playing forum mafia again and I'm trying to fit the game in my weekly schedule. I just want to get across that if you are town-aligned, getting a doc lynched when you can prevent it is a terrible play.

Johnny, while you're here, thoughts on my theory?

Idk I'm more inclined to believe they're both scum than believe hopkirk scum outs himself for no reason instead of just letting derp swing here

This case is also possible, just very unlikely given derp's cc timing to the Plus claim. For one, a D1 scum cc really doesn't happen a lot. Also, scum would have to coordinate in that 30 minute instance for things like that to happen.

I could also vote nopo. I felt like he and I were on the same page at the start of today and then this hopkirk back and forth happened

Do you think I'm scum for disagreeing with you or Hop? because that's terrible.

Im going to sit on my Staarling and Keita SRs. If y'all are right and nopo is scum, I will allow you to say "I told you, you dumb dumb" to me once, tomorrow.

This is town. I can absolutely see Nora-scum jumping on my wagon at this point.

Noraa's posts feel very towny today. Derp's posts feel towny too but the CC is my hangup and I don't want to let that wagon go. Who is willing to lim derp today?

Who is against it?

I've never seen two town doctors in a set-up so I'm not against the idea, but we've already lost a PR so I would really prefer a good lynch today instead of a policy lynch that could go wrong. What do you think of the Johnny, Trendall, Starling slots?

[nopointinactingup]

TSC is likely town atm.
Starling is a tough read even with an ISO, mainly because I don't know hectic.
@Mod: Do we have a prod or replace for Keita?

[JacksonVirgo]

VC 2.3

nopointinactingup (3)

- Hopkirk, JohnnyFarrar, Trendall

Noraa (2)

- nopointinactingup, Staarling

derp (1)

- Glitch

Staarling (1)

- Noraa

Hopkirk (1)

- nopointinactingup

JohnnyFarrar (1)

- The Slime Collective

Trendall (1)

- Flubbernugget

Not Voting (2)

- Keita, derp

It takes 6 votes to hammer, meaning nopointinactingup is on E-3

Deadline:

(expired on 2020-11-14 17:40:00)

Mod Notes:

• Keita has been prodded!

MODDDDDDDDD

, could u pls update 1st post with slimey gang

Donerino

[Noraa]

This is town. I can absolutely see Nora-scum jumping on my wagon at this point.

Lovely that you finally decided to read me correctly but you're just gunna leave ur vote there?

[Keita]

Hey, sorry for inactivity. Don’t really know why we’re keeping this slot around. VOTE: Staarling

[Noraa]

Hey, sorry for inactivity. Don’t really know why we’re keeping this slot around. VOTE: Staarling

what what what?

[Keita]

Hey, sorry for inactivity. Don’t really know why we’re keeping this slot around. VOTE: Staarling

what what what?

Since they’re probably not who they say they are, any attempt to read them will be pretty much impossible in practice.

[Noraa]

Thats all you have? After 38 pages the only SR you can suggest is a PL?

[Keita]

Thats all you have? After 38 pages the only SR you can suggest is a PL?

What else am I supposed to do? I don’t feel confident in any other slot in this game. I am not good at making and explaining reads.
I just think this slot is not good for town to have in the game.

[Noraa]

I.......

[JohnnyFarrar]

Do you think I'm scum for disagreeing with you or Hop? because that's terrible.

Nah i sr you for our interactions d1.

[Flubbernugget]

I think there's been enough talk about the claims. I don't think there's a full picture yet

[JohnnyFarrar]

What u thinking flubsy. All this focus on nopo and hopkirk has stalled the game methinks

[The Slime Collective]

I fail to see how is nopointinactingup scummy.
He is active, post reads, interacts. When he pushed Hopkirk he didn't hard tunnel: he posted read about our slot and Noraa. This is a very unscummy thing to do.
-Green Slime

[Flubbernugget]

I could also vote nopo. I felt like he and I were on the same page at the start of today and then this hopkirk back and forth happened

What didn't you like about the back and forth, johnny?

[JohnnyFarrar]

It feels... idk stretchy? I don't think they're on the right track and I don't see how they can really believe it

[Glitch]

Hey, sorry for inactivity. Don’t really know why we’re keeping this slot around. VOTE: Staarling

Oh wow there went any TL

I'd vote there today

[Glitch]

There being Keita