I'm think that at least one hero is scum. I also feel the same about people with posting restrictions.ZONEACE wrote:yeah, I don't think comic alignment is indicative of game alignment.
Does anyone else agree?
Mini 638 - Batman Mafia - Prozacmod 1 - Over
-
-
Inspector Godot Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 185
- Joined: June 21, 2008
- Location: Australia
First of all, sorry about the previous post. I accidentally submitted it before typing anything. Feel free to delete it.
-
-
DarlaBlueEyes Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1615
- Joined: April 13, 2008
- Location: Texas
tehhheehhheeehheeehheeeheeeeheeehheeeCrub wrote:Ooops sorry, didn't realise this game had started.
Randomvote: DarlaBlueEyes
well this game is certainly a blast from the past =D
Howdy there crub.
I would also like to point out that, if we just looked at this logically we would see that the heroes must be the mafia. All of us are in Arkham. Meaning that the general masses are 'villains'. Justifying the assumption that to us, the villains of Arkham, the majority, those working against us must be the "heroes'. Obviously this isn't a given in a game of mafia, but we shouldn't lynch based on character. Keeping in mind that in many games <see X-men mafia> its a mix, where someone, say Storm is mafia. Even so I like to believe in my mind that the Bat will be evil, but perhaps I'm just biased. Revenge will be ours occupants of Arkham!!
HEhehehehHEHhehehhehEHhehehHEhehEhheHeheheShowyou done goofed.
Il Sarcastro (3:40:26 AM): Hitler doesn't like the Beatles
Il Sarcastro (3:40:30 AM): And that's what makes him Hitler-
-
Singing Librarian Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 226
- Joined: January 13, 2008
- Location: England
-
-
charter Beware of Dog
- Beware of Dog
- Beware of Dog
- Posts: 9261
- Joined: July 12, 2007
- Location: Virginia
-
-
kloud1516 Executioner
- Executioner
- Executioner
- Posts: 700
- Joined: May 27, 2008
I didn't say it would be impossible for the heroes to be scum, I just said I did not believe that would happen, for the game would be too easy. I am not going to cast aside any theory yet, for it is still early in the game and there are many possibilities. I think the idea of the scum being a mixture of heroes and villains makes more sense (for right now that is).ZONEACE wrote:Its entirely possible that the heroe's are scum, 3 scum in a mini is not unstandard.
I'm not the only one that thinks this am I? I mean, it would seem reasonable for for the 3 heroes to be scum and have been given false claims AND PRs.-
-
Inspector Godot Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 185
- Joined: June 21, 2008
- Location: Australia
Logic. Having all three heroes as pro-town would seem too obvious, as would having them all scum. So at least one hero is scum in my eyes. And having everyone that has a posting restriction as either all pro-town or all mafia doesn't seem right either. Should I put an OMGUS vote on you?charter wrote:vote Inspectot Godot
My feline sense wonders how you're so sure the scum must have posting restrictions and at least one is a hero. Once again, what makes you so sure?-
-
charter Beware of Dog
- Beware of Dog
- Beware of Dog
- Posts: 9261
- Joined: July 12, 2007
- Location: Virginia
Whether or not all three heroes are scum or protown is WIFOM. Go ahead and vote me, you're just going to get clawed for it.Inspector Godot wrote:
Logic. Having all three heroes as pro-town would seem too obvious, as would having them all scum. So at least one hero is scum in my eyes. And having everyone that has a posting restriction as either all pro-town or all mafia doesn't seem right either. Should I put an OMGUS vote on you?charter wrote:vote Inspectot Godot
My feline sense wonders how you're so sure the scum must have posting restrictions and at least one is a hero. Once again, what makes you so sure?-
-
pwnz Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 414
- Joined: September 6, 2004
- Location: Sunnyvale
Here are my personal observations on each of the players with apparent posting quirks. I'm not sure if this will be extremely useful or not, but maybe someone who knows about Batman more then I do might be able to pick up on something.
Grimmy - No pattern that I can detect
kloud1516 - No pattern that I can detect
One thing about kloud1516 that perked my interest was this statement, which leads me to believe that he might in fact be the famous Dr. Arkham.
Singing Librarian - No pattern that I can detectI am in agreement with the cat that has been traipsing through my laboratory
Inspector Godot - No pattern that I can detect
The only thing worth mentioning is in his first post, which reminds me of Mr. Freeze.
Crub - Not enough posting infoHello everyone. It's so c-c-cold down here right now that I feel sorry for all the little animals outside, be they a dog, a caterpillar or a bird
Flameaxe - Not enough posting info
Seems to be associated with Batman's sidekick, Robin.
The only other thing that I can detect is that he has used an exclamation mark in every one of his posts.Holy vase batman!Holy "random" votes, Batman!
ZONEACE - Has asked a question in every single one of his posts. Similar to Flameaxe except instead of exclamation marks this time it is question marks.Praise the lord, for he is our savior!does anyone else like the color green?wait, what are we talking about now?
charter - Has a reference to cats in each of his posts. Catwoman?Does anyone else agree?I love pink catsShould we massclaim our characters? I've got a few of them down from the cat-firmation stage
Albert B. Rampage - Joker-esque postsOOps, had a little cat-astrophe in my last post, won't happen again. SorryGoOd EveNinG LadIeS and GENtle MeN....HyahaahahahaA little fight in ya. I like that.
DarlaBlueEyes - Laughs at seemingly random intervals, seems to be liked to the Riddler. No other pattern that I can detect.I agree that the nasty bat and his friends are obviously the killers, we should weed them out and enact our revenge.AhAhahahAHahAHahHAhahhahahAHAhaWell this IS the question now isn't it
KingEnigma - Seems to have some sort of a speech impediment or posting restriction linked with his spelling. Group has speculated that he may be the Ventriloquist.dude, wrong game, this is Gatman, I mean gatman....this could ge a proglem.
Last but not least, just to be fair:we are talking agout how some people have speech impediments, which is insulting I don't have a speech impediment, lets go find those gad guys!
pwnz - No pattern that I can detect
None of this is definitive, but I figured that I might as well share.-
-
Inspector Godot Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 185
- Joined: June 21, 2008
- Location: Australia
Entirely unintentional on my part.pwnz wrote: Inspector Godot - No pattern that I can detect
The only thing worth mentioning is in his first post, which reminds me of Mr. Freeze.
WIFOM? Of course it is, that's why I think it's a mix of heroes and villains, normal posters and those without restrictions. Speculation never hurt anyone and if you're worried and/or petty enough to place a vote due to it then I'll take the lift down to your level.charter wrote:
Whether or not all three heroes are scum or protown is WIFOM. Go ahead and vote me, you're just going to get clawed for it.Inspector Godot wrote:
Logic. Having all three heroes as pro-town would seem too obvious, as would having them all scum. So at least one hero is scum in my eyes. And having everyone that has a posting restriction as either all pro-town or all mafia doesn't seem right either. Should I put an OMGUS vote on you?charter wrote:vote Inspectot Godot
My feline sense wonders how you're so sure the scum must have posting restrictions and at least one is a hero. Once again, what makes you so sure?
Vote Charter-
-
ZONEACE There's no F in ZONEFACE
- There's no F in ZONEFACE
- There's no F in ZONEFACE
- Posts: 4548
- Joined: November 10, 2003
- Location: Harlem NYC
-
-
DarlaBlueEyes Mafia Scum
-
-
Porochaz Oh, Prozac
- Oh, Prozac
- Oh, Prozac
- Posts: 9317
- Joined: September 6, 2007
-
-
Grimmy Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1429
- Joined: May 14, 2008
- Location: NYC
Probably Scarecrow. I think this was said by someone else.pwnz wrote:kloud1516 - No pattern that I can detect
One thing about kloud1516 that perked my interest was this statement, which leads me to believe that he might in fact be the famous Dr. Arkham.I am in agreement with the cat that has been traipsing through my laboratory
Thats OLD SCHOOL robin stuff. he may be Nightwing, who was the first robin.
Flameaxe - Not enough posting info
Seems to be associated with Batman's sidekick, Robin.
The only other thing that I can detect is that he has used an exclamation mark in every one of his posts.Holy vase batman!Holy "random" votes, Batman!Praise the lord, for he is our savior!
This would be the RiddlerZONEACE - Has asked a question in every single one of his posts. Similar to Flameaxe except instead of exclamation marks this time it is question marks.does anyone else like the color green?wait, what are we talking about now?Does anyone else agree?
Again, OLD SCHOOL catwoman (By Old school, I mean the old TV show)charter - Has a reference to cats in each of his posts. Catwoman?I love pink catsShould we massclaim our characters? I've got a few of them down from the cat-firmation stageOOps, had a little cat-astrophe in my last post, won't happen again. Sorry
BOTH of these can be alluded to the Joker, so we may be able to add HARLEY QUINN to the group, but which one? I dunno.Albert B. Rampage - Joker-esque postsGoOd EveNinG LadIeS and GENtle MeN....HyahaahahahaA little fight in ya. I like that.
DarlaBlueEyes - Laughs at seemingly random intervals, seems to be liked to the Riddler. No other pattern that I can detect.I agree that the nasty bat and his friends are obviously the killers, we should weed them out and enact our revenge.AhAhahahAHahAHahHAhahhahahAHAhaWell this IS the question now isn't it
just adding my 2 cents to this post.
Grimmy
has change comingShowv/la on weekend until further notice.
Rishi wrote:
Of course, Grimmy never seems to leave the random stage - even on like Day 3. And he seems to do okay.
Grimm "Bruce" Lee - I-will-punch-you-in-the-SHIRT!-
-
kloud1516 Executioner
- Executioner
- Executioner
- Posts: 700
- Joined: May 27, 2008
I agree with both pwnz's and Grimmy's observations here, and I can see the evidence suggesting that both the Joker and Harley Quinn are in the game. I find it interesting that we still haven't suggested anyone stands out as possibly being the big bad Bat himself, for we have 4 pages to go on here. I haven't seen anything that suggests who could be the Bat, but then again I haven't been looking as hard as I could be. I am going to do a reread and maybe I will find something.Grimmy wrote:
Probably Scarecrow. I think this was said by someone else.pwnz wrote:kloud1516 - No pattern that I can detect
One thing about kloud1516 that perked my interest was this statement, which leads me to believe that he might in fact be the famous Dr. Arkham.I am in agreement with the cat that has been traipsing through my laboratory
Thats OLD SCHOOL robin stuff. he may be Nightwing, who was the first robin.
Flameaxe - Not enough posting info
Seems to be associated with Batman's sidekick, Robin.
The only other thing that I can detect is that he has used an exclamation mark in every one of his posts.Holy vase batman!Holy "random" votes, Batman!Praise the lord, for he is our savior!
This would be the RiddlerZONEACE - Has asked a question in every single one of his posts. Similar to Flameaxe except instead of exclamation marks this time it is question marks.does anyone else like the color green?wait, what are we talking about now?Does anyone else agree?
Again, OLD SCHOOL catwoman (By Old school, I mean the old TV show)charter - Has a reference to cats in each of his posts. Catwoman?I love pink catsShould we massclaim our characters? I've got a few of them down from the cat-firmation stageOOps, had a little cat-astrophe in my last post, won't happen again. Sorry
BOTH of these can be alluded to the Joker, so we may be able to add HARLEY QUINN to the group, but which one? I dunno.Albert B. Rampage - Joker-esque postsGoOd EveNinG LadIeS and GENtle MeN....HyahaahahahaA little fight in ya. I like that.
DarlaBlueEyes - Laughs at seemingly random intervals, seems to be liked to the Riddler. No other pattern that I can detect.I agree that the nasty bat and his friends are obviously the killers, we should weed them out and enact our revenge.AhAhahahAHahAHahHAhahhahahAHAhaWell this IS the question now isn't it
just adding my 2 cents to this post.
Grimmy
has change coming
OoO, the kitten's got claws!charter wrote:
Whether or not all three heroes are scum or protown is WIFOM. Go ahead and vote me, you're just going to get clawed for it.Inspector Godot wrote:
Logic. Having all three heroes as pro-town would seem too obvious, as would having them all scum. So at least one hero is scum in my eyes. And having everyone that has a posting restriction as either all pro-town or all mafia doesn't seem right either. Should I put an OMGUS vote on you?charter wrote:vote Inspectot Godot
My feline sense wonders how you're so sure the scum must have posting restrictions and at least one is a hero. Once again, what makes you so sure?
Will more a little later.-
-
KingEnigma Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 614
- Joined: May 17, 2004
- Location: TN
what if its the jason todd robin? if thats the case we could have a "gad" guy right there, he isnt agove a little tough love. well i guess he was all agout the tough love after he got glowed up, gut still.So a nun, the easter bunny, and a blonde walk into a bar. The bartender says "What is this, a joke?-
-
kloud1516 Executioner
- Executioner
- Executioner
- Posts: 700
- Joined: May 27, 2008
EBWOP~will post more later. And here it is.
I have gone back through in hopes of figuring out who everyone is (character wise). All of this speculation got me curious as to who was who, and so here is my theory:
Zoneace: Riddler
Crub: ? Not enough material to make a hypothesis
KE: Ventriloquist
SingingLibrarian: ?
DarlaBlueEyes: Penguin/Harley Quinn. Based on the DBE's confirmation post, I am more inclined to believe she is the Penguin. I might be wrong here, but didn't Penguin laugh a lot as well?
charter: Catwoman
pwnz: Not sure; I feel that you are either Batman or Nightwing because of your confirmation post.
This leads me to believe you are either Mr. Batty himself or Nightwing, but I have no evidence beyond mere speculation.pwnz wrote:SHADOW
Grimmy: Not sure; I am going to guess Two-Face
Two-Face would be stuck in the middle ground, for he is half monster, half human due to his multiple personality disorder. I know this might not be correct, but is all I've got at the moment.Grimmy wrote:
I prefer grey myself.ZONEACE wrote:does anyone else like the color green?
its more of a middle ground thing.
Grimmy
stuck in the middle.
ABR: Joker
Flameaxe: Robin or Nightwing -- for reasons already addressed by Grimmy and pwnz.
Godot: Mr. Freeze
------------------------------------------
In my opinion, it is still early in the game, and I do not think that someone expressing their opinion to possible possiblities is all that bad. At the same time, I can see where charter is coming from, for the WIFOM is only helps to create confusion (at least to me). Instead of focusing on possible set-ups, I think we should focus on weeding out who seems the most suspicious and interrogating them, hero or villain, post restriction or no instead of dwelling on speculation and possibility. This will help us answer the questions at hand as well as get rid of scum. Anyone agree?Inspector Godot wrote:
WIFOM? Of course it is, that's why I think it's a mix of heroes and villains, normal posters and those without restrictions. Speculation never hurt anyone and if you're worried and/or petty enough to place a vote due to it then I'll take the lift down to your level.charter wrote:
Whether or not all three heroes are scum or protown is WIFOM. Go ahead and vote me, you're just going to get clawed for it.Inspector Godot wrote:
Logic. Having all three heroes as pro-town would seem too obvious, as would having them all scum. So at least one hero is scum in my eyes. And having everyone that has a posting restriction as either all pro-town or all mafia doesn't seem right either. Should I put an OMGUS vote on you?charter wrote:vote Inspectot Godot
My feline sense wonders how you're so sure the scum must have posting restrictions and at least one is a hero. Once again, what makes you so sure?
Vote Charter
unvote
FoS: Zoneace; what exactly is your reasoning behind voting charter? I didn't see any justification above.
Is that what the Riddler fears most; a vicious kitten? This certainly is an E.Nygma.-
-
charter Beware of Dog
- Beware of Dog
- Beware of Dog
- Posts: 9261
- Joined: July 12, 2007
- Location: Virginia
Ok, this kitty doesn't understand why everyone feels the need to quote everyone's posts and then put up what role they think they have.
I think it was my first post, but shouldn't we massclaim our roles? This will put an end to speculating and maybe we can get some better discussion going. I don't see what harm it can do to the town.
I'm pretty obvious, Catwoman.-
-
ZONEACE There's no F in ZONEFACE
- There's no F in ZONEFACE
- There's no F in ZONEFACE
- Posts: 4548
- Joined: November 10, 2003
- Location: Harlem NYC
-
-
ZONEACE There's no F in ZONEFACE
- There's no F in ZONEFACE
- There's no F in ZONEFACE
- Posts: 4548
- Joined: November 10, 2003
- Location: Harlem NYC
-
-
charter Beware of Dog
- Beware of Dog
- Beware of Dog
- Posts: 9261
- Joined: July 12, 2007
- Location: Virginia
-
-
charter Beware of Dog
- Beware of Dog
- Beware of Dog
- Posts: 9261
- Joined: July 12, 2007
- Location: Virginia
-
-
ZONEACE There's no F in ZONEFACE
- There's no F in ZONEFACE
- There's no F in ZONEFACE
- Posts: 4548
- Joined: November 10, 2003
- Location: Harlem NYC
-
-
Grimmy Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1429
- Joined: May 14, 2008
- Location: NYC
Any lynch may help us figure out the answer to the "comic alignment" question.
And yes, Im one of them who think the "heroes" in the comics are the "scum" in this game.
Grimmy
NOONE is above the almight OMGUS!!!Showv/la on weekend until further notice.
Rishi wrote:
Of course, Grimmy never seems to leave the random stage - even on like Day 3. And he seems to do okay.
Grimm "Bruce" Lee - I-will-punch-you-in-the-SHIRT!-
-
Flameaxe Comma Police
- Comma Police
- Comma Police
- Posts: 6642
- Joined: July 9, 2007
- Location: Denver
-
-
ZONEACE There's no F in ZONEFACE
- There's no F in ZONEFACE
- There's no F in ZONEFACE
- Posts: 4548
- Joined: November 10, 2003
- Location: Harlem NYC
Flameaxe wrote:
So why aren't you voting him? Hm?charter wrote:My cat sense is tingling, that pretty much settles it, Zoneace is scum.
He wants to lynch me on page 4, and doesn't give a reason, other than "we need to lynch someone".
because he's full of shit. Sooooo, how bout them yankees?Late twenties, early Thursdays
Copyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.