Mafia 79 - "The Amish Mafia" GAME OVER... WHO WON?

[DizzyIzzyB13]

That way leads to huge piles of WIFOM, killa seven. Huge piles.

Piles of wine? How would that even work?

[Korts]

unvote, vote: StrangerCoug

While I don't agree with k7 completely, I do think that your reason for voting wasn't just reaching, it was outright BS. k7 wasn't making assuptions about the roles that are left, he was making assumptions about the mafia's NK. Whole different story.

Also,

FoS q21

because I don't have to votes. Not only do you state that k7's reasoning leads to WIFOM, which in itself does not, you also seem to imply that an uncountered nurse-lynch is the way to go (even if it's hardly counterable). RBT isn't the lynch for today.

[Riceballtail]

That way leads to huge piles of WIFOM, killa seven. Huge piles.

Piles of wine? How would that even work?

Pyramids, I'm guessing. Maybe those fancy wine racks? </notgame>

UNVOTE, VOTE:Coug

One good backstab deserves another...

Sidenote: Today feels as horribly difficult as D1.

[StrangerCoug]

UNVOTE, VOTE:Coug

One good backstab deserves another...

It'd be OMGUS by my book if I weren't still voting you.

Heck, this probably qualifies as OMGUS anyway.

[StrangerCoug]

EBWOP:

UNVOTE, VOTE:Coug

One good backstab deserves another...

It'd be OMGUS by my book if I

were

still voting you.

Heck, this probably qualifies as OMGUS anyway.

Fixed.

[q21]

unvote, vote: StrangerCoug

While I don't agree with k7 completely, I do think that your reason for voting wasn't just reaching, it was outright BS. k7 wasn't making assuptions about the roles that are left, he was making assumptions about the mafia's NK. Whole different story.

Also,

FoS q21

because I don't have to votes. Not only do you state that k7's reasoning leads to WIFOM, which in itself does not, you also seem to imply that an uncountered nurse-lynch is the way to go (even if it's hardly counterable). RBT isn't the lynch for today.

I agree with your reasons for voting Coug and if it comes down to it I'll happily hammer him, but as for my continuing vote on RBT: It's not so much whether he was countered or not as it is that I simply don't believe him.

[mr. incrediball]

i'm not fully believing RBT's claim either. protective roles are easy fakes to pull off... that is, until an obvious choice for protection gets NKed. until such an event, i say we leave RBT alone.

unvote

.

[xyzzy]

Amish Mafia votecount 4-2

riceballtail: DizzyIzzyB13, q21
DizzyIzzyB13: kuribo
killa seven: StrangerCoug
StrangerCoug: Korts, riceballtail



Not voting: UnofficialRulerOfEveryone, Surye, SensFan, killa seven, Mr. Incrediball

UnofficialRulerOfEveryone replaces Inquisitor JL. Marmalade is modkilled - he was a townie, as noted in post 1. Sending another mass prod just so everyone knows we're back on track.

[Korts]

Still here, still thinking SC is scum.

[SensFan]

I'll admit I I've fallen a little behind in this game. Allow me to reread, and I'll have content up within 48 hours.

[killa seven]

welcome uroe.

[StrangerCoug]

Ugh... I had to look back to remind myself why I voted for killa seven. Not good xP

Unvote: killa seven

because forgetting the reason for your vote is blasphemy.

Expect one of my next couple of posts in this thread to be a PBPA of the game.

[StrangerCoug]

killa seven:

Good case on Mellowed Man and reasonable case on Riceballtail, but otherwise not very active in the thread. Somewhat scummy.

Evilgorillaz/StrangerCoug:

That's for you to work out—I know what I've picked up from him

nswhorse/Korts:

I can't get a decent read on nswhorse by reading his posts in isolation. Korts' second incarnation's cases on q21's second incarnation and me make sense. I want to say he's pro-town if only because he knows what he's doing most of the time.

Celebloki/q21:

Celebloki comes off to me as a rather cautious person who tries to consider everything before making any hard and fast decisions, which is a good thing; but his replacement has tarnished his slate for wanting to kill an uncounterclaimed power role, whether he believes Riceballtail or not. My top suspect, so

Vote: q21

Surye:

Relatively inactive, but I understand his limited access despite not having posted since June 30. I don't like his bandwagoning for the sake of bandwagoning early on, nor do I like his encouraging others to do so. His later posts are clean, but I'm still leaning toward him being scum.

babygirl86/SensFan:

babygirl86's posts scream frustrated newbie more than anything. This is her last post before asking for a replacement:

you know what? screw you people.

Tell me that's not something a frustrated newbie would post.

As for SensFan, I don't like his voting for Mellowed Man with only a quote to back it up, nor do I like the reason for his FoS'ing Riceballtail—seems to me like a person who'll happily go with common consensus rather than give actual reasons for his suspicions. Very scummy.

Major HoS: SensFan

Inquisitor JL/UnofficialRulerOfEveryone:

I can't get much of a read from Inquisitor JL and UnofficialRulerOfEveryone hasn't posted yet, but I think the former has posted enough information to make me believe he is town.

Rigel/kuribo:

Rigel only posted once, so I can't get a read on him. kuribo has been most suspicious of DizzyIzzyB13 all game, but is taking other people into account, so he's not guilty of tunnel vision. Town to me.

mr. incrediball:

He has pretty good cases on a number of people in this game and seems to be a pretty experienced player. I wish I had much more to say about his 42 votes than this, but I can say that I'm getting town vibes from him right now.

Riceballtail:

I don't like his accusing ValiantValant of posting too much, especially if the latter says he's sick. Very weak case for his vote on ZombieSlayer54, essentially zero case for his vote on babygirl86, and a stretchy case for his FoS on Korts. I have no comment on his vote on me since I used the same reason to vote him (remember, we were in pretty much in an inactive state). Scummy, but I'm not going to do anything else to him unless and until a counterclaim happens.

ValiantValant/DizzyIzzyB13:

ValiantValant is way too panicky about his having voted Korts and takes his vote off him when he's at L-7. I also do not know whether he's being contradictory about there not being support for the Day 1 wagon but his willingness to wagon "should something come up". DizzyIzzyB13 has not been completely successful in cleaning his slate as she seems to be tunneling on babygirl86 when the latter was still in the game. She refuses to unvote Riceballtail until he explains the reasons for his protections. On the scummy side.

FoS: DizzyIzzyB13

LIST OF SUSPICION

q21
SensFan
Riceballtail
DizzyIzzyB13
killa seven
Surye
UnofficialRulerOfEveryone
Korts
mr. incrediball
kuribo

That's in decreasing order of scumminess to me, by the way.

[Riceballtail]

I am also still here. Still suspicious of Coug, but I'm not convinced enough on anyone for a lynch. Did a good analysis, giving town-vibes, but not fully convinced yet. Vote stays for now, may remove if it becomes out of control on the wagon. My top three fall into Mr. I, Coug, and Dizzy. No real order to it, just my top three suspects right now.

[Korts]

Shiny post there. I'll try to order my thoughts tomorrow or something.

[q21]

Celebloki/q21:

Celebloki comes off to me as a rather cautious person who tries to consider everything before making any hard and fast decisions, which is a good thing; but his replacement has tarnished his slate for wanting to kill an uncounterclaimed power role, whether he believes Riceballtail or not. My top suspect, so

Vote: q21

I don't judge a role claim on whether it is counter claimed or not, especially one so unlikely to be counter-claimed. I can think of no situation arising in the future which would clear up his claim on way or the other. So I leave my vote right where it is because that's where I believe it should be.

A question: You seem to suspect me and Dizzy for the same thing - you thought my replacee was townie and you thought Dizzy's was scummy. Why am I then so much higher in you scum list than Dizzy?

[StrangerCoug]

I don't judge a role claim on whether it is counter claimed or not, especially one so unlikely to be counter-claimed. I can think of no situation arising in the future which would clear up his claim on way or the other. So I leave my vote right where it is because that's where I believe it should be.

Call me freaking cautious then. My play style does not involve killing an uncounterclaimed power role unless I have a good reason to do so.

If you can give me a good reason why we should kill Riceballtail anyway, then I'll happily unvote you, but I don't plan to do the former right now.

A question: You seem to suspect me and Dizzy for the same thing - you thought my replacee was townie and you thought Dizzy's was scummy. Why am I then so much higher in you scum list than Dizzy?

If you're talking about what I think you are, then my best answer to this is that DizzyIzzyB13 refuses to unvote Riceballtail until he explains his protections and you refuse to unvote him at all. My abrupt switch in thinking probably factors into this too. My LoS isn't set in stone, and it can be shuffled around based on other things that come up.

[kuribo]

can we just get on with lynching dizzy?

[Korts]

You know, I remember ValiantValant being real scummy. Dizzy hasn't done much to clear his reputation.

unvote, vote: DizzyIzzy

[killa seven]

can we replace surye?
and also vv was scummy day one need to go check out what it was again.

[Riceballtail]

unvote; vote Dizzy

It's time to try and get this game going again...

[Korts]

This game hasn't gone anywhere much since Day 1...

[Riceballtail]

This is sadly true. Granted, I've said that already today too.

[killa seven]

unvote vote dizzy

this game is painfull

[StrangerCoug]

Unvote: q21
Pressure vote: DizzyIzzyB13