Gimbo (3) -
Chelseafan (3) -
KNIGHT42 (1) -
Forbiddanlight (1) -
Adel (1) -
Not voting (3) -
False. It can be confirmed that I am voting chelseafan because a random number generator told me so.KNIGHT42 wrote:I think flea is currently voting for his fellow mafia member because the vote is him of suspicion.chenhsi wrote:Why do you think flea is voting for his fellow mafia member? The only reason you think they are mafia is because they claimed.
Why should Chelseafan's vote change because you voted for him?
If you really think we are scum, why don't you vote for Gimbo, who has more votes and is closer to being lynched?
That's not true. Chenshi and Chelseafan haven't claimed scum. YOU LIE.KNIGHT42 wrote:1. Gimbo WIFOM, claims scum along with flea
2. Chenshi and Chelseafan quickly follow suit
Why can none of the votes on Gimbo be from Mafia?KNIGHT42 wrote:4. People suspect of Gimbo, votes accumulate (none from the possible mafioso)
This whole section doesn't mean anything at all, because both "Flea withdraws" and "Flea stays" have "Flea is scum" and "Flea is town" as outcomes.KNIGHT42 wrote:If flea withdraws:
A. Both are mafia
B. Flea is mafia, trying to perhaps frame chelsea
C. Is town and = worthless
If he stays
A. Mafia and dumb at the same time
B. Town and innocent thus clearing the likes of gimbo
Because I don't think he's scum, simple.KNIGHT42 wrote:Why would flea withdraw his vote if he is a town?
You assume we trust you...KNIGHT42 wrote:Because if we find go through with the lynching of Chelseafan, and he is innocent, I will thus reveal my partner leaving us with an easy win!!!
It proves nothing, and, even working under the assumption that everything KNIGHT says is true, I still don't know what it proves...Chelseafan wrote:'m just rather confused at the plan that's all.
It proves nothing from what I can see.
Knight, I think the problem is all your outcomes under "flea withdraws" are that SSF and chelseafan are either mafia or town. There is no definitive outcome to the vote movements, especially as you state you are not going to force a lynch your move has no credibility. Especially your "C. Is town and = worthless " - if both SSF and chelseafan are town, how ischenhsi wrote:Is anyone besides knight42 NOT confused with his plan?
Now that is purely unfair. To state simply that those who haven't claimed are scum is entirely specious. I have said I am in favour of a claim but, unlike your unilateral action, I have left it to my partner to decide if he agrees with me and so make the claim himself. It is unfortunate that my partner (and some others) have taken a low profile/forgotten about the game/been kidnapped by aliens/died/whatever, but to decide this makes us scum is entirely unfounded.Gimbo wrote:I say that at minimum, there are 2 scums below:
...
Harvey Pew
...
either your memory is bad, or you are lieing.Gimbo wrote:Adel, like I've said before, in another game, with a fellow player claiming scum in their 2nd post, and you being a scum in that game, you immediately voted the said player in a seemingly angry way after their 'claim'.
But an equal probability scumsplit isn't a fair assumption.Gimbo wrote:I don't see how I am 'accusing' anyone of anything since 2/6 and 2/6 means its really equal probability.
I'm not really overreacting. i decided, before the game even started, to be more aggressive because in this setup it is obvious that multiple strong wagons will lead to the most information necessary for the town to win (I, of course, assume a Day 1 mislynch).SpyreX because of his overreaction to my posts which is odd given his normally mellow temper in all the other games I'm in with him.
As I allready said, it will make it harder for me to catch scum.Gimbo wrote:1) You never clearly said how exactly is claiming on D1 bad.
Exactly. You asked a superior player how to play as scum under this set up. To answer it would be to tutor you.2) I asked you a hypothetical* question on your take on the game if you were scum and you ignored it saying you didn't want to 'tutor' me.
Do you often have trouble telling a doctor-claim apart from a scum-claim? That must make this game very difficult for you.3) You ignored the comparison I made of this game is a previous game you were in when the MoS scum-claim gambit happened.
May I assume that he is Firestarter than, because he hasn't posted for 2 days and is the least active among those who have not claimed yet?Harvey Pew wrote:Now that is purely unfair. To state simply that those who haven't claimed are scum is entirely specious. I have said I am in favour of a claim but, unlike your unilateral action, I have left it to my partner to decide if he agrees with me and so make the claim himself. It is unfortunate that my partner (and some others) have taken a low profile/forgotten about the game/been kidnapped by aliens/died/whatever, but to decide this makes us scum is entirely unfounded.Gimbo wrote:I say that at minimum, there are 2 scums below:
...
Harvey Pew
...
Hmm. I think that's fishing...chenhsi wrote:May I assume that he is Firestarter than, because he hasn't posted for 2 days and is the least active among those who have not claimed yet?Harvey Pew wrote:Now that is purely unfair. To state simply that those who haven't claimed are scum is entirely specious. I have said I am in favour of a claim but, unlike your unilateral action, I have left it to my partner to decide if he agrees with me and so make the claim himself. It is unfortunate that my partner (and some others) have taken a low profile/forgotten about the game/been kidnapped by aliens/died/whatever, but to decide this makes us scum is entirely unfounded.Gimbo wrote:I say that at minimum, there are 2 scums below:
...
Harvey Pew
...
exactly, which is one of the reasons I'm on to you. An open and honest answer from me to your "hypothetical" question would've given you a clue.Gimbo wrote:^ haha chenhsi nice.
Adel, scratch that, I read it long ago and screwed up the details in my head, apologize for that. But I still don't see HOW exactly is it more difficult to catch scum if 12 is reduced down to 6.
do you still lack any support for this, other than my vote on you?Gimbo wrote:Adel is obvious scum, town is blind.
The game he is talking about is Newbie 540.Gimbo wrote:Adel, like I've said before, in another game, with a fellow player claiming scum in their 2nd post, and you being a scum in that game, you immediately voted the said player in a seemingly angry way after their 'claim'.
What is fishing?somestrangeflea wrote:Hmm. I think that's fishing...chenhsi wrote:May I assume that he is Firestarter than, because he hasn't posted for 2 days and is the least active among those who have not claimed yet?Harvey Pew wrote:Now that is purely unfair. To state simply that those who haven't claimed are scum is entirely specious. I have said I am in favour of a claim but, unlike your unilateral action, I have left it to my partner to decide if he agrees with me and so make the claim himself. It is unfortunate that my partner (and some others) have taken a low profile/forgotten about the game/been kidnapped by aliens/died/whatever, but to decide this makes us scum is entirely unfounded.Gimbo wrote:I say that at minimum, there are 2 scums below:
...
Harvey Pew
...
Vote: chensi
SSF is accusing you of trying to expose who are lovers together, despite his partner doing that repeatedly as well as trying to get everyone to claim.chenhsi wrote:What is fishing?somestrangeflea wrote: Hmm. I think that's fishing...
Vote: chensi
chenhsi wrote: May I assume that he is Firestarter than, because he hasn't posted for 2 days and is the least active among those who have not claimed yet?
Well done Columbo...Firestarter wrote:Connectivity will be low for the next 2 days guys, Ill try to get on at some point during this time.
This logic is highly and obviously flawed, as others have already pointed out. To Knight, do you still honestly believe this is going to clear or damn anyone,KNIGHT42 wrote:If flea withdraws:
A. Both are mafia
B. Flea is mafia, trying to perhaps frame chelsea
C. Is town and = worthless
If he stays
A. Mafia and dumb at the same time
B. Town and innocent thus clearing the likes of gimbo
I supported the massclaims, but I wasn't going to start doing so while other players believed they could find the mafia easier without doing so ... Not that there's much point now that half the players have already claimed.forbiddanlight wrote:I alsoFoS:Namelessfor being on board for pair reveals before Gimbo's gambit, and now avoiding doing so.