Mafia 79 - "The Amish Mafia" GAME OVER... WHO WON?

[StrangerCoug]

EBWOP: *waits (man, that was too dumb not to fix).

We forgive you. Confusing homonyms is not scummy.

[xyzzy]

Mass prod sent.

[StrangerCoug]

Alright, I'm probably going to be yelled at for making a random vote at Day 4, but this thread needs discussion fast, and controversial ways of doing so are not really a concern to me if the game is this dead. I do intend to take this vote off if I am led to believe that this person is town.

Vote: killa seven

Say something.

[SensFan]

I'm here.

I agree with the points brought up against RBT,

FoS

.

[kuribo]

Alright, I'm probably going to be yelled at for making a random vote at Day 4, but this thread needs discussion fast, and controversial ways of doing so are not really a concern to me if the game is this dead. I do intend to take this vote off if I am led to believe that this person is town.

Vote: killa seven

Say something.

Wait, you could have "random" voted anyone, any of the lurkers, any of the "I'm only here cause I got prodded" crowd--- and you voted for the guy who posted 5 posts before you?

[StrangerCoug]

As I said, I intended to stir up discussion and I predicted that the way I did so would result in someone yelling at me.

OK, so we have our debate: I voted for somebody five posts before me with the intent of sparking discussion. Explain how that is scummy, uncalled for, etc., and I'll defend. As I said, once I have reason to believe killa seven is town, I'm unvoting him.

[mr. incrediball]

dude, we have a scummy candidate. we just need more submariners to pop up and discuss the popular lynch choice atm. putting your head on the block is not a smart way to get discussion going...


*realises this is exactly what SC wants me to do*

[kuribo]

As I said, I intended to stir up discussion and I predicted that the way I did so would result in someone yelling at me.

OK, so we have our debate: I voted for somebody five posts before me with the intent of sparking discussion. Explain how that is scummy, uncalled for, etc., and I'll defend. As I said, once I have reason to believe killa seven is town, I'm unvoting him.

The vote itself isn't scummy, it's your reason. You said you could have random voted anyone. So instead of voting against someone who's been lurking, and trying to goad them into discussion, you vote against a guy who posted the page before you? That's scummy, IME.

[StrangerCoug]

For the moment my concern is not if my vote is good or bad (though, granted, it's most likely bad) as long as my attempt at sparking discussion works.

[killa seven]

i get where your coming from, maybe wagoning someone who hasnt posted yet today would get them to post.

[StrangerCoug]

Well, he said something.

Unvote: killa seven
Vote: nswhorse

You're next on my pressure vote list.

[Riceballtail]

I agree with Coug's ideals.

Also, I will be inactive most of the next two days (travel) and when I get back I should be able to be off LA. I don't really see any lynch candidates right now, so...

UNVOTE

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Just posting quickly to let people know that my activity is going to be sketchy for a little while, due to a serious family illness.

[xyzzy]

Amish Mafia votecount 4-1

riceballtail: Mr. Incrediball, DizzyIzzyB13
nswhorse: StrangerCoug



Not voting: nswhorse, Inquisitor JL, Celebloki, Marmalade, Surye, riceballtail, killa seven, SensFan, kuribo

Missed Celebloki asking for replacement >.< Looking for that now.

[kuribo]

Vote:DizzyIzzy

Have at you, scum!

[killa seven]

vote nswhorse

Post or die

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Vote:DizzyIzzy

Have at you, scum!

Explain your vote, please.

[Riceballtail]

VOTE:Marmalade

Page 26 lurker hunt ready go.

[mr. incrediball]

blimey, i've been L/A all weekend and this thread has only advanced a few posts!? not only is the conversation slow, but you've been reduced to lurker hunting!?

lurker hunting rarely gets you anywhere, since lurking is a null-tell. if you're that worried about the lurkers, ask for replacements! don't go lynching possible townies!

[Riceballtail]

Only voting to get people to post. Unless you're afraid you and your scumbuddies are going to quick-hammer.

[StrangerCoug]

mr. incrediball, if you don't like the fact that Riceballtail and I are lurker hunting, then actually vote for one of us.

Riceballtail, why do you believe mr. incrediball is scum?

[Riceballtail]

I'm just fairly suspicious as to how all of my enemies/people who found me suspicious are dead, but yet I haven't killed anyone. Him bringing that fact up makes me think he's trying to peg me with the crime, when I haven't done anything.

[StrangerCoug]

Did you just soft-claim?

[Surye]

I'm just fairly suspicious as to how all of my enemies/people who found me suspicious are dead, but yet I haven't killed anyone. Him bringing that fact up makes me think he's trying to peg me with the crime, when I haven't done anything.

This kind of response, in my opinion, is damaging to the town. It creates an atmosphere where analysis and postulation will get you killed. On the other hand, his idea that someone is trying to frame him is an interesting, but probably incorrect play. My guess is it's mostly coincidental.

[mr. incrediball]

mr. incrediball, if you don't like the fact that Riceballtail and I are lurker hunting, then actually vote for one of us.

1. my vote's already on RBT.

2. Lurker-hunting isn't scummy, it just distracts from actual scumminess. therefore i'm not voting for you.