Baton Pass [Game Over!]

[gameplay506]

Heeeeey
So votes rn are good ye?

[gameplay506]

I meant that they don't result in the person getting most votes dying
Anywayy since RVS seems to be off the table we can do some RQS and uhh ask some really personal questions and bond and uhh win this way

[gameplay506]

VOTE: SS

[gameplay506]

I doubt they're serious votes?

[gameplay506]

I'm just trying to get some votes on someone dunno why you react this way
People have been oddly serious and its page 2 so uh

[gameplay506]

how do you think scum approach this setup?

Is this for me?

[gameplay506]

Townreads>scumreads for this game since scum benefit more from townreading their buddies than bussing
So taking more time to explain those is not going to be bad imo

[gameplay506]

Hey I exist and I can townspew myself pretty well too

[gameplay506]

Hey I'm gameplay, I'm town, I want to win this one, lets do it
Is that sufficient

[gameplay506]

Townreads>scumreads for this game since scum benefit more from townreading their buddies than bussing
So taking more time to explain those is not going to be bad imo

What are your town reads or just vague townie impressions so far this game?

Uhmmm
I like Bitmap, gives me the same vibes as last game(if that is the Bitmap head posting)
That's it

[gameplay506]

OS seems cool too I guess

[gameplay506]

Ye ok good
Honestly from what we've had so far I have more negative then positive reads atm
It might be that the other large theme magical girls was pretty jokish for the first 10-15 pages or so but SS, wisdom and SH posts just seem a little out of place
Esp SS and his questions which just seem like overdoing it a bit

[gameplay506]

Oof I couldn't resist to fos, sorry

Pedit:Its nothing about meta, dunno why you even mention that I've played with you before
Just not a fan of your questions

[gameplay506]

Do you just think they're trying too hard?

Kinda
I mean it might be just playstyle but it just seems a bit unnatural

[gameplay506]

someone said magical girls would be a town stomp

Well it was going to be but

[gameplay506]

What would you have expected it to be based on, if not random?

is rvs ever random

I mean, it's usually arbitrary, which is very similar.

I'm ready to hammer.

Oh?

What I'm talking about @SS
It just seems like you are trying to comment on something without being actually too engaged into what it is

[gameplay506]

Hey uh
I just woke up and I got 30+ pages to catch up to
But I'm a hardworking boy and will do it today

[gameplay506]

If someone wants to give a tldr of what I the most important moments are that can speed up the process

[gameplay506]

Hey so
I will start my reread
It turns out I have 50 pages to read and I was procrastinating too much
Gonna do it page by page 'cus I will lose track of posts if I try to summarize it all in one

Page 5:

Cephrir is one grumpy boar but he cute
123 is just pointless

Page 6:

128 Eh
138 I mean you replaced into that game, didn't provide a lot of content and died the same night. I couldn't really get too familiar with your playstyle. So I'm looking at those posts restricted only by this game and they stand out.

Page 7:

I like OS tone here. His posts flow naturally/ don't come off as fabricated
Soshin makes another stiff comment. Eh
This seems to be a trend for this game tho
Hey SH do you usually have formed reads on page 7 ( btw you made this post on page 7, its page 50 something which means 40 pages in. What you got as reads?)

Page 8:

184 RC I SEE YOU
185 you tr both, cool, me too
189 She hasn't been striking me as anything strong rn dunno why this exists
Btw the stiff comment from last page applies a lot to Dann. I find him different from what he was in MG even in the early game where he was a bit more serious than late
190 MMM, I haven't given it much thought, but idk, not really? Tho I might be misunderstanding this so if you can explain
191 Weird vibe from the sorry SS line
192 Lets not do magic girls again, they have only posted twice lol
197 I yell ^

Page 9:

219 Ah I think I understand now. I agree?
I can't get anything of the Wisdom/SH exchange about Nacho, sorry

Page 10:

RC going about how he is going to die N1 gives me deja vu from MG but I think that's something typical of him
WOW is 232 scummy bad
I have liked OH so far and 239 is quite good. Might be because I see where they are coming from, might be because I like the flow of the post, might be because he ACTUALLY HAS THE COURAGE(and patience) TO FIGHT RC but I like it.
I can get behind what Gay Dance is proposing too
243 Eh. I mean it raises opposition because you voted him after 2 posts when he basically said nothing AI. And you seem to have a weird attitude towards that slot for the last 2 pages.
I still like Gay Dance but its something to mark.
248 Getting a universal agreement from all players with what to do with the baton will most likely go wrong. JUST SAYING

Page 11:

257 Wut, where did this come from
269 Yes
This was it huh

Page 12:

I think that the one with a strange obsession for RC is Yukz who seems to only like to talk about him and not really bother with anything else
Like why?
284 EH
Yukz
Sorry but what Wisdom is saying makes sense, don't fight me for that RC
Since I have to mention Yukz for the third time, I really don't like him

Page 13:

300 Amazing
302Hey I haven't mentioned SS but at best he is a null. His openning was weird, his remarks are not very exciting and so far he hasn't been up to much. So why is this?
305Ah, an answer to the above. And he doesn't seem stiff now?
SS lol
OS talk I can't really join in so on to

Page 14:

329 I wanna know why
336That is just a bad proposal.
Shoshin seems to be in the RC fanclub as well
I wanna know why Wisdom too, maybe we get an explanation next page?

Page 15:

350 I don't understand what you are getting at with those
That he is filler posting? If so, I think he isn't alone there
362is more nice posting from OH
Nacho has a ok-ish/good-ish entrance post
The self-conscious argument about Wisdom is cool but shoshin is definitely not as towny as other slots so what is that vote Dann

THIS IS GOING SLOWER THAN I THOUGHT
Gonna split it in several posts so that i don't clog the thread with mine

[gameplay506]

Oof that looks just badly structured
Hope its readable guys

[gameplay506]

To sum up: OS, Oh, Gay dance kinda are good
Wisdom near that level
If all the celestial posting is RC then I can't really form much of a read there tho what has been posted is consistent with MG imo
SH is meh. I guess I expected more from her
Shoshin is so-so . I haven't been a fan of him tho the wisdom take bad at first glance can totally come from town
Yukz, SS, PM are not good

[gameplay506]

I will do more in a bit

[gameplay506]

Do explain

[gameplay506]

I am still waiting for a reply shoshin

[gameplay506]

But it's a catchy song

[gameplay506]

Ok lol
I anticipated this so I started doing the next one with quotes

[gameplay506]

It being hard to read

[gameplay506]

Why does shoshin get the benefit of the doubt on the wisdom read and I don't gameplay?

Because of the way you and him did it.
Your argument for wisdom was centered around RC, it being basically that Wisdom is trying to get RC to go mad and people trying to piss RC off are scum. That's just a shitty and lazy argument and last game I saw that the very same argument isn't true.
Soshin's argument was an oddly specific one, the effort for which I see more as coming from town than from scum

My problem isn't that it's hard to read - hate the format, but can follow it just fine. My problem is that you aren't really saying anything that you seem to care about/all of your observations seem like they're completely disconnected from one another.

Like, if you're town here and go through 10 pages, I'd expect 1 of 2 things. The first is that you find something that grabs you and it's something that you push and make your voice heard while the second is that you don't find anything that interesting and so you don't spend an hour or whatever creating a post saying that you didn't really find anything. The main point that your post seems to serve is demonstrating to us that you're trying to catch up which is nice and I appreciate it but also has a stronger scum motivation than a town one.

Does that make sense?

Yea I see what you mean
I guess me seeming like I don't care can be explained with how I approached the catch-up post(more in a rush, trying to get into the later pages) or its just my style of posting idk. I don't think I come off as totally disconnected from what I'm saying tho. I stand by what I say and I hope people consider my reads for once but I am also in the process of catch-up with my thoughts on the game being highly likely to change so I would rather not commit to hard onto what I am reading rn.
I guess the two main things of what I am trying to do rn is to 1. Form reads and 2. Present my thought process so that I can make myself more easy to read.

[gameplay506]

Shoshin literally said part of her case was stuff I picked out

Where?

[gameplay506]

I stand by what I say and I hope people consider my reads for once

sure. what's something from your catchup so far that you'd like for me to address?

Um I don't know? Can't really think of something specific that I wan't you to comment on if that's what you are asking

Gameplay what do you think shoshins case on wisdom is?

There's a degree of self-consciousness in 315 that doesn't feel like town Wisdom.

This is the argument/line I am referring to.

[gameplay506]

I MEAN my last post prior to my catch-up was on page 5 with probably half of my posts being jokish Celestial
I don't know how you expect me to townspew myself without posting

[gameplay506]

I think even 'a universal townread' doesn't do it justice, he was the single person I think everyone agreed was 100% town the entire game from super early on.

I agree that I was townleaning in most player's eyes but also a strong townread in scum's eyes
But an universal townread no, Gamma, Titus and someone else I can't recall rn didn't have me as town at all

[gameplay506]

it feels so wrong not to be able to vote you right now.

Eh
I don't know what you expect from me or what you are asking me to do rn
I don't need your feedback on my thoughts and I don't see how that makes me so bad


Pedit: I don't want you to chime in and start giving your take on what I find/don't find interesting from 40 pages ago since I already said that those thoughts are highly likely to change
And I hope people will listen to my reads part refers to when I actually finish reading and form more solid reads

[gameplay506]

Meh it seems like I am getting baton killed tonight
I don't have time to properly catch up and I probably won't be able to do that soon given how fast this game is moving. I have no idea why I am getting scumread so heavily and skimming the thread it seems that that has actually been going for some time before my actual catch up which is absurd since my last posts were from page 5. But I just won't bother addressing it seeing that everything I say prompts even more shit to get thrown my way.
So whatever, imma peace out and safe some mental energy
VOTE: CC
This might be hammer or L-1 according to last VC

[gameplay506]

Nah sorry Nacho but I don't have the energy nor the time to read 65 pages and make something sensible out of them
I guess best I can do rn is give the slot to someone who won't spare the effort to rehabilitate it
Sorry all