Greasy Spot wrote:dcorbe wrote:icemanE wrote:Also, yeah, I still don't understand the "breadcrumbing". Most often people breadcrumb when they're a protown power role as a way of trying to reveal info without claiming. I don't see how it would be at all advantageous to breadcrumb as scum, so I don't buy that part of the argument.
It's not advantageous to breadcrum as scum and that's sort of the point.
Whether it's a weak tell or a strong tell is also an irrelevant point. The point of the vote was to try and get a pressure wagon going on him and it worked because now he's dropping scum tells.
Iceman makes a good point saying it is not advantageous to breadcrumb as scum. Then dcorbe counters that with a good arguement.
Here's the deal as I see it. Scum don't need to breadcrumb as scum. If they want to breadcrumb as a cop or a doc to throw the town off that could be a good play later on. However it does not benefit scum to breadcrumb as scum.
Which is why hinting that you have inside knowledge of the game setup is a tell. Only scum would have such knowledge. There are plenty of examples of this on MS, some of which I have witnessed. I wish I had gospel to quote but then I would be talking about ongoing games which is a no-no.
Greasy Spot wrote:
As far as putting pressure on someone to see if they pop this is a good method. I believe Doktor Per has popped from the pressure but I'm not sure yet if he is scum.
I think dcorbe should be looked at closely for pushing this lynch. I could be wrong but I don't think Doktor Per is not scummy enough to lynch yet.
I'm not really pushing the lynch anymore. I'm not the one who put him at L-1. Asking for a claim when he's L-1 is protocol but he already claimed, so I wanted him to say something in his own defense. The only reason anyone at all is still "pushing" for his lynch is because he's doing such a horrible job. I'm not going to unvote until I have a better lynch target for the day, and if he does get lynched and turns up town (which I'm doubtful of) it will be his own fault
Greasy Spot wrote:Post42 wrote:Doktor Per wrote:dcorbe wrote:
And in all seriousness, how do you know how many scum there are in this game? Breadcrum much?
Unvote, Vote Doktor Per
According to the formula there should be three or four scum.
unvote
That was one of the scummiest posts I've ever read.
vote: dcorbe
If you are town, your paranoid antics will only hold us back. I will laugh if you will have the cop lynched.
This is no way indicates he is claiming cop or any other power role. He is simply saying he thinks you are going to push the wrong lynch eventually and it's going to be the cop.
Doktor Per wrote:I am a vanilla, mark my words, I just find his silly "OMG PARANOIA! SERIOUS BUSINESS" silly and stupid. The ideal ratio for scum versus town is one scum per three town. If there were five scum, if we would lose three town in short succession, it's much too easy for scum to win that way. Three is leaning towards town, while four would seem somewhat ideal.
Instead of realizing that not liking puns = Mafia is a joke, you all jump on the dcorbe bandwagon, because he decides that paranoia (or pointing fingers) is a really good tactic. Or this is all a inter Mafia scheme to distance us so in the end game, Dcorbe will be trusted and can take you hosers out one by one. HA HA HA!
What is going to happen now is that I get lynched, turn up as vanilla, someone speculates about me being scum miller or whatever you crazies do.
Jesus Christ guys, way to not have a sense of humor. I forgot that Mafia is SRS BSNSS.
Holding on for you to over interpret my post
You can do it, lovable scamps.
I hardly think this is a claim. More of a clarification to the twist dcorbe is trying to put on it.
I'm not twisting his words, you're just not paying close enough attention to things when you do rereads. He did claim. Loud and clear, and while he was nowhere near L-1
In his own words:
Doktor Per wrote:
47 I claim vanilla, what of it? I'm accused of soft claiming when I call Dcorbe a paranoid silly, so I just claim and come clean, I've seen this kind of stuff roll before.
It doesn't get any less ambiguous than that.