Mafia 79 - "The Amish Mafia" GAME OVER... WHO WON?

[q21]

*dies*

[killa seven]

i need to re read the game, ill post something up soon.

[Near]

sorry guys.
reading. will post in a couple of days!

[mr. incrediball]

well...

RBT's main antagonists are dead. they are town. one or two of them was nightkilled.

he's been wagoning, and opportunistic.

he's had little input, and next to no defence.

he is scum.

vote RBT

.

[Riceballtail]

Now that Mellowed Man's on the way, I'm looking pretty hard at Riceballtail. Here's why:

Day 1: He accuses ValiantValant of posting too much, as if he has to defend everything that comes up about them. One, how is posting too much scummy? Two, why shouldn't he have defended everything? Was he supposed to sit there and ignore the accusations, and God knows what misfortune befalls him?

Day 2: Bandwagon much? He gave a very weak reason for voting for BabyGirl86, and it seems like he was backing her into a corner and forcing her out of the game. Bullying bankrupts your credibility if it gets you anywhere at all,

Day 3: His only post is to vote for Mellowed Man because of the lynch-all-liars strategy. Granted, I eventually hammered MM for LAL too, but this is all you have!? Come the heck on!

Vote: Riceballtail

Day1: He posted 5 times in a day. He took a very defensive stance, and I found it scummy when it was very random at that stage of the game.

Day2: I would say that it could easily have been seen as weak reasoning, but I find it frustrating when people act that way. You seem to be picking pretty hard with making that a big case of it. Her play was very scummy, so why do you call my reasoning weak?

Day3:See all my reasoning from D2. There was already a strong case, and I'd pointed it out then. This is a bad justification. D3 didn't have a lot of discussion, it was mostly decided from D2 he was the lynch of the day if there weren't two kills.

VOTE:Coug

, you only have a decent case from D1, and that's still a bit of a reach.

well...

RBT's main antagonists are dead. they are town. one or two of them was nightkilled.

he's been wagoning, and opportunistic.

he's had little input, and next to no defence.

he is scum.

vote RBT.

Yes, my antagonists are dead, I guess I'll just have to fish up some new ones, won't I? Hmm, funny you are pointing this out though. It's quite easy that someone has been doing this to set me up, possibly you?

HoS:Mr.I

[DizzyIzzyB13]

RBT's defence is weak. Coug's case is pretty good and I agree with mr. incrediball's assessment. I think a

vote: RBT

is in order.

[mr. incrediball]

Yes, my antagonists are dead, I guess I'll just have to fish up some new ones, won't I? Hmm, funny you are pointing this out though. It's quite easy that someone has been doing this to set me up, possibly you?

HoS:Mr.I

yes, of course. i've been slowly killing off anybody who's suspected you for the sole purpose of making you look scummy. i've taken all this trouble to set up you, someone who looked scummy anyway. what a pity you foiled my conspiracy. huzzah for you.

[StrangerCoug]

Day1: He posted 5 times in a day. He took a very defensive stance, and I found it scummy when it was very random at that stage of the game.

I'll buy that.

Day2: I would say that it could easily have been seen as weak reasoning, but I find it frustrating when people act that way. You seem to be picking pretty hard with making that a big case of it. Her play was very scummy, so why do you call my reasoning weak?

You only said it "seems scummy" and that "she's earned the lynch". Nowhere in the post I'm getting this from do you explain your thinking.

Day3:See all my reasoning from D2. There was already a strong case, and I'd pointed it out then. This is a bad justification. D3 didn't have a lot of discussion, it was mostly decided from D2 he was the lynch of the day if there weren't two kills.

That's great, but my primary concern with you about Day 3 was your activity. Pop in, vote, pop out. That's all you did.

VOTE:Coug

, you only have a decent case from D1, and that's still a bit of a reach.

Welcome to OMGUS land.

[killa seven]

Yes, my antagonists are dead, I guess I'll just have to fish up some new ones, won't I? Hmm, funny you are pointing this out though. It's quite easy that someone has been doing this to set me up, possibly you?

HoS:Mr.I

yes, of course. i've been slowly killing off anybody who's suspected you for the sole purpose of making you look scummy. i've taken all this trouble to set up you, someone who looked scummy anyway. what a pity you foiled my conspiracy. huzzah for you.

Lol at rbt. that is very unlikely.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Day1: He posted 5 times in a day. He took a very defensive stance, and I found it scummy when it was very random at that stage of the game.

I'll buy that.

Day2: I would say that it could easily have been seen as weak reasoning, but I find it frustrating when people act that way. You seem to be picking pretty hard with making that a big case of it. Her play was very scummy, so why do you call my reasoning weak?

You only said it "seems scummy" and that "she's earned the lynch". Nowhere in the post I'm getting this from do you explain your thinking.

Day3:See all my reasoning from D2. There was already a strong case, and I'd pointed it out then. This is a bad justification. D3 didn't have a lot of discussion, it was mostly decided from D2 he was the lynch of the day if there weren't two kills.

That's great, but my primary concern with you about Day 3 was your activity. Pop in, vote, pop out. That's all you did.

VOTE:Coug

, you only have a decent case from D1, and that's still a bit of a reach.

Welcome to OMGUS land.

Hah. It's not as OMGUSucky as claiming that mr. incrediball had been trying to set him up all game long.

[Riceballtail]

Lol at rbt. that is very unlikely.

Oh, but wouldn't that make quite a nice gambit?

[Riceballtail]

That's great, but my primary concern with you about Day 3 was your activity. Pop in, vote, pop out. That's all you did.

That was my finals time. I was on LA, so I didn't have much time to make a real elaborate post. Also note how much time the day took in pages, many people only posted once, or not at all. I feel that making me scum from that isn't very considerate of the circumstances.

[kuribo]

RBT's defence is weak. Coug's case is pretty good and I agree with mr. incrediball's assessment. I think a

vote: RBT

is in order.

Explain how so? (PS, I still think you're scum)

[Celebloki]

Hello, I am sorry to do this but I would like to ask for replacement. I have been very busy in life right now and I am gonna pull down my number of games.

Mod: I request replacement

[StrangerCoug]

That's great, but my primary concern with you about Day 3 was your activity. Pop in, vote, pop out. That's all you did.

That was my finals time. I was on LA, so I didn't have much time to make a real elaborate post. Also note how much time the day took in pages, many people only posted once, or not at all. I feel that making me scum from that isn't very considerate of the circumstances.

OK, fine.

Unvote: Riceballtail

, but you still get an

FoS: Riceballtail

for right now.

[Riceballtail]

RBT's defence is weak. Coug's case is pretty good and I agree with mr. incrediball's assessment. I think a

vote: RBT

is in order.

Explain how so? (PS, I still think you're scum)

Is this to me or Izzy?

[kuribo]

Izzy. That was the whole point of me quoting Izzy.

[Riceballtail]

MOD: Can we get some mass-prod action?

nswhorse, Surye, Inquisitor JL, Marmalade, and Sensfan have yet to post today. This game can't move forward much more from here with five people out after almost a week.

As to kuribo, I was referencing the idea as to who you thought was scum, but I'll assume you meant Izzy in that too.

[kuribo]

As to kuribo, I was referencing the idea as to who you thought was scum, but I'll assume you meant Izzy in that too.

Yep.

[killa seven]

Mass prod needed.

[StrangerCoug]

Lonely... xP

[mr. incrediball]

Lonely... xP

don't worry strange... i'm here!

[killa seven]

im not sure about the others but ive seen surye posting in other games, its strange hed completely blow this game off.

[Surye]

im not sure about the others but ive seen surye posting in other games, its strange hed completely blow this game off.

Not strange, I just have a limited time resource, as posted in other games, and I am working my way though them, this game is up next. The really long nights and weights has caused me to completely lose track of this game, and it's going to take effort to get back in.

But thanks for noticing me <3

[Surye]

im not sure about the others but ive seen surye posting in other games, its strange hed completely blow this game off.

Not strange, I just have a limited time resource, as posted in other games, and I am working my way though them, this game is up next. The really long nights and weights has caused me to completely lose track of this game, and it's going to take effort to get back in.

But thanks for noticing me <3

EBWOP: *waits (man, that was too dumb not to fix).