Mafia 79 - "The Amish Mafia" GAME OVER... WHO WON?

[Battle Mage]

Surely we'd want him to die loudly so we can use his noise to track his buddies?

this post gives me terribly scummy vibes. Enough for a wagon at this stage.

BM

What the hell…looked like a harmless joke to me. I really am starting to dislike playing with you.

Lol its a shame i cant reference the game as it isnt quite over, but i had a similar conversation yesterday. Somebody i attacked started resorting to personal comments when a wagon formed on him, and it looked like he was going down. I'm now starting to regard OMGUS under certain circumstances, as scummy.

With reference to your (limited) content, how the hell can you conceive that Izzy's post was a

JOKE????!!!

Btw, if i didnt say earlier, im still ok with an Alabaska lynch. But Izzy is my pick for today.

BM

[Battle Mage]

It's not like you are contributing either. All you've done in the past week is say you want Evilgorillaz like 6 days ago, then say a few people are scummy (whom many people have, what a follower) and ask BM to post more detailed explanations of his votes

All of this sounds like content to me.

Surely we'd want him to die loudly so we can use his noise to track his buddies?

this post gives me terribly scummy vibes. Enough for a wagon at this stage.

BM

Really? Seriously?

yes.

[mr. incrediball]

With reference to your (limited) content, how the hell can you conceive that Izzy's post was a

JOKE????!!!

hm... i don't get that. is it meant to be sarcastic?

[kuribo]

I was going to post my case against DizzyIzzy, but it's mostly a case against Valiant Valiant. DI can't answer those questions on his behalf anyway.

Post #470, of which there has already been much ado, looks like a bit of a reach to me. It seems like a passing comment that Dizzy wants to paint as scummy in order to keep herself off the block today--- "Die quietly" is not necessarily an instruction, more like a turn of phrase. (One which I've encountered at least once myself in the last month or so)

[Battle Mage]

With reference to your (limited) content, how the hell can you conceive that Izzy's post was a

JOKE????!!!

hm... i don't get that. is it meant to be sarcastic?

umm, no. Please feel free to field the question for your buddy Alabaska, if you agree with him. Christ, i'm sick of so many people making so little sense...

BM

[Alabaska J]

I really don't understand why this comment is such a big deal. I could totally see that comment with a after it and its meaning wouldn't change for me at all. I mean, seeing as the comment was closer to an attack on me (if I had to frame it as such) than anyone else, and I don't see anything wrong with it. BM's play has just been off this whole game and while I see a major connection with him and the claimed vig I reeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaally can't take it anymore.

unvote, vote: Battle Mage

. Please explain again what you see as scummy in the comment.

[Battle Mage]

I really don't understand why this comment is such a big deal. I could totally see that comment with a after it and its meaning wouldn't change for me at all.

I mean, seeing as the comment was closer to an attack on me (if I had to frame it as such) than anyone else, and I don't see anything wrong with it

.

BM's play has just been off this whole game

and while I see a major connection with him and the claimed vig I reeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaally can't take it anymore.

unvote, vote: Battle Mage

.

Please explain again what you see as scummy in the comment.

Why not let Izzy answer?

Izzy, was your comment total BS for the sake of humour, or was it a genuine suggestion on how the town should behave?

The bit in italics is an example of why i cant take you seriously. If you think all this game is about is one big OMGUS match, there isnt alot more i can tell you. Except, try a few more newbie games before you take on the large un's.

The bit in bold is confusing, as i dont think ive ever played with you before. That said, what makes you think my play is 'off' here. Where are you drawing this meta argument from?

Finally, the bit underlined is wierd. Why would you want me to explain something again, about 5 posts after i originally explained it?? 0.o
You havent indicated anything in particular was unclear, and from your vote, i take it that you are suggesting that i am scum. That being the case, why would you even care for me to repeat myself?

BM

[q21]

This thread has gotten bloody confusing in the last page or so - I'm not even sure why you're all arguing about something which seems fairly inane to me. Unless I've completely missed what it is that you're all going on about.

The one conclusion I have drawn from these pages is that either BM or Alabaska has to die today.

Becaues of those two he has more votes at the moment:

unvote, vote AlabaskaJ

MOD: CAN WE HAVE A VOTE COUNT PLEASE

... and Riceballtail sneaks through another day.

[Alabaska J]

The bit in italics is an example of why i cant take you seriously. If you think all this game is about is one big OMGUS match, there isnt alot more i can tell you. Except, try a few more newbie games before you take on the large un's.

WRONG. EPIC FAIL REREAD.

I never said anything about it being OMGUS at all. Also, I'm assuming, because The Fonz thinks that your analysis of the quote is off too, he should go back to newbie games?

[Mellowed Man]

unvote, vote Alabaska

Votecount, please. Alabaska's just running us around in circles now, and there's really nothing to comment about in the last few pages. We are basically beating a dead horse.

[Battle Mage]

The bit in italics is an example of why i cant take you seriously. If you think all this game is about is one big OMGUS match, there isnt alot more i can tell you. Except, try a few more newbie games before you take on the large un's.

WRONG. EPIC FAIL REREAD.

I never said anything about it being OMGUS at all. Also, I'm assuming, because The Fonz thinks that your analysis of the quote is off too, he should go back to newbie games?

You said that the fact that the criticism was about you, you should have the best judgement on whether it is scummy or not, which is totally untrue and also hugely arrogant.

The Fonz is a legend. But he's not always right. Actually Fonz didnt make such a criticism, he just didnt quite understand what i was getting at-mainly because i didnt go into a detailed explanation.

BM

[Battle Mage]

This thread has gotten bloody confusing in the last page or so - I'm not even sure why you're all arguing about something which seems fairly inane to me. Unless I've completely missed what it is that you're all going on about.

The one conclusion I have drawn from these pages is that either BM or Alabaska has to die today.

Becaues of those two he has more votes at the moment:

unvote, vote AlabaskaJ

MOD: CAN WE HAVE A VOTE COUNT PLEASE

... and Riceballtail sneaks through another day.

Unvote, Vote: Q21

If you are suspicious of RBT, why would you limit yourself to 2 completely different lynches??

BM

[DizzyIzzyB13]

[
Why not let Izzy answer?

Izzy, was your comment total BS for the sake of humour, or was it a genuine suggestion on how the town should behave?

Well, it was certainly phrased in order to be amusing and that was the primary motivation for the comment, but it also reflects my personal opinion that forcing content from scum is always a good idea, whether they're bluffing, lying or telling the truth.

[q21]

Because my vote on RBT is achieving nothing. If suddenly a wagon on him springs out of nowhere I'll happily switch back, but do you see that happening?.. no, me neither.

[Surye]

Because my vote on RBT is achieving nothing. If suddenly a wagon on him springs out of nowhere I'll happily switch back, but do you see that happening?.. no, me neither.

Spineless.

I stand by a RBT lynch.

[Mellowed Man]

Is it just me, or is it a telling tell if it is hard to start a wagon on some guys who have more evidence against them, while it is really easy to start a huge wagon, leading to lynch -1 on someone else, who is not as scummy?

[xyzzy]

Amish Mafia votecount 2-4

Mellowed Man: babygirl86, Mr. Incrediball
riceballtail: Surye
Alabaska J: Marmalade, evilgorrilaz, q21, Mellowed Man
Battle Mage: The Fonz, Alabaska J
babygirl86: DizzyIzzyB13, riceballtail
DizzyIzzyB13: kuribo
q21: Battle Mage


Not voting: Killa Seven, nswhorse, Inquisitor JL, kuribo, Celebloki

[Alabaska J]

Is it just me, or is it a telling tell if it is hard to start a wagon on some guys who have more evidence against them, while it is really easy to start a huge wagon, leading to lynch -1 on someone else, who is not as scummy?

Why thank you Mellowed Man.

Also,

unvote, vote: q21

.

Opportunistic scum just got himself caught. It looks as though me and Bowel Movement over there might finally agree on something.

[Battle Mage]

Because my vote on RBT is achieving nothing. If suddenly a wagon on him springs out of nowhere I'll happily switch back, but do you see that happening?.. no, me neither.

hmm ok, fair do's.

Unvote

[Battle Mage]

Is it just me, or is it a telling tell if it is hard to start a wagon on some guys who have more evidence against them, while it is really easy to start a huge wagon, leading to lynch -1 on someone else, who is not as scummy?

Why thank you Mellowed Man.

Also,

unvote, vote: q21

.

Opportunistic scum just got himself caught. It looks as though me and Bowel Movement over there might finally agree on something.

Lol opportunistic yourself.

Vote: Alabaska J

Now try and tell me you arent OMGUSsy scum, purely dominated by the will to survive.

I'm happy to lynch this damn fool whenever.

BM

[mr. incrediball]

bugger this game.

unvote, vote alabaska

. your play for most of this game looks like scum backed into a corner, and trying to do anything to shift the blame.

fos BM

, you complained about alabaska's wierd reach on you, and then do exactly the same to DI over there. also your play for this game has seen you madly flailing onto any lead possible.

fos q21

. after making sense of mellowed's post, it looks like he has a point there.



anything else? hm....


oh yes:

Spineless.

I stand by a RBT lynch.

is it supposed to be

a

RBT or

an

RBT? that's always confused me.

[kuribo]

Really not liking the opportunism behind Ala's last post.

Unvote, Vote: Alabaska J

with a warning to DizzyIzzy that I'll be watching you very closely.

raises the People's Eyebrow at DI

[Surye]

Is it just me, or is it a telling tell if it is hard to start a wagon on some guys who have more evidence against them, while it is really easy to start a huge wagon, leading to lynch -1 on someone else, who is not as scummy?

Why thank you Mellowed Man.

Also,

unvote, vote: q21

.

Opportunistic scum just got himself caught. It looks as though me and Bowel Movement over there might finally agree on something.

Lol opportunistic yourself.

Vote: Alabaska J

Now try and tell me you arent OMGUSsy scum, purely dominated by the will to survive.

I'm happy to lynch this damn fool whenever.

BM

Seriously, what the hell is Alabaska J playing at? RBT can wait,

Unvote, Vote: Alabaska J

for scummy play. (It rhymed! )

[DizzyIzzyB13]

That would be L-1, correct? And Alabaska hasn't claimed, has he? I believe that makes it CLAIM OR DIE time, no?

[Surye]

Yes, claim or die.