Mafia 79 - "The Amish Mafia" GAME OVER... WHO WON?

[Mellowed Man]

Interesting no-one at all has noticed my absence. So just who are we jumping on now MM has revealed (thinking he was dead)? I must say we're on a roll - two masons and the doc gone, and almost certainly the serial killer should have been gone. Is the aim of this game to get rid of all minor power roles?

That a grand enough welcome for you? FOS for being so damned cock-sure of himself and pretending a one-line post constitutes a well-reasoned argument and summation of damning evidence.

Can you elaborate? I don't know what you are talking about. And, by the way, Yes, we did notice that some people weren't posting.

almost certainly the serial killer should have been gone.

Are you kidding?

FoS: nwshorse

Unvote, vote Alabaska J

Also, just because Alabaska I FoSed BM right away, I was freaking out anyways when I was being bandwagoned. The fact that you are trying to link me to him is scummy.

[Alabaska J]

How? He jumped everyone off of your lynch for the wrong (no, really) reasons! Now that you are not hammered, we can possibly prove your night ability. And you are not a guaranteed nightkill, as the mafia may just let you live, and because you don't die, you will be the top lynch target for many tomorrow. However if we can somehow prove your night ability, we can avoid any possible wifom situations tomorrow. And if you are scum, the fact BM jumped off of your lynch first chance he got without giving a good reason is an obvious scum connection for me.

Also, BM, your post makes no sense. There is an obvious connection between you and Mellowed Man if he comes up scum. And what is this business about setting up multiple lynches? How am I doing that any more than you are and how in the fucking world does this connect me to Mellowed Man?

Also, Marmalade, I'm really looking forward to even less content in your post. You're pretty good now with the whole posting-no-evidence thing, but I feel you could post even less reasoning. You know, a two-word post or something.

[Battle Mage]

[quote="Alabaska J"]
Also, BM, your post makes no sense. There is an obvious connection between you and Mellowed Man if he comes up scum. And what is this business about setting up multiple lynches? How am I doing that any more than you are and how in the fucking world does this connect me to Mellowed Man?
quote]

Umm, what? Because i decided to bus my scumbuddy, then somehow MADE SURYE FAIL TO UNVOTE, and then defended him. You make literally no sense. Get out of the thread until you have taken your appropriate medication please.

BM

[Alabaska J]

Wrong. [hypothetical]You bussed your scumbuddy, he claims vig, makes a big show of being town, people kind of believe him, it turns out he was never lynched, then you change your mind about bussing him with his new claim and stance as a possibly confirmed townie, and jump on Riceballtail .[/hypothetical]

However, if neither of you are scum

which I am leaning towards

(there is a reason I am not voting either of you atm), then you just saved the vig. Congrats. Also, thank god for Riceballtail looking extremely scummy IMO.

Got it?

[Surye]

I'd like to see more on the Rice train.

[Mellowed Man]

unvote, vote Riceballtail

He started backtracking quickly once I wasn't lynched, too with that post about how he probably "did reach" just moments after the xyzzy update.

[Battle Mage]

Wrong. [hypothetical]You bussed your scumbuddy, he claims vig, makes a big show of being town, people kind of believe him, it turns out he was never lynched, then you change your mind about bussing him with his new claim and stance as a possibly confirmed townie, and jump on Riceballtail .[/hypothetical]

However, if neither of you are scum

which I am leaning towards

(there is a reason I am not voting either of you atm), then you just saved the vig. Congrats. Also, thank god for Riceballtail looking extremely scummy IMO.

Got it?

Eh? I didnt bus him UNTIL he claimed Vig as far as im aware. The claim was the main point against him. But, that aside, hypothetical situations arent usually all that helpful. I could make a similar situation up for 90% of the players in this game.

Also, umm, i didnt save the Vig. Surye did.

BM

[mr. incrediball]

Are we really? Well, I'll give mellowed one more shot, though I'd like to somehow work out a way to prove his ability.

unvote, vote Riceballtail

. I love how he didn't even try to defend himself.

Also, if Mellowed is scum, I'm perfectly fine with a BM lynch.

Don't you realize that the scum are going to kill me tonight no matter what?

Also, are you encouraging me to kill someone at night, of your choice? There really is no way I can prove it, because if you all get me to kill someone, there may be a mafia roleblocker, like there are in Newbie Games.

FoS: Alabaska J

i thought you said you were 1-shot?

[Battle Mage]

he changed his claim. lol

[Evilgorrilaz]

Vote: Alabaska J

Unless you are telling me that somehow MM managed to tell that surye's vote didn't count when everyone though it did, there is no way I am not believing his claim, especially since it was made during "twilight". You trying to tie him as scum to other players reeks.

[Mellowed Man]

unvote, vote Alabaska J

Right now, I don't trust certain people.

[Riceballtail]

Checking in, classwork has kept me busy the last few days. Hoping to get a good read soon.

[q21]

unvote

The fact that he persisted that he was a vig in twilight makes it much more believable that he actually is.

My new vote will probably go on either of Alabaska or Riceballtail, but I'd like to see how things develop before I decide which.

Both Rigel and VV have not posted once on D2 so far. Even though the day almost ended once.

MOD: Has VV got his prod? Can you prod Rigel too please?

On catching up a post I didn't like was this one by nswhorse. (The inderlining is mine.)

Interesting no-one at all has noticed my absence.

So just who are we jumping on now MM has revealed (thinking he was dead)?

I must say we're on a roll - two masons and the doc gone, and almost certainly the serial killer should have been gone. Is the aim of this game to get rid of all minor power roles?

FOS:

Battle Mage

That a grand enough welcome for you? FOS for being so damned cock-sure of himself and pretending a one-line post constitutes a well-reasoned argument and summation of damning evidence.

Its like he's willing to lynch anyone. Also I don't quite follow his FoS on BM. As such

FoS nswhorse

. So yeah, add nswhorse to that list of people I may vote for.

[Alabaska J]

Vote: Alabaska J

Unless you are telling me that somehow MM managed to tell that surye's vote didn't count when everyone though it did, there is no way I am not believing his claim, especially since it was made during "twilight". You trying to tie him as scum to other players reeks.

Dear god.

unvote, vote Evilgorrilaz

.

Think before you post. Did you even read what I said or did you see multiple votes on me, go to the first post in which I was voted, and copy-paste? BM did the exact same thing in response to me and he gets nothing. Obviously didn't read the thread. I'm not tying him to scum at all. I said if he comes up scum, I would look at BM. I never said I thought he was scum. I never said I thought BM was scum. Also, there is no way you can ever be sure of anyone's alignment in a situation like this. I too believe his claim, but because of the situation, if he happened to come up scum, I would look into BM.

@BM: You did save him. The

exact same thing happened day one

and the person was hammered soon afterwards. I'm sure something similar would have happened today had you not speedily unvoted.

One last thing:

unvote, vote Alabaska J

Right now, I don't trust certain people.

Can I have your babies please?

[Battle Mage]

I would look at BM. I never said I thought he was scum. I never said I thought BM was scum.

if he happened to come up scum, I would look into BM

lolwut?
Whats with you?? You are so keen to emphasise that you arent attacking me now, and you dont find me atall scummy, but inexplicably, you will be after my hide if someone i unvoted comes up scum, when in fact, several people have unvoted-i was just the first on the scene.

Also, there is no way you can ever be sure of anyone's alignment in a situation like this.

No shit!

That's mafia kiddo. But i'm really not buying your defence. It seems like you attempted to push multiple lynches, then when called on it, realised you had over-committed yourself, and backtracked, with the clear intention of bringing it up later. I'm not having it.

@BM: You did save him. The

exact same thing happened day one

and the person was hammered soon afterwards. I'm sure something similar would have happened today had you not speedily unvoted.

Are you an advert for terrible townsmanship?
Anyone who hammered in the same situation is an idiot.
I'm serious when i say your attitude truly befuddles me.

One last thing:

unvote, vote Alabaska J

Right now, I don't trust certain people.

Can I have your babies please?

meh, i hate cradle-snatchers.

Unvote, Vote: Alabaska J

BM

[mr. incrediball]

hmmm...


mellowed man... mellowed man...

1) i'm sorely tempted to go with LAL on this one. i can't see any motivation behind lying about the number of shots you have if you are town.

2) you're vote-hopping. a lot. calm down. not everyone who accuses you is guaranteed scum.

3) i don't get this whole "he claimed in twilight, he must be town" thing. i've been in plenty of games where players have maintained that they are town all the way up to the death scene, and then turned out scum.


Alabaska, on the other hand, also seems to be cracking under pressure. accusing people left, right, and centre.


I don't see enough evidence against riceballtail to constitute a lynch, considering all he did was reach a bit.

and BM is flip-flopping on the MM issue. He seemed to leap straight from "MM must be scum" to "Rice must be scum" without there seeming to be any moment of confusion in between the two conclusions.




so:

Major FOS: MM and Alabaska.
FOS: BM

[Battle Mage]

hmmm...


mellowed man... mellowed man...

1) i'm sorely tempted to go with LAL on this one. i can't see any motivation behind lying about the number of shots you have if you are town.

Maybe so he doesnt get NKed?

3) i don't get this whole "he claimed in twilight, he must be town" thing. i've been in plenty of games where players have maintained that they are town all the way up to the death scene, and then turned out scum.

This is true. In fact, i almost always do it. But i tend to think that newer players are less likely to. Not everyone is as sick as me.

and BM is flip-flopping on the MM issue. He seemed to leap straight from "MM must be scum" to "Rice must be scum" without there seeming to be any moment of confusion in between the two conclusions.

erm, dude, use some context please. In between me thinking MM was scum and my subsequent suspicions was the fake-twilight thing. Anyway being suspicious of multiple people is usually a town tell. Why would there be confusion??
Is that a towntell that i missed?

BM

[babygirl86]

wow guys I just realized I've highly been neglecting this game.... high apologies- the new semester just started and already its been kicking my ass. I'll do a reread here in a few and post my new thoughts

[mr. incrediball]

Maybe so he doesnt get NKed?

have you heard of a wonderful new invention? it's called a doc.

erm, dude, use some context please. In between me thinking MM was scum and my subsequent suspicions was the fake-twilight thing. Anyway being suspicious of multiple people is usually a town tell. Why would there be confusion??
Is that a towntell that i missed?

BM

meh. you just seemed to switch way too fast. i was reading, and it was like "woooosh!"

[Mellowed Man]

Maybe so he doesnt get NKed?

have you heard of a wonderful new invention? it's called a doc.

Have you noticed who's died in this game? Korts was a doctor.

[Battle Mage]

Maybe so he doesnt get NKed?

have you heard of a wonderful new invention? it's called a doc.

Have you noticed who's died in this game? Korts was a doctor.

thats a towntell for incrediball imho. An idiottell but a towntell too.

BM

[babygirl86]

Alright I semi finished the readthrough. i find it funny that mm told us that he would not be able to post until May 10(today) yet he has been posting quite a bit. Also, I don't like the fact that he changed his claim... which one are you- vig or one shot? make up your mind? I'm not sure how I feel about the alabaska bandwagon right now.... I still think mm is scum.. And with that my vote stays.

[babygirl86]

also it looks like our mod keeps forgetting about this game..... but just in case he hasn't

mod votecount please?

[Alabaska J]

I would look at BM. I never said I thought he [Mellowed Man] was scum. I never said I thought BM was scum.

if he happened to come up scum, I would look into BM

lolwut?
Whats with you?? You are so keen to emphasise that you arent attacking me now, and you dont find me atall scummy, but inexplicably, you will be after my hide if someone i unvoted comes up scum, when in fact, several people have unvoted-i was just the first on the scene.

Yes. I don't think you are scummy, but you will jump to the top of my list if Mellowed Man comes up scum because the interaction between you two at that point points to a possible scum connection. And yes several people unvoted. Also, several people had reasons. Not only were you "first on the scene," you had no reason to unvote.

Also, there is no way you can ever be sure of anyone's alignment in a situation like this.

No shit!

That's mafia kiddo. But i'm really not buying your defence. It seems like you attempted to push multiple lynches, then when called on it, realised you had over-committed yourself, and backtracked, with the clear intention of bringing it up later. I'm not having it.

How the fuck did I push multiple lynches? Where is this bs coming from? All I stated was that if Mellowed Man

ever

came up scum (whether from a nightkill or a situation that occurs later in the game that causes him to be lynched (counter-claim or something)), I would look into BM first, because of the actions that occurred at the point in time when Mellowed Man was about to be lynched.

@BM: You did save him. The

exact same thing happened day one

and the person was hammered soon afterwards. I'm sure something similar would have happened today had you not speedily unvoted.

Are you an advert for terrible townsmanship?
Anyone who hammered in the same situation is an idiot.
I'm serious when i say your attitude truly befuddles me.

Doesn't prevent it from happening. We have our fair share of idiots here at Mafia Scum.

One last thing:

unvote, vote Alabaska J

Right now, I don't trust certain people.

Can I have your babies please?

meh, i hate cradle-snatchers.

Unvote, Vote: Alabaska J

BM

Haha I meant somehow give birth to his children (even though I am a man). That is how in love with Mellowed Man I am after that post.

[Battle Mage]

I would look at BM. I never said I thought he [Mellowed Man] was scum. I never said I thought BM was scum.

if he happened to come up scum, I would look into BM

lolwut?
Whats with you?? You are so keen to emphasise that you arent attacking me now, and you dont find me atall scummy, but inexplicably, you will be after my hide if someone i unvoted comes up scum, when in fact, several people have unvoted-i was just the first on the scene.

Yes. I don't think you are scummy, but you will jump to the top of my list if Mellowed Man comes up scum because the interaction between you two at that point points to a possible scum connection. And yes several people unvoted. Also, several people had reasons. Not only were you "first on the scene," you had no reason to unvote.

WTF? Yes i did. I unvoted because he sounded genuine, and to some extent confirmed himself.

Also, there is no way you can ever be sure of anyone's alignment in a situation like this.

No shit!

That's mafia kiddo. But i'm really not buying your defence. It seems like you attempted to push multiple lynches, then when called on it, realised you had over-committed yourself, and backtracked, with the clear intention of bringing it up later. I'm not having it.

How the fuck did I push multiple lynches? Where is this bs coming from? All I stated was that if Mellowed Man

ever

came up scum (whether from a nightkill or a situation that occurs later in the game that causes him to be lynched (counter-claim or something)), I would look into BM first, because of the actions that occurred at the point in time when Mellowed Man was about to be lynched.

thats pushing multiple lynches! And on poor grounds too, seeing as ANYONE town would have unvoted at that point. I'm sure you would claim to do the same, hence i find your attack grossly hypocritical.

@BM: You did save him. The

exact same thing happened day one

and the person was hammered soon afterwards. I'm sure something similar would have happened today had you not speedily unvoted.

Are you an advert for terrible townsmanship?
Anyone who hammered in the same situation is an idiot.
I'm serious when i say your attitude truly befuddles me.

Doesn't prevent it from happening. We have our fair share of idiots here at Mafia Scum.

...true dat.

BM