Mafia 79 - "The Amish Mafia" GAME OVER... WHO WON?

[The Fonz]

Which is fine. If they don't claim now, they lose the opportunity to claim later.

[Evilgorrilaz]

No access until Wednesday
Just finished my AP comp gov test, need to study for AP calc bc, comp sci, and stat

[Alabaska J]

Yep same here with stat and AB DX

[Battle Mage]

Right, ValiantValiant, you're first up.

Mason or Not Mason?

BM

[q21]

Just a heads up. I have a monster project due for Friday and as such I will be on self imposed limited access until this weekend. I will try to keep up, respond to any direct questions and vote where necessary. But don't expect any in depth play from me until the weekend.

unvote, vote Mellowed Man

At this point Mellowed Man is just very scummy. His vig claim is dodgy, both in its timing and in that he never listed who he thought was scummy. As such we have no idea if he really thought Korts was mafia or is just making the convenient excuse... Also, what pro-town vig kills on night one?

There are a number of players who haven't shown any signs on life yet on day 2. I think prods are in order. What ValiantValant has to say today is something that interests me as he was under a bit of pressure yesterday.

[Battle Mage]

just ftr, i dont understand the argument that a town vig should not kill on N1. Firstly, it isnt N0-the vig has had time to find people suspicious. Secondly, even a N0 Vig is not a terrible play, if it is used on a total imbecile. lol
Plus if he WAS a 1-shot vig, i could see alot of logic in him firing earlier rather than later.

BM

[Alabaska J]

Plus if he WAS a 1-shot vig, i could see alot of logic in him firing earlier rather than later.

I think quite the contrary. If you are one-shot, you should wait until you are closer to endgame and have more information so that you can use your kill more wisely. This makes his claim less legitimate IMO.

[Alabaska J]

Also,

prod ValientValent

.

[xyzzy]

Amish Mafia votecount 2-1

babygirl86: Surye, Mellowed Man
Mellowed Man: babygirl86, Battle Mage, Alabaska J, riceballtail, The Fonz, q21


Not voting: Killa Seven, Evilgorrilaz, nswhorse, Celebloki, Marmalade, Inquisitor JL, Rigel, Mr. Incrediball, ValiantValant

Prodding ValiantValant as per post 307.

[Battle Mage]

Plus if he WAS a 1-shot vig, i could see alot of logic in him firing earlier rather than later.

I think quite the contrary. If you are one-shot, you should wait until you are closer to endgame and have more information so that you can use your kill more wisely. This makes his claim less legitimate IMO.

I disagree. After Day 1 he was always going to be high on the list of suspects, and i can see some logic in him wanting to use his kill in order to confirm himself, if he was worried about his immediate future. You'd be amazed how many times i see these 1/2 shot power roles using their shots early on.

BM

[q21]

BM - one problem I have in believing that that is the case is that he never mentioned that he suspected korts. If you plan on killing night one to confirm yourself then you need to give some sort of indication that you think the person you're going to kill is scummy.

[Battle Mage]

BM - one problem I have in believing that that is the case is that he never mentioned that he suspected korts. If you plan on killing night one to confirm yourself then you need to give some sort of indication that you think the person you're going to kill is scummy.

hmm, thats a valid point, although its possible that he didnt plan that far ahead. Either way, i dont think he IS a Vig, so this convo is pretty irrelevant. Im just pointing these things out from a general perspective.

BM

[Celebloki]

I apologize for my absence in the past few days, I will do a read-through and post a little later today as I am rather busy at work.

[Celebloki]

After reading through the posts made, including my D1 suspicions when MM was supporting VV about the sickness thing but then still voted him(still makes no sense to me) along with everything that I have seen today I can't not

Vote: Mellowed Man

.

His last 4 posts as well as his one shot vig claim solidified it. He did not even state he thought korts was the scummiest person he saw, he just didn't like how he was going after him. Then the string of almost pity seeking posts he made about his finals was even worse. I think even if he is a one shot vig hes proven to be rather useless to the town. That aside however I believe he reeks of scum or SK as BM has said.

[Battle Mage]

i think that is -2.

BM

[mr. incrediball]

i don't really think MM is telling the truth. he seems to be attempting to pull the wool over our eyes using a 1-shot killing role to cover his bases.

also, has anyone considered that this "cutting his computer time" is just an excuse to deadbeat?

i'll put him at l-1 for you. it'll be YOUR choice to lynch him.

vote mellowedman

.

[Celebloki]

i'll put him at l-1 for you. it'll be YOUR choice to lynch him.

This line confuses me, who does it refer to?

[Battle Mage]

Claim-time.

BM

[q21]

He already claimed...

[Surye]

Claim-time.

BM

He did claim though, if he changes his claim, LAL. Either way, he's going. I'd be willing to hammer, if someone doesn't get to it before I get to a quick pre-hammer re-read.

[Battle Mage]

Claim-time.

BM

He did claim though, if he changes his claim, LAL. Either way, he's going. I'd be willing to hammer, if someone doesn't get to it before I get to a quick pre-hammer re-read.

I knew that. -.-

*slaps self awake*

Someone hammer then. Also, LAL sucks!

BM

[Mellowed Man]

Aww man, I'm scared the mafia will kill me at night. That's why I claimed one-shot, maybe they'll think I'm useless.

Anyways, BM is an idiot for forgetting I claimed, how can he forget that?


Also, I'll as the vigilante kill whoever the town wants me to kill at night, if you wish, but I'm basically dead already, and the mafia will hammer now, so have fun everyone, I've made a lot of mistakes, but that's part of the game.

So have fun!

P.S.
Since when do I have to say why I want to kill someone. Korts called me a hypocrite at the beginning of the game, and was always wanting to kill me.

[Battle Mage]

Aww man, I'm scared the mafia will kill me at night. That's why I claimed one-shot, maybe they'll think I'm useless.

Anyways, BM is an idiot for forgetting I claimed, how can he forget that?


Also, I'll as the vigilante kill whoever the town wants me to kill at night, if you wish, but I'm basically dead already, and the mafia will hammer now, so have fun everyone, I've made a lot of mistakes, but that's part of the game.

So have fun!

P.S.
Since when do I have to say why I want to kill someone. Korts called me a hypocrite at the beginning of the game, and was always wanting to kill me.

I play alot of games. Actually, forgetting who was claimed is a scumtell for me.

BM

[Surye]

Aww man, I'm scared the mafia will kill me at night. That's why I claimed one-shot, maybe they'll think I'm useless.

Anyways, BM is an idiot for forgetting I claimed, how can he forget that?


Also, I'll as the vigilante kill whoever the town wants me to kill at night, if you wish, but I'm basically dead already, and the mafia will hammer now, so have fun everyone, I've made a lot of mistakes, but that's part of the game.

So have fun!

P.S.
Since when do I have to say why I want to kill someone. Korts called me a hypocrite at the beginning of the game, and was always wanting to kill me.

"Next person who votes me is scum" I hate that defense. Also you're saying you lied about your role. You were given a chance.

Vote: Mellowed Man

[Mellowed Man]

Alright, I'm dead, and I was a VIG. =)

Sorry to Korts, and FOS Surye for being really active Day 1, and now doing this.