You know what's funny? That I think alvinz95 now feels more protown than scum. Why? Mmm, why would he (a relative newbie) would suspect Elias (an experieced player) and for a weak reason? Wouldnt newbie scum avoid this kind of players? Also, I liked his theory where he involved some players and myself. Im involved but it seems a valid scumhunting. So, I dont know where this alvinz wagon come from. (And I know that at the beginning I said something like "There's something that feels wrong in his posts", but with all that has been posted after, I sincerely think he feels more agressive townie that silly scum")
Therefore, I will like to ask some questions:
CC09 wrote:Avinz95 is catching my suspician as well, mellows logic seems to be heading in the right direction.
Can you elaborate in this, please?
Gaspode wrote:For now, I will vote: alvinz95. Partly based on Mellowed's logic of being agreeable and careful, also somewhat based on the fact that he seems to be trying to take charge of the game and be extremely helpful.
Sometimes this means someone's just a useful pro-town person, but it can also be a scum tactic
(especially for someone who's been around for a few months--long enough to be trying different stuff like that, but not long enough to know it is extremely difficult to pull off). Finally, post 101 is one of the worst posts of this game--in addition to many other problems, the quote about "he is BY FAR not on my scum list"
is either incredibly stupid townness (starting Elias off on the innocent side of the spectrum, rather than in the middle) or more unnecessary scum friendliness.
If your suspcions can go either way, .-null tells FTW-, why are you voting him?
Elias wrote:correct, upon correction. Defensiveness is a major strong point of my town and scum play
Fixed.
Elias wrote:So yeah, I'm still totally undecided, as I like to wait until I've examined tells from every angle before jumping into a decision
Go,go,go.
Mellowed man wrote:Alvinz seems to be the either "totally defensive" or "totally agreeing personality."
At the same time, I just have an instinct he is scum.
Can you qoute some lines where you've found
this personality
? What do you think about Evilgorrilaz)
Elias wrote:Tajo: more agressive than I saw in my last game with him
And that means...
Elias wrote:Evil Gorillaz: lulz, doesnt understand pretentious
Any comments on the love for bandwagons?
iamausername wrote:Well, if there's a certain player that a lot of people say in thread is pro-town, and no one thinks is scummy, scum will be likely to NK them because they'll know for sure that they'll have trouble getting a bandwagon going on that person, and there won't really be any way to link them to the kill. I mean, sure, to a certain extent, they can find the most townie looking players without our help, but people stating it in thread just gives them a more definite idea of their best targets without any particular benefit to the town.
Can I add you to my protown L-list?
alvin wrote:It is as if he's asking his scum partner to back him up on this. Saying "Do YOU feel it?". Other wise, he's trying to start a wagon with that question, which is scummy considering he started it without even getting on it.
You said it was a stretch, and it is. Its nice scumhunting, though, shows some effort, but it doesnt make sense becuase I sincerely didnt want to start a wagon on you. Just I dont know why I didnt like that post of yours.
I did a quick reread, and a quicked copy-paste, so I may have missed some things.
Conclusions:
I still like my Evilgorrilaz vote, (where is he?)
I dont understand yet the Alvin wagon
I like iamasuername, Marmalade, maybe Gaspode.
I dont like Evilgorrilaz, Mellowed Man.
I think we should prod lurkers.
Neutral about other players.
And we're pretty fcked up becuase Elias is scum. (Thats a joke, guys.)
Call me Tajo.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=12894
Coming summer 2010: Tajo's Starcraft Mafia.
Tajo's MagictheGathering Mafia