-GLaDOS
Guardian 2 (Incognito, Ether)
Not Voting: Gorrad, Guardian, Miztef, Your Worst Nightmare
The fact that Ether has provided evenEther wrote:By the way, Incognito is even more obvobvtown because he's voting Guardian. If he were a serial killer, no-lynch would be the safer route for him.
If Guardian is lynched today and does turn up town, I will do whatever the general town consensus is.Gorrad wrote:Incognito, please don't kill if Guardian turns up town.
1. That depends on night actions, doesn't it?Guardian wrote:vote: no lynch
"The plan", though it has faults, is much better than lynching me.
What are you going to do when I turn up town and there's 4 -- or 3 -- people alive tomorrow?
Lynch Ether? Lynch Incognito? Lynch YWN? Lynch Miztef?
You'll have no flipping idea what to do, because you'll have wasted today lynching me for -- ostensibly -- role-based reasons -- reasons that are leading to a completely incorrect conclusion.
No one's concretely critiqued my play in the slightest, you're just saying "oh, well, Guardian must be scum... vote."
Oh, and Incognito's note about the night 1 kill is bogus, especially since Sir T was around to make the no hide choice.
You're also ignoring how I claimed a role that did nothing N1, and Hid N2 -- that fits in perfectly with Ether's claim, that I had no way of knowing anything about. Lyching me today is a great way to start pulling defeat out of the jaws of victory.
We've got 2 scum dead, let's not throw the game away, please. Thanks.
Huh?Gorrad wrote:1. That depends on night actions, doesn't it?
The plan *has* problems: if Incognito is a SK, for instance. However, It is better than lynching me and going to night with no kill.Gorrad wrote:2. Alright. Guardian must be scum because of how much pressure he put on a working plan
wtf -- you think the scum have no role that illudes your restults? we've lynched 2 goons. you think I'm scum and ether and incog are town:Gorrad wrote:as well as my results
huh?Gorrad wrote:and Incognito's points.
no shit. my no hide is *ALSO* consistent with everyone else's claims, *despite* my claiming first. that's on *everyone's* word.Gorrad wrote:3. That there was a no-hide is on your word alone
This is idiocy. We're doing really well, and there are 6 alive. We can afford to lynch a townie, since tomorrow won't -- OH WAIT. Tomorrow WILL be lylo, for 100% certainty if you lynch me, unless ether blocks scum AND incognito no kills.Gorrad wrote:4. We're doing really well. We can afford to take a gamble like this that has odds so much in our favor.
No it wouldn't. Because he knows that by doing exactly that, he'd make you believe he is viggean and not SK.Ether wrote:By the way, Incognito is even more obvobvtown because he's voting Guardian. If he were a serial killer, no-lynch would be the safer route for him.
I would like to know HOW she was able to determine that, and why she only revealed it AFTER you yourself said you were a viggean.Incognito wrote:I like the fact that Ether was able to surmise that I was the other killer based on the information she drew from the thread and through her own abilities if she is in fact the roleblocker.
Yet you keep your vote...Incognito wrote:Anyway, I'd advise that nobody hammers in the meantime. I would like to go back through the thread to see if I could find anything that might implicate someone else as the possible scum partner for Flameaxe and The Jester.
What's wrong with that?Your Worst Nightmare wrote:Yet you keep your vote...Incognito wrote:Anyway, I'd advise that nobody hammers in the meantime. I would like to go back through the thread to see if I could find anything that might implicate someone else as the possible scum partner for Flameaxe and The Jester.
Incognito wrote:Also, you're criticizing Gorrad for not thinking that the mod might have placed a mafia role in the game to counteract his investigative abilities but you're completely ignoring the fact that Gorrad himself could be mafia who could have some ability to counteract the weak doctor and you, the so-called hider. Why haven't you considered that? Is it because youknowhe's town and not lying about his role?
If Guardian is lynched as mafia today and the game doesn't end, Incognito will be lynched next, no questions asked. If he's a serial killer, his only chance to win is to keep the last mafiate alive until LyLo.Post 511, YWN wrote:No it wouldn't. Because he knows that by doing exactly that, he'd make you believe he is viggean and not SK.
And even so, no-lynch WOULDN'T be the safer route for him anyway. The quicker he disposes of people, the less likely people start doubting his claim. And the more easier and faster his job becomes (being the last one alive).
Process of elimination. Like I said, I wanted to see if Incognito would claim the kills without knowing that I would get him lynched/blockspammed if he didn't.Post 511, YWN wrote:I would like to know HOW she was able to determine that, and why she only revealed it AFTER you yourself said you were a viggean.
You wouldn't have been told you were roleblocked. Hiders don't get results. It's irrelevant.Post 506, Guardian wrote:You're also ignoring how I claimed a role that did nothing N1, and Hid N2 -- that fits in perfectly with Ether's claim, that I had no way of knowing anything about.