Scummies 2010 Nominations

[jmj3000]

Nominate KittyMo Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion/The wiki - "Professor Mafia" Award

For her work in smoothing out the "Gameplay Improvement" thread and offering advice to people wherein (work in progress). Seriously, she combed the thread, organized it, and gave advice to a summer. AND no one even asked her to.

Second

Third

[Andrius]

Forgot to do this earlier, but I'm nominating

AlmasterGM

for the

Funniest Player

award for his performance in Choose Your Side: A Comedy of Whims, plus the Night Action PMs he sent me in that game.

I also nominate him for

Best Third Party

performance for the same game. It's not often that you can get away with not only claiming Third Party, but also claiming cult, and still win the game. Plus, his quasi-fakeclaim kept people fooled for multiple game-days, and he was very conniving with persuading a town player into joining the cult over taking a sure-fire town win.

HEY. I JOINED HIS CULT BECAUSE I WANTED TO WIN AS CULT.
I DIDNT DO IT BECAUSE HE DUPED ME. I WAS GUARANTEED THE WIN NO MATTER WHICH SIDE I CHOSE.
I JUST CHOSE AGM OVER SSBF.
HE DIDN'T "PERSUADE" ME TO JOIN, I JOINED BECAUSE I WAS SELFISH AND GREEDY AND REALLY WANTED TO WIN AS A CULT.

BUT YEAH.

Nth AlmasterGM for Funniest Player (despite him berating me publically) and Best Third Party

<3,
Stephen Gevanni

[CSL]

Nominate KittyMo Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion/The wiki - "Professor Mafia" Award

For her work in smoothing out the "Gameplay Improvement" thread and offering advice to people wherein (work in progress). Seriously, she combed the thread, organized it, and gave advice to a summer. AND no one even asked her to.

Second

Third

A TOTALLY deserved Fourth

[KittyMo]

I'm flattered, but that's really not deserving of a Scummy. I hope that one day I will complete a similar project actually deserving of that award.

Thanks for the appreciation anyway, though.

[danakillsu]

Nominate Star Wars Mafia for Best Setup

I think it just had the perfect mix of roles. Very balanced and lots of fun.

Seconded!

This was my first game on mafiascum.net and to date I can never recall laughing so hard, or more maniacally.

Looooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooved this game. Love Love Love Love Love.

:O
This has never been thirded???????????????????????????????????????????????????
:O
Totally

Thirded

If you can read this game and not be amazed........
You suck. That is all.
And yeah, I did complain a little bit about the way the setup worked at the end of the game, but all things considered, the setup really was cool, and the mod was da best.

[bv310]

Nominate Star Wars Mafia for Best Setup

I think it just had the perfect mix of roles. Very balanced and lots of fun.

Seconded!

This was my first game on mafiascum.net and to date I can never recall laughing so hard, or more maniacally.

Looooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooved this game. Love Love Love Love Love.

:O
This has never been thirded???????????????????????????????????????????????????
:O
Totally

Thirded

If you can read this game and not be amazed........
You suck. That is all.
And yeah, I did complain a little bit about the way the setup worked at the end of the game, but all things considered, the setup really was cool, and the mod was da best.

Ah, fuck it.

N'thd

[ReaperCharlie]

bv310, you DO know, don't you, that a certain line you said in that game directly resulted in somebody else's user title, right?

See my wiki if you're confused. kek

[bv310]

I know, and stand by what I said. Those were loaves.

[Antihero]

Nominate Flameaxe for Smooth Operator Award

NY 118: BBM's Large Normal Mafia

He was quick with the vote counts, replacements, prods, and night actions for the entirety of the time I was there (day 2-day 8); this is very praiseworthy, especially in a large game.

[singersigner]

Nominate Flameaxe for Smooth Operator Award

NY 118: BBM's Large Normal Mafia

He was quick with the vote counts, replacements, prods, and night actions for the entirety of the time I was there (day 2-day 8); this is very praiseworthy, especially in a large game.

Second.

AND he found someone who was willing to replace into a 92-page game. Legit.

[evilpacman18]

Nominate Flameaxe for Smooth Operator Award

NY 118: BBM's Large Normal Mafia

He was quick with the vote counts, replacements, prods, and night actions for the entirety of the time I was there (day 2-day 8); this is very praiseworthy, especially in a large game.

Second.

AND he found someone who was willing to replace into a 92-page game. Legit.

Third

For letting me replace in as Godfather in a large game without any previous experience on this site.

[evilpacman18]

Also, if I'm allowed to do more than one, I wanna

nominate EtherDent

for best replacement in NY118

[Ether]

Eh. I'm flattered, of course, but the bottom line is we really didn't

do

that much aside from agree to replace into a 96-page game. (Well, Yosarian actually read a lot of it, but we didn't really affect the outcome.)

Having said that, if anyone else needs a replacement and is cool with hydras, feel free to drop us a line.

[danakillsu]

Nominate Flameaxe for Smooth Operator Award

NY 118: BBM's Large Normal Mafia

He was quick with the vote counts, replacements, prods, and night actions for the entirety of the time I was there (day 2-day 8); this is very praiseworthy, especially in a large game.

Second.

AND he found someone who was willing to replace into a 92-page game. Legit.

Third

For letting me replace in as Godfather in a large game without any previous experience on this site.

Don't think this matters, but

Fourthed

Great game, great mod, just missed winning (see Antihero's sig).

[Bunnylover]

Nominate Flameaxe for Smooth Operator Award

NY 118: BBM's Large Normal Mafia

He was quick with the vote counts, replacements, prods, and night actions for the entirety of the time I was there (day 2-day 8); this is very praiseworthy, especially in a large game.

Second.

AND he found someone who was willing to replace into a 92-page game. Legit.

Third

For letting me replace in as Godfather in a large game without any previous experience on this site.

Don't think this matters, but

Fourthed

Great game, great mod, just missed winning (see Antihero's sig).

Fifth

Awesome game .

[SaintKerrigan]

Forgot to do this earlier, but I'm nominating

AlmasterGM

for the

Funniest Player

award for his performance in Choose Your Side: A Comedy of Whims, plus the Night Action PMs he sent me in that game.

I also nominate him for

Best Third Party

performance for the same game. It's not often that you can get away with not only claiming Third Party, but also claiming cult, and still win the game. Plus, his quasi-fakeclaim kept people fooled for multiple game-days, and he was very conniving with persuading a town player into joining the cult over taking a sure-fire town win.

HEY. I JOINED HIS CULT BECAUSE I WANTED TO WIN AS CULT.
I DIDNT DO IT BECAUSE HE DUPED ME. I WAS GUARANTEED THE WIN NO MATTER WHICH SIDE I CHOSE.
I JUST CHOSE AGM OVER SSBF.
HE DIDN'T "PERSUADE" ME TO JOIN, I JOINED BECAUSE I WAS SELFISH AND GREEDY AND REALLY WANTED TO WIN AS A CULT.

BUT YEAH.

Nth AlmasterGM for Funniest Player (despite him berating me publically) and Best Third Party

<3,
Stephen Gevanni

I never said he duped you. He just played his cards right and chose the best person to invite to the cult in the endgame (imagine what would've happened if the invite went out to SSBF instead, or CSL). He also had people convinced that he had NK and lynch immunities, when it was really only a NK immunity.

Regardless of how you view it, definitely a worthy performance!

[Scummies]

Updated as of 765

[Mert]

He also had people convinced that he had NK and lynch immunities, when it was really only a NK immunity.

I haven't read the game but anyone who can convince a town that an entirely unkillable cult recruiter is in any way balanced deserves to win. Mental.

[ReaperCharlie]

Nominate Flameaxe for Smooth Operator Award

NY 118: BBM's Large Normal Mafia

He was quick with the vote counts, replacements, prods, and night actions for the entirety of the time I was there (day 2-day 8); this is very praiseworthy, especially in a large game.

Second.

AND he found someone who was willing to replace into a 92-page game. Legit.

Nth'd.

[SaintKerrigan]

Updated as of 765

For the game name in both the AlmasterGM "Funniest Player" and "Best Performance Third Party" nominations, "Comedy" is misspelled as "Compedy".

[Andrius]

He just played his cards right and chose the best person to invite to the cult in the endgame (imagine what would've happened if the invite went out to SSBF instead, or CSL).

And I totally abused the fact that he'd recruit me over anyone else to guarantee myself with a win. I could have won with either team.
I do agree that he played exceedingly well though. <3 Hades/Ares FTW

[ReaperCharlie]

I would like to nominate

Plum 'n Andy's The Lord of the Rings Mafia

for the

Most Enjoyable Game

award.

Also for the

Best Game Ever

award. lol <3

[Mariyta]

I would like to nominate

Plum 'n Andy's The Lord of the Rings Mafia

for the

Most Enjoyable Game

award.

Also for the

Best Game Ever

award. lol <3

Seconded and seconded.

[bv310]

I would like to nominate

Plum 'n Andy's The Lord of the Rings Mafia

for the

Most Enjoyable Game

award.

Also for the

Best Game Ever

award. lol <3

Seconded and seconded.

Thirded on both accounts

[gandalf5166]

I can't really say, as I was vigged N1. But it sure was an interesting read. That dead QT is awesome.