Mini 1830 - Game Over

[CCC]

@Grendel Sure. I will give it a try.

Wonderful.

So do you have any prior experience with anybody on the roster?

How do you feel about VictorDeAngelo and CCC?

To turn your question around, I do not have any prior experience with eagerSnake. Nor, for that matter, with anyone else on the roster.

If you like, I can point you to the two newbie games I played in, so you can see how I play. In summary, I know how to do probability calculations, but tend to rely too heavily on them (and at times I forget that other people do not speak math like I do). On day one, reads are too imprecise for my mathematical approach to be of all that much help; and while I can math like anything, my ability to actually read people is poor.

That's pretty much me in a nutshell. Would anyone else like to briefly introduce themselves?

[Square World]

Three mafia sounds about right to me.

let me guess, you're one, right?

VOTE: CCC

[Grendel]

For example, I’d like some clarification weather your vote on me is because you disagree with my play, or if you actually think I’m scum. See, while you raise valid points on why you disagree with how I opened you didn't say you thought I was scum.

I don't think you're scum (yet). Using the vote power can have various goals. In this case, I wanted to skip rvs bullshit and provoke some meaningful discussion right off the bat. Unfortunately I didn't get the results I wanted.

Why are you so concerned about my reason of voting you?

Shoot me a few guesses why I might question your vote. If you can't come to a consensus on your own then I'll tell you why.

What counts as meaningful for you?

I could see this becoming a meaningful conversation if we keep going.

[The_Jester]

I asked first so don't you turn this on me and make me answer for you.

[Grendel]

@Grendel Sure. I will give it a try.

Wonderful.

So do you have any prior experience with anybody on the roster?

How do you feel about VictorDeAngelo and CCC?

To turn your question around, I do not have any prior experience with eagerSnake. Nor, for that matter, with anyone else on the roster.

If you like, I can point you to the two newbie games I played in, so you can see how I play. In summary, I know how to do probability calculations, but tend to rely too heavily on them (and at times I forget that other people do not speak math like I do). On day one, reads are too imprecise for my mathematical approach to be of all that much help; and while I can math like anything, my ability to actually read people is poor.

That's pretty much me in a nutshell. Would anyone else like to briefly introduce themselves?

Actually CCC I've seen both Frozen landscapes, and Wake's role madness. Though my focus when spectating both those games wasn't you, I do recall you struggling with wordiness. And you praising Boring a whole lot.

[CCC]

Three mafia sounds about right to me.

let me guess, you're one, right?

VOTE: CCC

No, actually I'm not.

[CCC]

Actually CCC I've seen both Frozen landscapes, and Wake's role madness. Though my focus when spectating both those games wasn't you, I do recall you struggling with wordiness. And you praising Boring a whole lot.

Boring did play a brilliant game. I know I will be far more suspicious of her in any future games; she's going to find it a lot harder to fool me twice.

[Grendel]

I asked first so don't you turn this on me and make me answer for you.

Hmm, I was hoping to drag this out a bit until I found something telling from another player I've got my eyes on. :/

If I can't find what I'm looking for in several hours I'll go ahead and open up.

[Grendel]

Actually CCC I've seen both Frozen landscapes, and Wake's role madness. Though my focus when spectating both those games wasn't you, I do recall you struggling with wordiness. And you praising Boring a whole lot.

Boring did play a brilliant game. I know I will be far more suspicious of her in any future games; she's going to find it a lot harder to fool me twice.

Yeah, Boring did play well. I probably would have made the same decision as IV did at lylo.

[eagerSnake]

I have 2 people in my town block, and 1 person I know is scum.

I don't have any relevant experience with anyone in this game. I have off-site chat mafia experience with Gamma and gerryoat, but not enough to deem useful.

VOTE: Gamma Emerald

Kudos to anyone who can explain how I know this is scum based on his 5 posts.

[Gamma Emerald]

Well then. Looks like it's my first game all over again. Eager, I don't know what you're thinking, but you're going the wrong path.

[Gamma Emerald]

The only thing possibly incriminating is post 39, and that's not even that bad.

[eagerSnake]

Why would 39 be incriminating?

[Gamma Emerald]

Knowledge of the setup. And you are admitting you have nothing to go on.

[eagerSnake]

To me 39 seems like you are part of a 3-man mafia team and possibly worried about a 3rd party. 3 mafia and 1 3rd party wasn't even an option that I was giving as that would be mafia-favored.

[gerryoat]

i really doubt there is a 3 man mafia team and a 3rd party in an 11 man setup tho

[eagerSnake]

There shouldn't be.. unless there is only 2-3 VTs and 4-5 town PRs.

[Gamma Emerald]

To me 39 seems like you are part of a 3-man mafia team and possibly worried about a 3rd party. 3 mafia and 1 3rd party wasn't even an option that I was giving as that would be mafia-favored.

Where is the connection?

[eagerSnake]

Not sure what you're asking me..

I'm saying I didn't even give 3 mafia and 1 3rd party as a possibility, and that you came up with that one on your own.. It feels like you inexplicably know there is 3 mafia but are only unsure about the 3rd party... if that is what you're asking

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm pretty sure there is 3 mafia. There could be two, but I don't know because I'm not one.

[eagerSnake]

Gamma feels like town here.

VOTE: Unvote

Someone else's turn now. Fiance is getting mad that I'm on here too much tonight.

[Manuel87]

is your avi log horizon? it's my fav anime lol

Yes it is.

For setup speculation my guess would be 3 maf and 3 town PRs.
2 maf would probably mean a 3rd party or our PRs are weak/limited to one-shot.
3 maf and 3rd party seems unlikely.

[gerryoat]

Why does Gamma feel like town? I feel like what he's said is basically what I've said when it comes to the setup. Also, I still think it's not needed to talk about what kinda PRs we have

[The_Jester]

^stop speculating

Snake's quick unvote after being so convinced his target's scum when Gamma didn't even provide much of a defense seems like poor attempt of trying to appear active which I don't like. Could be seen as scum soft pushing scum to distance themselves but it's too early to say. I must commend Snake for his observation though.
@Gamma why would you think your setup spec in 39 is incriminating in Snake's eyes when he's also done the same? The only reason I can think of is you knew you slipped with that 3 mafia thing.

[VictorDeAngelo]

My vote on eagerSnake is now a serious vote.