Mafia 72: Peril in Panama - Game over!

[curiouskarmadog]

that was probably my worst game ever...I thought BM was going to submit the kill (very little conversation from him at night) the first night when I realized we had a 72 hours it was too late...the next day I was just at a loss and played like ass, thought my gambit with ABR would have saved me from lynching..but it didnt....I was not surprised when BM didnt send a NK night 2....I was however surprised to see that he made it to the last 3..

town, you got lucky because the mafia was disorganized and played horridly...

this was an embarassment...but I learned much..thanks for the game.

[JDodge]

that was probably my worst game ever...

Worse than self-hammering as a townie in lylo in a newbie game?

/stalks

[farside22]

Well I thought before everything happened that DP was scum. After the cop died I think BM was the clear mafia at that point. Thanks to all. Pete_d good job catching BooKitty that clearly helped the town out too.

[Mastermind of Sin]

shit...
Not alot i can say. Of course, i'm confirmed town barring a doc counterclaim, but i did fuck up last night. Anyway, this game should be wrapped up tomorrow.
Lynch DP then, and we should still win. Oh and MoS, you are officially a moron. I find your last post deeply insulting, and when you see your mistake, i fully expect an apology.

BM

Too bad I was 100% right about you. Read you like a fucking book, kthnxbai.

Good job town. This game was weird cuz there were only 14 people to begin with. I'm used to like 20 player games, so 3 mafia seemed too easy.

[Battle Mage]

shit...
Not alot i can say. Of course, i'm confirmed town barring a doc counterclaim, but i did fuck up last night. Anyway, this game should be wrapped up tomorrow.
Lynch DP then, and we should still win. Oh and MoS, you are officially a moron. I find your last post deeply insulting, and when you see your mistake, i fully expect an apology.

BM

Too bad I was 100% right about you. Read you like a fucking book, kthnxbai.

Good job town. This game was weird cuz there were only 14 people to begin with. I'm used to like 20 player games, so 3 mafia seemed too easy.

rofl. Or not. you couldnt have read me more wrongly if you tried. I was pleased to see you using the meta from clue to suggest that i could just be Vanilla, but i thought it was great that you went from swearing i was scum to swearing blind i was confirmed town within the space of 1 post. Of course, i knew you'd realise your mistake when DP came up town, hence i NKed you and hoped Pete D wasnt paying attention. lol

I was genuinely surprised that there was no more scum in this game. We were pretty fucked from the start, and it could have been a total walkover for the town, but i think i made a bit of a game of it at least, even if victory was impossible.

Oh and MoS, i stand by my Moron comment. I was the only scum, and so your talk about me sacrificing myself in order to help a buddy win was pretty silly.

Ill try and comment more later.

BM

[Dragon Phoenix]

Thanks for taking over the modding Patrick.

[Mastermind of Sin]

rofl. Or not. you couldnt have read me more wrongly if you tried. I was pleased to see you using the meta from clue to suggest that i could just be Vanilla, but i thought it was great that you went from swearing i was scum to swearing blind i was confirmed town within the space of 1 post. Of course, i knew you'd realise your mistake when DP came up town, hence i NKed you and hoped Pete D wasnt paying attention. lol

Umm, what? What meta from Clue? I don't have a clue what you're talking about. Did you do something in clue that would make me think you were a townie? I never even came close to suggesting that you could be vanilla. I always said you were scum after Setael died, I never even once said you were town. I just agreed that it was better strategy to lynch DP first and lynch you tomorrow. Wtf are you even talking about? I called you confirmed town? Are you blind, stupid, or both? Seriously, I may be arrogant, but at least I'm arrogant AND right. You're just plain wrong, and that makes your arrogance look retarded AND obnoxious, as opposed to just annoying, like mine is.

[Shanba]

Hrm.

I'm pleased with my play this game, as I felt my reads wee for the most part fairly accurate. I'm disappointed with the DP lynch - the Lowell one not so much. BM needed to bite the bullet and nk setael a night earlier, if he wanted a chance of winning, and given he actually managed to get away with that, he might even have stolen the game at that point.

Scum did implode somewhat, and were not helped by a setup that favoured the town to a large degree.

[Porochaz]

Thanks Patrick

[Battle Mage]

Your reaction right here just convinced me that there's no way you are NOT protown

^MoS stating his certainty of my innocence.

BM, don't call me a moron when you fucked up at being a doc

yet again

(or you are lying to begin with). I'm not going to apologize for anything, because you didn't even bother to offer an alternative to you being scum.

^MoS making a hint in reference to the Clue Game in which i claimed doc as vanilla, suggesting that i might not just be Doc or Scum.

And i should note that the entire post was made with the assumption that i was protown.

OWNED. rofl.

BM

*oh and btw, no hard feelings. I didnt set out to humiliate you, and i cant blame you for taking meta knowledge into account. Dont spoil my moment with bitterness please.

[Setael]

I disagree that this game was balanced toward the town from the start. If the mafia would've sent in NKs N1 and N2, they'd have won. That's what you get for trusting BM to be active enough to send in your kills.

Credit to ABR and everyone who lynched Bookitty. I wasn't seeing it (I can't read Bookitty) and if the godfather hadn't gone down early, I also think it would've ended differently.

[Patrick]

I disagree that this game was balanced toward the town from the start. If the mafia would've sent in NKs N1 and N2, they'd have won. That's what you get for trusting BM to be active enough to send in your kills.

Take out the two masons and the setup might be balanced. With them the town has too much power considering how small the mafia is.

I don't think the mafia would have won even if they'd nightkilled nights 1 and 2. There's only so many nights a claimed doctor should be surviving before people start wondering why they aren't being nightkilled.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Your reaction right here just convinced me that there's no way you are NOT protown

^MoS stating his certainty of my innocence.

Rofl, you self-centered prick! I wasn't even talking to you. That was in response to Porochaz. His suggestion that there might actually be a naive cop convinced me that he wasn't scum, because he wouldn't want to un-clear himself as scum.

BM, don't call me a moron when you fucked up at being a doc

yet again

(or you are lying to begin with). I'm not going to apologize for anything, because you didn't even bother to offer an alternative to you being scum.

^MoS making a hint in reference to the Clue Game in which i claimed doc as vanilla, suggesting that i might not just be Doc or Scum.

Actually, I was making a reference to Mafia 59, where you let me manipulate you when you were doc and I managed to kill the most powerful role in the game on the same night that it confirmed I was scum, because you failed to protect him.

And i should note that the entire post was made with the assumption that i was protown.

OWNED. rofl.

Except it wasn't, and you completely misread my post because you think everything's centered on you. I very specifically mentioned that my comment was only relevant IF you weren't lying, which I said I thought you were, and I was right.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Yeah I knew BM was scum, caught him early on but he claimed doc.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Apologies to Volkan (which I really screwed over this game after he killed Setael because of his faith in me) and Setael who I wrongfully accused.

I think we pretty much secured the game after lynching 2 scum and forced the 3rd to claim. Maybe BM could have pulled a lurk and NK'd the cop, but meh.

[Shanba]

Apologies to Volkan (which I really screwed over this game after he killed Setael because of his faith in me) and Setael who I wrongfully accused.

I think we pretty much secured the game after lynching 2 scum and forced the 3rd to claim. Maybe BM could have pulled a lurk and NK'd the cop, but meh.

Didn't I tell you vollkan was Setael mark II?

:P

[Battle Mage]

Yeah I knew BM was scum, caught him early on but he claimed doc.

actually that reminds me, credit to ABR in this game. Despite my doc claim, he kept on pushing me, and he was right on the money. Unfortunately he didnt really achieve much towards lynching me, but nonetheless it is a testament to his scumdar.

BM

[Mastermind of Sin]

ABR deserves a scummy nomination for this game, imo.

[Shanba]

Yeah, he played fantastically.

[vollkan]

I just noticed this game had finished, and we won.

Good game, especially ABR (despite his lynching of me ) and thanks Patrick

[farside22]

I just noticed this game had finished, and we won.

Good game, especially ABR (despite his lynching of me ) and thanks Patrick

I tried to tell people I didn't think you were scum. ABR still owes me for being right.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I was right about vollkan, too, but I was too lazy to fight for it.

[EmpTyger]

Love is but the discovery of ourselves in others, and the delight in the last post.