Mini 396: ChatMafia Mafia; GAME OVER

[AngusHutchsky]

Reread my posts and you should get it...

[Jack]

Vote: Draygn_mage

for saying he doesn't remember how to play this game.

Ditto, and for randomnesses sake.

vote draygn_mage

Scummy post. You put the third vote on draygn_mage and use "for the randomnesses sake" part to distance yourself from the bandwagon.

Unvote, vote AngusHutchsky

Unvote, vote milkman

for lack of counting ability. That was the 2nd vote on draygn_mage. Also, you seem to be making a serious accusation when there isn't much to go on.

[Y]

Vote: Coron

for crap logic.

I'll make it

Vote: AngusHutchsky

. Same reason.

[ChannelDelibird]

Vote: Coron

for crap logic.

I'll make it

Vote: AngusHutchsky

. Same reason.

*coughunvotefirstcough*

[ChannelDelibird]

Plus, in the games I have played on other sites (this is my first on MafiaScum) the Mafia convieniently(sp?) forget how exactly the game goes so they can lurk without being suspicious.

And you let them get away with that feeble excuse?

Seriously, did dragyn_mage sound serious to you? His exact words were 'let's see if I can remember', not 'I have forgotten', and I think they were fairly obviously a joke.

[ChannelDelibird]

MOD:

If you could clean up the quote tag in that last post I would be very grateful. It's quoting Angus, obviously...

[Y]

Rules

.
.
.
5. Votes should be bolded and in this format:

Vote: Player

to count. I will not accept a vote unless if it is in the correct format.

Unvotes are not necessary to place your vote somewhere else

, but they are recommended.

Usually I do unvote, but this one seemed better without the unvote part...

[draygn_mage]

Wow, one innocuous comment seems to have been pounced on like a baby bird out of the nest.

Being that he's new here, I don't think Angus understood the joke behind the comment. I haven't been on site in months due to real life issues. I don't know if he's also relatively new to the game of mafia though, as his seemingly conflicted reason for voting would indicate.

They're right man, either you random voted me *or* you had a reason. You just can't say both. If you're random voting, well there's nothing I can say about that, but typically if you have a reason to vote someone, it should be a reason you are ready to back up.

If no one buys your reasoning, you have to be prepared for the bandwagon to roll backwards and over you, instead of the person you voted for.

Oh, and just for discussion sake, I have never heard of a scum claiming ignorance of how to play in order to lurk. I've heard them claim to have no opinion on what is being discussed, they've claimed general confusion, indecision, even concensus with the rest of the group (and in Baby Jesus's case, even boredom), but not ignorance of rules.

[ChannelDelibird]

Rules

.
.
.
5. Votes should be bolded and in this format:

Vote: Player

to count. I will not accept a vote unless if it is in the correct format.

Unvotes are not necessary to place your vote somewhere else

, but they are recommended.

Usually I do unvote, but this one seemed better without the unvote part...

Fair enough. I didn't check the unvoting rules as I always unvote by force of habit.

[Jack]

Vote: Draygn_mage

for saying he doesn't remember how to play this game.

Ditto, and for randomnesses sake.

vote draygn_mage

Scummy post. You put the third vote on draygn_mage and use "for the randomnesses sake" part to distance yourself from the bandwagon.

Unvote, vote AngusHutchsky

Unvote, vote milkman

for lack of counting ability. That was the 2nd vote on draygn_mage. Also, you seem to be making a serious accusation when there isn't much to go on.

nm,

unvote

re-read and see how that could be scummy. I think he's just misusing the word "random" though.

[AngusHutchsky]

I am new to the site, but I am not that new to Mafia - been playing a few months. I guess the point I am trying to make isn't making it. Anyway, whether you see my vote as random or not, at least I know why I put it there and so there it will stay.

[AngusHutchsky]

EBWOP:

Oh, and just for discussion sake, I have never heard of a scum claiming ignorance of how to play in order to lurk. I've heard them claim to have no opinion on what is being discussed, they've claimed general confusion, indecision, even concensus with the rest of the group (and in Baby Jesus's case, even boredom), but not ignorance of rules.

I have, but maybe the guys I usually play with are as messed up as I seem to be.

[Coron]

Limited access until sunday/monday.

[draygn_mage]

At any rate, yeah, I know how to play, I just haven't played in a while. That was the point I was trying to make.

[milkman]

Vote: Draygn_mage

for saying he doesn't remember how to play this game.

Ditto, and for randomnesses sake.

vote draygn_mage

Scummy post. You put the third vote on draygn_mage and use "for the randomnesses sake" part to distance yourself from the bandwagon.

Unvote, vote AngusHutchsky

Unvote, vote milkman

for lack of counting ability. That was the 2nd vote on draygn_mage. Also, you seem to be making a serious accusation when there isn't much to go on.

Sorry, missed the unvote by coron. Still if that was the third vote that post would be really scummy. For now I agree with ChannelDelibird and you. His post was just worded badly.

[HurriKaty]

Woah this thread got to two pages fast.

Giving it a brief read through and then posting later today, so this post will seem less blatantly useless.

[milkman]

EBWOP:

I am new to the site, but I am not that new to Mafia - been playing a few months. I guess the point I am trying to make isn't making it. Anyway, whether you see my vote as random or not,

at least I know why I put it there and so there it will stay.

This reason?

I thought I explained what I meant in my last post.

It was a mostly random vote along with the fact that in other games I have played the Mafia likes to play dumb.

So no, it was not completely random, but it had some randomness mixed in. Sad That doesn't explain it very well, but it's the best I know how.

I was randomly voting based on the attitude of the Mafia in games I have played in the past.

Or this one?

Everyone else is voting randomly, why are you picking on me? Go be suspicious of someone else's random vote.

Plus, in the games I have played on other sites (this is my first on MafiaScum) the Mafia convieniently(sp?) forget how exactly the game goes so they can lurk without being suspicious.

Or both?

[Zindaras]

I think dragyn mage made a joke.

Vote: Twito

[AngusHutchsky]

milkman,

Both of the posts you just quoted say the same thing only worded differently. You just didn't vote the part about it being random as well on the second post. You guys obviously do not get my reason, and I am fine with that, which is why I just left it at "

at least I know why I put it there and so there it will stay.

"

[ChannelDelibird]

milkman,

Both of the posts you just quoted say the same thing only worded differently.

^ Correct. Methinks milkman is trying to make more out of this than is necessary.

unvote, vote milkman

[HurriKaty]

EBWOP:

I am new to the site, but I am not that new to Mafia - been playing a few months. I guess the point I am trying to make isn't making it. Anyway, whether you see my vote as random or not,

at least I know why I put it there and so there it will stay.

This reason?

I thought I explained what I meant in my last post.

It was a mostly random vote along with the fact that in other games I have played the Mafia likes to play dumb.

So no, it was not completely random, but it had some randomness mixed in. Sad That doesn't explain it very well, but it's the best I know how.

I was randomly voting based on the attitude of the Mafia in games I have played in the past.

Or this one?

Everyone else is voting randomly, why are you picking on me? Go be suspicious of someone else's random vote.

Plus, in the games I have played on other sites (this is my first on MafiaScum) the Mafia convieniently(sp?) forget how exactly the game goes so they can lurk without being suspicious.

Or both?

I'm trying to figure out the point to this post, but you know what, I just cant do it.

Is there even a reason its there?

[milkman]

milkman,

Both of the posts you just quoted say the same thing only worded differently.

^ Correct. Methinks milkman is trying to make more out of this than is necessary.

unvote, vote milkman

Sorta.

One quote said scum like to play dumb (period). The other post said scum play dumb so they can lurk without being suspicious. To me they are two diffrent things, so I left that post ambigious to see if angus would expand on his reasoning. It's hard to let go because I think Angus is scum.

I am new to the site

, but I am not that new to Mafia - been playing a few months. I guess the point I am trying to make isn't making it. Anyway, whether you see my vote as random or not, at least I know why I put it there and so there it will stay.

Everyone else is voting randomly, why are you picking on me? Go be suspicious of someone else's random vote.

Plus, in the games I have played on other sites (this is my first on MafiaScum)

the Mafia convieniently(sp?) forget how exactly the game goes so they can lurk without being suspicious.

It just seems so much like a tell to me. The reason for his vote was that scum like to act dumb in the games he played somewhere else, and he's been acting dumb himself.

[milkman]

I'm trying to figure out the point to this post, but you know what, I just cant do it.

Is there even a reason its there?

Actually, I deleted a part of my first post on accident lol. On reread that post was way more ambiguous(spelled it right this time) than I wanted it to be.

[AngusHutchsky]

I find it interesting how you like to only use part of my quotes. In that first quote you might note that I also said I am not new to Mafia, yet you seem to have conviniently left that part out so that you could make the point that I am acting dumb. As far as the second quote, all I can say is it's true.

[AngusHutchsky]

EBWOP:

Just to clarify - I mean you like to emphasize only part of them, not use only part of them.