NY 169: The EPIC XD Mafia Game of Greatness (Game Over)

[geists]

This ISO from another game is generic and another scum player (Sakura as it happens).

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go

Though I'll grant that he didn't interact that much with the other scum (SoS - GiF and me). Nobody did. We hardcore lurked that game.

[geists]

Yeah, that was what I was thinking. Ineffective and I went through your games counting the number of times the word showed up. The frequency difference was statistically significant. The word was "keep".

I rather liked that question. I doubted anyone could find it via an iso review in 5 minutes or even 10. The question I have in reserve isn't as obscure, but would be even more difficult to search and find the answer.

[geists]

Vote Titus with me. We'll make great things happen. I'll vote SAD/zMuffin with you tomorrow.

This is a strange post from you.

[geists]

What is your thought process?

[geists]

If I'm going to sheep someone about Ceph, I'm more likely to sheep nacho than you simply because if nacho is town, then he has incredibly strong motivation to get his Ceph read right this time. There are some things I want to check, though.

[geists]

I said "if". and I want to check some things, but it won't happen until later today.

I vastly prefer developing my own read.

[geists]

O hai!

Are you both here?

[geists]

How the hell did I miss you guys? I posted 2 minutes after GM did.

[geists]

I'm here.

[geists]

Ok, here's my 2nd question.

GM, in our offsite game, who died on night 2?

[geists]

Remember, Mara answers it.

[geists]

Correct.

GM didn't go by "goodmorning" on that site, and I didn't learn who I was playing against until later. You can't find the game by google searching both our names.

I'm satisfied. Though I didn't question the claim in the first place.

[geists]

I'm not voting anyone because I have a lot of work to do before picking a lynch.

You have a day and a half to do it. Picking a lynch is only the start if you come up with someone who's not currently on the table.

[geists]

Norl
Pie
SAD
Muffin

we lynch through this list of players, in no particular order, and this game should be done. If it isn't, there shouldn't be no more than one scum left, and this list

KBBQ
Proph
Titus
Sakura
Casso

should contain that last scum, assuming they are all alive at that point

I agree that KBBQ, Proph, and Sakura are town. Proph's recent posts about Generic interactions feel genuine. I also have a townread on Pie. I feel that the most likely scumteam are Titus, Arthur, and Muffin. I think we should lynch Arthur.

How does Pie's day 4-5 play line up with your town-Pie model?

[geists]

Subject: mini1510 PAUL WALKER MEMORIAL flights of angels sing thee to (Pie-scum game - Grimgroove is his buddy)

not only that but I was questioning Windblown earlier while my vote was on Slandaar. why isn't that one suspicious, when in Grimgroove's case it is?

This game:

it doesn't change the fact that you're supposedly interested in looking at the information from the lynch. but then when Generic tried to do that exact same thing, you apparently found it to be silly. either way, your thought process is contradictory as fuck

I dislike the similarities of these patterns. I am having second thoughts again after re-reading his posts in other games. He feels town. I

want

him to be town since we agree so much. But I wonder if it is too good to be true.

How does it fit into your own meta-model?

He seems more omgus-y to me than what I've seen in other games. As town, it's really easy to fall into the trap of default-scumreading people who scumread you and go after you, especially if you expect them to be able to read you. But, it's also an easy line of attack when you're scum if your game is usually confrontational.

I dunno. It's one of the things that bugs me about his play. That plus just feeling like he's not looking at the whole game, and not engaging people about their reads and his reads any more.

It could be a time-to-spend-on-mafia thing. I've had that assumption in the back of my mind for the last gameday or so.

[geists]

Unvote
Vote: SAD

Interesting.

[geists]

VOTE: zmuffin

Nati and I talked about our gut reads last night and who we trust more in terms of building consensus. The upshot of that was an intent to vote SAD, but I'm not feeling it right now.

I'd feel perfectly awesome about changing the vote to Titus if necessary.

[geists]

I am feeling all kinds of paranoia atm

Elaborate?

[geists]

Did he claim earlier in the game?

[geists]

Also, Nati has some stuff he wanted to throw into the thread before nightfall that he can hopefully get to soon. It's regarding Prophylaxis.

He prefers a Titus lynch.

[geists]

@F16, if you want meta, I am the person who knows Prophy the best although I don't make meta cases generally. I have played with him across four or five different sites. He lurks like mad when scum. What is he doing here? Lurking like mad. Bert's votes sucked major shit.

Oh really? Prophylaxis and I seem to have just missed each other's offsite groups. Interesting.

But this is consistent with my analysis. I'm gonna go look through a few games again, but yeah.

[geists]

@F16, if you want meta, I am the person who knows Prophy the best although I don't make meta cases generally. I have played with him across four or five different sites. He lurks like mad when scum. What is he doing here? Lurking like mad. Bert's votes sucked major shit.

Oh really? Prophylaxis and I seem to have just missed each other's offsite groups. Interesting.

But this is consistent with my analysis. I'm gonna go look through a few games again, but yeah.

[geists]

Also, Nati has some stuff he wanted to throw into the thread before nightfall that he can hopefully get to soon. It's regarding Prophylaxis.

He prefers a Titus lynch.

This is perhaps a little hyperbole.

But yeah I wanted to talk to muffin today. I have a sneaking suspicion he's town there.

[geists]

But i also won't be sad if he dies because I can never read him right I guess I dunno.

[geists]

thank tlaloc I didn't have to base jump off a tall building.