Mini 255 - RajÔÇÖs Freaktown I (The Beginning)- GAMEOVER

[Chaos]

And by the way. You were reffered to as "Mr. Shadow Man" night two, not night three. Thank you for confirming you're scum

Wai- Wha? How does this work? I just meant shadow man in general. I know it must be refering to a random killer in general, but I fail to see how that confirms anything.

Well, if you guys lynch me today, that's ok anyways, as I have already taken out my share of the mafia anyways.

[Stewie]

Well, I think raj's post kinda clears you in that sense... it seems to say that it was all flavour. Unless anyone has a different interpretation of what raj said, I would most likely go after LB today.

[LyingBrian]

well, well, well... this is an interesting game to say the least... i like Stewie & Chaos as Mafia, but then again, that's always dangerous when it's down to Lynch-or-Lose...

@Stewie

i understand that you think that my role may break the game, and it's possible that at this point it may... a broken game is not unheard of... everybody IS human & apt to mistakes... for example Eyewitness 1 in The Whole Sort of General Mish-Mash... the only person arguing that the game would be broken if all the information was correct was the person who we were trying to lynch... also if i was scum, why would i claim to be unnightkillable? i would be trying to keep as much information hidden as possible...

vote: Stewie

[Stewie]

1) also if i was scum, why would i claim to be unnightkillable? 2)i would be trying to keep as much information hidden as possible...

1) For the same reason Don Gaetano thinks I'm scum... being somewhat truthfull about your role. However, unkillable is common for scum and sk, but not for town.

Kind of a stupid argument to make from my position, but whatever.

2) You

have

been trying to keep as much information hidden as possible... remember when you were asked to reveal whether or not you had any extra abilities? You took quite a while to answer the question, and when you did you said "no." What, did you think the scum would be less likely to target you if they knew you had no abilities other than the fact that you were unkillable? (java doesn't work for me, so I can't figure out the code for the smiley face which is rolling its eyes. Imagine a smiley face rolling its eyes right here).

[Don Gaetano]

??? How did Raj's post clear Chaos?

It basically said he wasn't going to answer the question.

Then he said that the only thing "confirmed" by the night is that _____ was killed by a _____.

That doesn't mean that there's no other information in the flavour. Like the way the scum interacted with Alex/Ray in the scene where Sara is killed. The flavour isn't completely unrelated to the game.

---

To me, Chaos is basically confirmed scum. Atleat when you consider the "Mr. Shadow Man" comment. If he was scum he would vaguely remember being called "Mr. Shadow Man" night two, but if he was a one-shot vigilante as he claims. He would remember very well, that he wasn't called that when he killed.

If Chaos only meant shadow man in general as he claims, wouldn't it be normal to say "I don't know why I was called Shadow Man" instead of "I don't know why I was called

Mr.

Shadow Man"?

[Stewie]

the only thing that is confirmed by the night is that ____ was killed by a ____
everything else is flavor that only inhim, roland, etc. would understand.

I think that the "everything else" bit clears Chaos, because it states that only inhim, roland, and himself would understand. You bring up a good point about chaos wondering why he would be reffered as "mr. shadow man" when he hasn't, which kinda puts me back on the fence... which I can prove by showing you the fence pattern on my ass.

[Chaos]

The only reason I said "Mr. Shadow Man

buisness

" (context is fun!) is because you refered to that character as "Mr. Shadow Man" in that very same post I quoted, Don Gaetano.

:/

[Chaos]

Sorry for the double post... Again.

If Chaos only meant shadow man in general as he claims, wouldn't it be normal to say "I don't know why I was called Shadow Man" instead of "I don't know why I was called Mr. Shadow Man"?

Yeah, I agree, that probably would have made more sense. But you were talking under the context that they were the same person, and I am most definately not Mr. Shadow Man. Which is what I was trying to get across.

RAJ: fixed the tag

[elvis_knits]

Elvis, who's Jaide225?

Jaide is the girl raj took to prom, I think. He showed me a pic. Other than that I don't know anything really.

I think she'd approve of this diagram of a tumor though:


Hmm...I am not decided who to vote for yet. I'll be rereading the last few pages again to try to see how Don went from thinking Stewie was most likely scum, to voting for Chaos. I guess this is because he thinks Chaos is the "Shadow man." I'll be thinking...

[Don Gaetano]

Anyone who thinks flavour doesn't hint at anything, must also agree that it's completely incidental that people have been killed by the word of god. And that it doesn't hint at there being a killer with that kill method.

[LyingBrian]

so has everybody claimed...

[rajrhcpfreak]

i claim GOD...

i will clarify one thing about the most recent night scene.
loji (alex) had no part in halo (sara)'s death. he was only there because i wanted the flavor of him getting killed with her and not getting killed at home.
so if halo was still alive he wouldnt have known that logi left his house to kill.

thats all ill tell you

being that nothings really happen you all dont get a vote count agian.

[LyingBrian]

BTW, i was reviewing the thread, and one of the people who said that my role would break the game, RangeroftheNorth, came up scum! FYI

[LyingBrian]

also, Stewie was the last to vote for RangeroftheNorth yesterday... it was the 6th vote that wasn't counted in the final vote count, but a pretty safe place to put a vote on your scum partner...

[LyingBrian]

I am a

one-shot

vig.

I figured I would thrust my trusty

spork

into his face and see what happens.

the shadow man

grabs a

spork

out of the nearest trashcan and starts to stab Alex repeatedly with it in the face.

the Shadow Man

attacks him and starts to strangle him with a bra.

The shadow man

...then pours the extra concrete onto Keith’s feet and pushes him into the pool.

we are not going to get any better proof that 1 player is anti-town... if you are truly a one-shot vig, Chaos, how did we have 3 kills N1? also, you admitted to using the weapon attributed to the "shadow man" on N3, yet that specific phrase was used the other 2 nights as seen above... even if the phrase "the shadow man" doesn't refer to the same player each night (which i believe it does), then you still can't explain the 3 kills on N1... i don't believe that you were either one-shot or a vig... i believe you are a SK...

unvote

vote: Chaos

[Chaos]

I don't really understand what you are pointing out there, but when I sent the PM to raj, all I said was that I wanted to kill logitus. I didn't specify a kill method. (Nor was one specified in my role PM.)

[elvis_knits]

If you didn't know what your kill method was, why did you say in your vig-claim post:

I figured I would thrust my trusty spork into his face and see what happens.

And yeah, I basically think you are SK at this point. I may put my vote on shortly.


P.S. Don't you think horses are beautiful? I do. I own the movie Seabiscuit so that I can watch horses any time I want!

[LyingBrian]

And yeah, I

basically think

know you are SK at this point. I

may

will put my vote on shortly.

fixed

FOS: elvis_knits

how can you ask for a better lead?!?... he still didn't answer my question about N1!?!...

[elvis_knits]

The only reason I want to think about it some more is because relying too heavily on the mod death scenes can be dangerous. I'll probably vote Chaos in the next few hours though...

LyingBrian=peer pressurer!

[elvis_knits]

Ok. I'm convinced. How did we have three kills N1 if he's a one-shot vig? He's SK.

vote chaos

[LyingBrian]

well since it's twilight, i'll go ahead & post my thoughts...

i think there were 4 anti-town roles (2-person Mafia & 2 SK's) if this is correct, there should only be 1 kill tonight theoretically by the word of God...

it is possible for the remaining SK to win (provided my assessment is correct) if i can be killed in endgame... if there was a killing role & myself left in endgame, i would assume the killing role would win... (BTW, i PMed Alex to see if he would give me an answer)

i won't bother to say who i think should be protected, as it will start a WIFOM argument, we'll just have to wait on the nightscene...

[Don Gaetano]

It doesn't matter who I protect. I'll get killed, since there's no one to protect me.

[elvis_knits]

I can see ways that you might not die.

[Don Gaetano]

Anything you can say?

[LyingBrian]

It doesn't matter who I protect. I'll get killed, since there's no one to protect me.

can't Stewie say the same thing... like i said a WIFOM...