Open 482: Popcorn Mafia {Game Over}

[Limo]

Distances himself from the two flipped mafiosos - doesn't even mention them actually. Was quick to try to look for confirmed townies via setup gimmicks. I don't like how he for a lack of a better word, "retaliates" with his defense of his plan. It's kind of unnecessary. Either way I think there's one scum between AP and Juke. Leaning in favor of the Juke shot.

[Limo]

oh sorry

[Limo]

If it means anything I didn't really think much of Juke until AP's replacement. Wrote him off as probably town.

[Cherry Nog]

Is Duck Duck Goose your only completed game?

[Limo]

Yep.

[Juke]

Here, shoot me quick, I'll shoot AP.

[Cherry Nog]

dammit nothing's still happening.

Going for it.

Shoot Juke

[Jal]

Cherry Dog stares at his gun. RedPanda just kinda

knew

who to shoot. Why didn't he? He thought and thought and thought until his nog turned blue. Finally, he came to a conclusion as to the best thing he should do.

He walks back into Mantisdreamz's house and stays as quiet as a mouse. He hears it. Looking to his left he finds the door he knew is needed. He opens the door and down the staircase he proceeded.

The air grew musty. Is that the smell of piss he whiffs? This must be the right place. Finally he reaches the end to his destination. He takes out his gun - anything next can happen in his estimation. Turning the corner to the basement, the sight of Juke beholds him:







"LOL Hey Mantisdreamz, look at th- OH GOD U NOT MANTIS." Juke tumbles and falls trying to get himself up off the floor.

In disgust or in fear of his own life, which I do not know, Cherry shoots and closes his eyes to the impending gore.

Juke,

Mafia Goon, and official thread bum

, collapses into a bowl full of fat jelly.

Day 6 Begins!

The gunbearer is still

Cherry Nog

. He is

innocent

.

Deadline

: April 2nd, 8:00 pm PST

Deadline Countdown

: (expired on 2013-04-02 20:00:00)

[AngryPidgeon]

Sorry for,lurkaderping. Im glad we shot that though.

Boardgame night at work, playing battlestar gallactica. ^^, content in a bit..

[Jal]

MadHatter is being replaced.

[Cherry Nog]

dammit that confirmation of scum doesn't help me, Juke hardly interacted with anybody.

But I think those he did interact with and call town he was looking for them to call him town in return and are probably actually townies. (Limo and HadMatter, with the read and retraction on Limo both fairly early on)

I think I'll look at RedPanda's next on the line list seeing as he had 3 of the scum down, so either CBD or Bum. it would possibly be now, but I don't know which one to shoot and it'll probably be the opposite one to N.

[Jal]

RachMarie replaces HadMatter immediately.

[RachMarie]

/confirm

[AngryPidgeon]

Hi Rach! How caught up are you? Its a fairly light game as far as reading goes.

Im thinking my kill list would be:

Bumfuzzled
CDB
Limo
Rach

in that order. I really do want a chance to do a legit ISO reading session, I know I keep promising.

Right now I'm really not super sold on my list order and I'm feeling a little lazy because as long as I am never shot, this is a town win. But yeh.

I would not be overly upset if you shot CDB next. I think Im fairly certain its not Rach/Hatter. Everyone else is not a super strong read, gun to my head. But bumfuzzled seems fairly self aware and I didn't like his Juke read throughout the game, so I'm inclined to think its them.

[RachMarie]

Still catching up a bit, Though so far I would put you in the Town pile based on your ISO.

Have not finished all the ISOs yet.

[RachMarie]

So Cheery and N are conftown
I have AP pegged as town Though I kinda not as sure as you are about Bum being the last scum. Still need to figure them out.

So need to look more closely at Bum, CDB, and yeah I need to read Limo's ISO still, but from the skim read of the whole game kinda leaning town on him too.

[AngryPidgeon]

Ya, Limo hasn't posted much. And I'm lightly paranoid about him because the last time I replaced in and someone said "Oh AP will be easy to read, unlike his predecessor" the person flipped scum.

[Cherry Nog]

Still Alive
Bumfuzzled
AngryPidgeon
ChannelDelibird
Limo
RachMarie

Flipped Mafia
Siveure DtTrikyp
Mantisdreamz
Juke

I can see Juke suggesting who to give the gun to and Siv and Mantis not really caring.
Limo, Mac, Awest and HadMatter wouldn't have known anybody so wouldn't have an opinion.
Regfan would definitely have a suggestion, and it would be a well thought-out one, too. In Sixty's everyone-has-a-gun game, he chose newbies to be on his scumteam because he knew they wouldn't be shot early and could slip under the radar.
I'm not so sure on CDB, though. He's been inactive through a lot of this game, so he may not have even made it to the pregame scum chat to be able to make a suggestion, and I'm not so sure he would if he had.

To be honest, I wouldn't have chosen HD, and I don't think Regfan would have either. HD is pretty stubborn and would be hard for scum to manipulate. I would have chosen either mcqueen or a newbie. Or, to go the opposite way, a stronger, established player and hope they make the wrong decision and get them out of the way early on.

So, I don't really think bum is the most likely scum. This is the closest we can get to night kill analysis and it points towards Juke being the most vocal in the pregame scum qt. Juke pointed to Limo replacing in right before the game started as proof Limo didn't help plan who got the gun to begin with, but I don't think that means much, as they'd probably already submitted that HD would have the gun.

[Cherry Nog]

I can wall sometimes

[Cherry Nog]

Rach, what's your read on HM?

[AngryPidgeon]

I think that was Cheery?

Who would _you_ have given the gun to to start? Thinking about it, I think the logical choice would be someone you want out of the game first (a strong player).

[Cherry Nog]

Was my post really that rambly that you thought I was Cheery?

I already said I'd probably give it to mcqueen.

[Cherry Nog]

Or was that a general "you" to everyone?

[AngryPidgeon]

I meant you Hi N!

Ah. I guess I wasn't really going anywhere with that. It just seems to me that Bumfuzzled/CDB would have been big targets for the gun since they have a moderate reputation. But its possible scunm weren't even thinking that the first gunbearer should be a strong player or w/e.

[Cherry Nog]

Scum obviously wasn't thinking about giving the gun to a strong player, because neither bum nor CDB have it and they can't both be scum.