Open 319: Jungle Republic - Day 5: Calamity *GAME OVER*

[Ray Montano]

If votes are flip-flopping, and the town lynched a townie day one and another townie ate it during night, and the seer cannot get a plausible wagon on the wolf then I'd say about 60-70% through the deadline.

[tyhess]

I'd wait a bit long, but that's more a preference than anything...I still think it limits how much the seer (as in the only town power roll) helps us.

[FightingShadow]

Let's even say its Day 3 (so 4 players are killed), and we have 1 werewolf, 2 mafia, and 4 towns left + the seer...is it really beneficial to off one mafia (and get an innocent town) to off yourself at night? Imo, no...

The Mafia don't possess a night kill in this setup. So it would be hands down the best play for the Seer to claim there. Lynch the last killing antitown player, and get a clear for the rest of the game.

The Ray wagon has virtue beyond Thor's evidence.
VOTE: Ray Montano

What virtue does Thor's evidence have, and what virtue does the wagon have beyond it?

Also, everyone should read the setup - the Mafia cannot kill. While they are a threat, the Werewolves are the only ones killing us at night.

[FightingShadow]

Let's even say its Day 3 (so 4 players are killed), and we have 1 werewolf, 2 mafia, and 4 towns left + the seer...is it really beneficial to off one mafia (and get an innocent town) to off yourself at night? Imo, no...

The Mafia don't possess a night kill in this setup. So it would be hands down the best play for the Seer to claim there. Lynch the last killing antitown player, and get a clear for the rest of the game.

The Ray wagon has virtue beyond Thor's evidence.
VOTE: Ray Montano

What virtue does Thor's evidence have, and what virtue does the wagon have beyond it?

Also, everyone should read the setup - the Mafia cannot kill. While they are a threat, the Werewolves are the only ones killing us at night.

[tyhess]

Let's even say its Day 3 (so 4 players are killed), and we have 1 werewolf, 2 mafia, and 4 towns left + the seer...is it really beneficial to off one mafia (and get an innocent town) to off yourself at night? Imo, no...

The Mafia don't possess a night kill in this setup.

So it would be hands down the best play for the Seer to claim there. Lynch the last killing antitown player, and get a clear for the rest of the game.

But the wolves do....

[Ray Montano]

I'd wait a bit long, but that's more a preference than anything...I still think it limits how much the seer (as in the only town power roll) helps us.

I think waiting 60-70% is reasonable. Its given an ample amount of time for discussion and leaves room for the town to dissect what the seer has to say and squeeze some last little morsels from the wolf.

[tyhess]

30% of 18 days=5ish days...Imo it doesn't take 5 days to get enough votes on the convicted seer's player (giving us less real life days of talk), but again that's just really arguing for the sake of arguing

[Ray Montano]

Well I wouldn't think we'd need those full five days in that scenario. But if everyone was smart it'd still take a full real life day or so to end the game day.

[DeityKabuto]

Eh... more setup speculation, this is my 2nd Jungle Republic game.

Anyways

Unvote

[TheFool]

Blegh theory argument.

what virtue does the wagon have beyond it?

Fluff posting. 15 posts, 0 content.

[DeityKabuto]

Mod, Vote Count, please.

[CMPunk]

not liking the way DK jumped on the Rey wagon right after not understanding it.

[/b]unvote
vote: DK[/b]

[CMPunk]

bah

unvote
vote: DK

[DeityKabuto]

I'm still wondering if I should even react to that.

[FightingShadow]

But the wolves do....

Seer only finds wolves. Seer outing the last wolf means an invincible clear.

Fluff posting. 15 posts, 0 content.

I can roll with this.

UNVOTE: Sky
VOTE: Ray Montano

Eh... more setup speculation, this is my 2nd Jungle Republic game.

Anyways Unvote

Why did you Unvote?

[DeityKabuto]

Why did you Unvote?

For CMPunk's reasoning, a wagon that I had not understood.

[Sky]

Why did you Unvote?

For CMPunk's reasoning, a wagon that I had not understood.

Why'd you join?

And why are we discussing what the seer should do? It's a waste of time if you ask me.

[DeityKabuto]

Why did you Unvote?

For CMPunk's reasoning, a wagon that I had not understood.

Why'd you join?

And why are we discussing what the seer should do? It's a waste of time if you ask me.

I don't recall being apart of the Seer discussion and I don't feel comfortable with all these questions either.

[Ray Montano]

Blegh theory argument.

what virtue does the wagon have beyond it?

Fluff posting. 15 posts, 0 content.

15 "fluff" posts > 2 fluff posts IMNSHO

[Sky]

I don't recall being apart of the Seer discussion and I don't feel comfortable with all these questions either.

I'm not including you in on the seer discussion. And here's another question : what questions are you not comfortable with?

[tyhess]

DK-Why are you uncomfortable about the question?

[CMPunk]

Not going to be about much until Sunday evening, got a lot to do this weekend.. V/LA I believe it is here? But yea, I'm V/LA until Sunday evening.

[DeityKabuto]

I'm getting the feeling that Sky and Shadow are the same people because of the pace the question were asked, that is why.

[Ray Montano]

Sooo you're accusing someone of cheating?

[DeityKabuto]

Sooo you're accusing someone of cheating?

no