Mini 1041: Wheel of Fortune Mafia (Game over!)

[FakeGod]

lol reck, you're just jealous cuz I got a buddy

[Reckamonic]

You might have a buddy, but I have something better, and he's playing the same role as me =D

[FakeGod]

can't argue with that

[StrangerCoug]

VOTE COUNT

Charlie (2): Xite91, PieMan
FakeGod (1): Reckamonic
Oman (1): curiouskarmadog
Prof. Guppy (1): Oman
Reckamonic (2): Me=Weird, yabbaguy
Not voting (5): brianj, Charlie, FakeGod, jmj3000, Prof. Guppy

With

12

players alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.

Asperger's actually.

Hey, me too!

[PieMan]

Charlie, FakeGod why does either of you think it was a good idea, to out that if you are town, you are essentially the worse role, minus VT

Yabba, why push it further and try to discern anymore of their roles, when more info about everyone's roles, at this point is detrimental.

[brianj]

brianj's #27 doesn't sit well with me, specifically because he just shows up seemingly to say that he doesn't know what to think of Charlie's post.

brian, what do you think of Charlie's post now?

Obviously main point of my post was my question against Prof. Guppy, not just to say I don't know what to think of the softclaim (you haven't replied yet btw, Guppy). By "Don't know what to think of Charlie's post at the moment" I was saying I thought Charlie's post was essentially null-read. Although seemingly anti-town move, we don't know enough about his role or setting to sufficiently attack the decision. Of course when Charlie posts more or when the full roleclaim comes, I would be more certain about the motivation behind his post.

I think I have rough idea about what their role is about now but I'll wait and see. Kind of surprised about how Charlie and FakeGod seem to be certain of each others alignment though.

Charlie, FakeGod why does either of you think it was a good idea, to out that if you are town, you are essentially the worse role, minus VT

Yabba, why push it further and try to discern anymore of their roles, when more info about everyone's roles, at this point is detrimental.

Is it me or does the content of the post contradict each other.

[FakeGod]

Charlie, FakeGod why does either of you think it was a good idea, to out that if you are town, you are essentially the worse role, minus VT

We had a good reason. Trust me.

And what did I say about

rolefishing

discussing about me and Charlie? hmmm?

Charlie, FakeGod why does either of you think it was a good idea, to out that if you are town, you are essentially the worse role, minus VT

Yabba, why push it further and try to discern anymore of their roles, when more info about everyone's roles, at this point is detrimental.

Is it me or does the content of the post contradict each other.

Well, it's not you.

[PieMan]

Im not asking your role im asking your intention, cause you just made it way harder on any big role we may have.

what contradiction?

[PieMan]

dont worry about answering that FG, I hope you guys know what your doing, but I seriously dont think that was a good play by you guys.

[Xite91]

On #44
Showing intent to vote FakeGod, but don't know where the votes are at
**Note: This has nothing to do with flavor**

[jmj3000]

reckamonic: I didn't say I was going to sheep him, I said I was going to listen to him.

xite: What are you talking about in #59?

Charlie/FakeGod: Why did you two feel like you had to out yourself? Also, FG, why did you feel that this was necessary?

Trust me when I say that when I say that Charlie and I didn't know each other before the game started, which is why Charlie actually had to softclaim for me to find him, and there is a very good reason why he soft-claimed looking for me.

Guys, could you stop asking/speculating about me and Charlie? I can guarantee right now that both of us are town.

[Oman]

Not random voting.

Vote The good Prof. Guppy

How's that working out for you

Quite well, actually. My scumdar just got a blip when I pointed it in your direction.

My "fuck you"-dar just got a.....shut up!

No votes huh?

And, slap my ass and call me charlie..oman, here???????? Been ages.

vote Oman

, you the man.

<3 been a while mate, saw you and had to join.

I'm pretty happy with yabba's point that one of the two mysteries are scum. I'm also assigning brianj as the partner. He is arguing against the plan for no reason. His disagreement seems to be around the fact that he doesn't get how yabbaguy got to the conclusion, which I found incredibly simple. brianj then steps forward with my biggest hate in a mafia game "WIFOM!" as a reason to cease all conversation when A) WIFOM doesn't exist and B) they're wrong. That's more bad play than scummy though. Really my biggest gripes with brianj are along his immediate emotional reaction to things. It's so far out of place, that it looks scummy.

Look, I'm not really happy with the huge amount of rolefishing, and I think that for a softclaim that was mighty fierce. These things tend to happen though.

Anyway, just in case anyone cares, brianj is pinging as scum, hardcore. Just thought I'd let you all know.

FG: Confirm that it's mod-confirmed that you're both town
charlie: Confirm that FG is mod-confirmed town for you.
VOTE: Unvote; Vote: brianj

[Oman]

That vote tag is...not good for unvoting.

[Xite91]

@Oman - Which is why I don't use it.

Asperger's actually.

Hey, me too!

Doesn't this kind of confirm what he was saying?



Fakegod is scum based off of gut. Give him a chance to post another 3-5 posts and I will have a case on him. Promise

[PieMan]

Heres my biggest problem with thinking only one of them is mafia.

Im willing to say neither of them could be,

but im also willing to say they both are mafia

it just doesnt seem necessary for one to be maf and the other to not be, for some weird strat or power or w/e

[curiouskarmadog]

Ahhhhhhhh...I dont understand if they are what they said they are, they had to come out...i assume it has something to do with their role, but still it makes me uneasy. they sounds more like neighbors than they do masons...but the fact the "had" to come out for some reason, (shrug)...I cant see two scum buddies pulling this together. Seems stupid if that is the case.

unvote, vote ME=Weird

....more posting please.

[Prof. Guppy]

Not random voting.

Vote The good Prof. Guppy

How's that working out for you

Quite well, actually. My scumdar just got a blip when I pointed it in your direction.

My "fuck you"-dar just got a.....shut up!

You have no idea you you're dealing with if you think for one second I can begin to shut up.

Mod: I think you have Reckamonic listed on the vote count twice.

FoS: PieMan

I would like to see some clear idea about who you think is scum in your posts.

[Oman]

I don't know much, but I know I love you.

[FakeGod]

It's mod-confirmed that Charlie and I are both town.

May I leave it that?

[brianj]

PieMan #57
Since his softclaim was specifically aimed at finding the other Mystery Wedge, asking for Charlie to reveal his intention behind his action would likely lead to some more information about role of him/FakeGod, which is exactly the thing you are questioning yabbaguy for speculating.

Oman #61

Unless specifically stated so I am sticking with the opinion that one's alignment is arbitrary.

I argued that the cost of revealing the role of one (potentially two) individuals was not an acceptable trade-off for finding

'Bankrupt' mystery wedge which may or may not turn out to be scum

(I am guessing underlined part is WIFOM aspect). Also, I am curious where you got the impression that I was reacting emotionally.

FakeGod #68
Okay, that information was what I needed. It mean that you and Charlie must share same alignment, it be truly town partners, third-party partners, or mafia gambiting. For the moment I am willing to lay off, though I am quite surpised at that confession; like what karma said, I expected them to be more of neighbours rather than mod-confirmed.

[Oman]

I got the impression you were reacting emotionally because you sure weren't reacting rationally. Mostly tone and word choice.

It's mod-confirmed that Charlie and I are both town.

May I leave it that?

Not really, that's quite big thing to just trust you with. I don't need to know powers or anything (unless the power is that you both confirm), but I'm just not buying such an easy to produce mason pair like that.

I could consider a serial killer/psychiatrist relationship, where the SK has said "fuck this noise" and gone for the town option, but I can't really buy something so easily mod confirming popping up in balance like this (yes that is modWIFOM, but there has to be a point where you drop it out and say "facts is facts").



My awesome breadcrumb/softclaim

[Oman]

Attempt 2?

[FakeGod]

I got the impression you were reacting emotionally because you sure weren't reacting rationally. Mostly tone and word choice.

who me?

[Oman]

Nein, brianj

[curiouskarmadog]

It's mod-confirmed that Charlie and I are both town.

May I leave it that?

More to the point, I have issue with this.

when you say mod confirmed...is it something that you ask him or was it in your PM?