Mini 1003 Mafia - Game Over

[MagnaofIllusion]

Lemon, can we "hate" on you for the irony of your interesting language choices in that last post in conjunction with your criticism of Zang's spelling?

Also, Mindgamer needs to stop lurking in his QT and post his usual scum-tells in thread so we can get to lynching him.

[Zang]

Votecount-

Mindgamer - 1 - (Lemon) (L-6)
Lemon - 2 - (Tasky, MagnaofIlusion) (L-5)
nopointinactingup - 1 - (Equinox) (L-6)
MagnaofIlusion - 1 - (youngminii) (L-6)

Not Voting: chihuahua0, Mindgamer, AWA, RetroAudio, 
nopointinactingup, AClockworkMelon, Untrod Tripod

7 needed to lynch


I fixed the spelling errors in the sample role.

[Lemon]

Just because my vocabulary is varied (cat speak to standard English), doesn't mean you can attack me. And what if his scum-tell is his lurkiness?

Also,

@Mod

maybe use the Green you outlined in rule 2? I don't really care though, your choice.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Just because my vocabulary is varied (cat speak to standard English), doesn't mean you can attack me. And what if his scum-tell is his lurkiness?

First anyone can attack you for any reason they choose. Whether the attack is valid or not is another matter.

Second Self-Inconsistancy (in relation to actual game issues) is a huge scum-tell IMO. Going out of your way to point out the spelling errors in the sample PM while yourself using h8 in place of hate (along with other issues) is being self-inconsistent. Regardless I don't feel it is anything other than a way to generate discussion in this case.

My post re: Mindgamer is a direct reference to the game we played together (Newbie 912) and nothing more.

Lemon, do you find lurking to be a scum-tell?

[Zang]

Also, @Mod maybe use the Green you outlined in rule 2? I don't really care though, your choice

Sorry

[Lemon]

Just because my vocabulary is varied (cat speak to standard English), doesn't mean you can attack me. And what if his scum-tell is his lurkiness?

First anyone can attack you for any reason they choose. Whether the attack is valid or not is another matter.

Second Self-Inconsistancy (in relation to actual game issues) is a huge scum-tell IMO. Going out of your way to point out the spelling errors in the sample PM while yourself using h8 in place of hate (along with other issues) is being self-inconsistent. Regardless I don't feel it is anything other than a way to generate discussion in this case.

My post re: Mindgamer is a direct reference to the game we played together (Newbie 912) and nothing more.

Lemon, do you find lurking to be a scum-tell?

Yeah, I know.

As for self-inconsistency, perhaps, but I don't think on vocabulary it terribly matters. And the h8 also felt ironic due to the idea of being picky about the sample, excuse me if I'm wrong.

I see. Then what about the other person who said hi specifically to Mindgamer ? Regardless, it was just a random vote.

As for my position, I find it as scumtell somewhat, but I haven't played a lot of games (as noted astutely in part A of your reasoning of my vote) to have a really strong position on it. But from some chat mafia games (which I don't know if they're a complete other thing or not) it seems like a pretty useful measure.

[Tasky]

Don't h8 for me being observative and/or new.

why do you think I hate you? should I?

[Tasky]

Don't h8 for me being observative and/or new.

Do you really think I hate you?

should

I hate you?

Why

?

[Tasky]

damn... sorry... I sended my message twice because I didn't see page 2 of the discussion... lol

[Untrod Tripod]

vote Tasky

. too much rhetoric for this early in the game. I'm like, 1% serious and 99% joking about that

[Tasky]

Second Self-Inconsistancy (in relation to actual game issues) is a huge scum-tell IMO. Going out of your way to point out the spelling errors in the sample PM while yourself using h8 in place of hate (along with other issues) is being self-inconsistent. Regardless I don't feel it is anything other than a way to generate discussion in this case.

well... I do agree with you that self-inconsistancy is a huge scum-tell, but if and

only if

it's related to the game itself... not if it is related to something like grammar.
just wanted to point out that logical fallacy, done on purpose or not

[Tasky]

So for now:

UNVOTE: Lemon
VOTE: MagnaofIllusion

[MagnaofIllusion]

Second Self-Inconsistancy (

in relation to actual game issues

) is a huge scum-tell IMO. Going out of your way to point out the spelling errors in the sample PM while yourself using h8 in place of hate (along with other issues) is being self-inconsistent. Regardless

I don't feel it is anything other than a way to generate discussion in this case.

well... I do agree with you that self-inconsistancy is a huge scum-tell, but if and

only if

it's related to the game itself... not if it is related to something like grammar.
just wanted to point out that logical fallacy, done on purpose or not

I've bolded my initial post to highlight where I say exactly what you are attempting to explain in your first sentance. What purpose do you have in making a point that was already made in the post you quoted?

[youngminii]

Second Self-Inconsistancy (in relation to actual game issues) is a huge scum-tell IMO. Going out of your way to point out the spelling errors in the sample PM while yourself using h8 in place of hate (along with other issues) is being self-inconsistent. Regardless I don't feel it is anything other than a way to generate discussion in this case.

well... I do agree with you that self-inconsistancy is a huge scum-tell, but if and

only if

it's related to the game itself... not if it is related to something like grammar.
just wanted to point out that logical fallacy, done on purpose or not

Agreed, what's wrong with using hate and h8 interchangeably? Nothing scummy about that at all.

[AClockworkMelon]

Lemon - Any point in pointing out the mod's spelling mistakes and non-use of green text?

[AClockworkMelon]

Tasky - Seconding Magna's confusion as to your voting for him for saying

exactly

what you said.

[Tasky]

Second Self-Inconsistancy (

in relation to actual game issues

) is a huge scum-tell IMO. Going out of your way to point out the spelling errors in the sample PM while yourself

using h8 in place of hate (along with other issues) is being self-inconsistent

. Regardless

I don't feel it is anything other than a way to generate discussion in this case.

well... I do agree with you that self-inconsistancy is a huge scum-tell, but if and

only if

it's related to the game itself... not if it is related to something like grammar.
just wanted to point out that logical fallacy, done on purpose or not

I've bolded my initial post to highlight where I say exactly what you are attempting to explain in your first sentance. What purpose do you have in making a point that was already made in the post you quoted?

well, ok... we are fine then... just wanted to make it clear...
to me "in relation to actual game issues" seemed like you applied to Lemons action
and the part in italics made me think you were connecting his inconsistency to the other kind of inconsistency (the one which IS a scum tell)
well... I interpreted the last bold part as saying that HIS post was just a way to generate discussion...

good to have made the point clear then, just didn't want other people to hurry to conclusions before having anything...

Tasky - Seconding Magna's confusion as to your voting for him for saying

exactly

what you said.

the vote was more like symbolic... I don't have any clear ideas yet, so I am just throwing around my vote and see what happens and what reactions I get

[chihuahua0]

My Chihuahuas conform this by faxing

a kitty

to Zang's bunny. Many are outraged.

Be careful, this is my first game out of the newbie forums.

[chihuahua0]

Oh, and here's my random vote:

VOTE: AClockworkMelon for making a pun out of a movie that had got the NC-17 rating. And because I see you too much.

[youngminii]

Oh, and here's my random vote:

VOTE: AClockworkMelon for making a pun out of a movie that had got the NC-17 rating. And because I see you too much.

*Book

[Tasky]

My Chihuahuas conform this by faxing

a kitty

to Zang's bunny. Many are outraged.

Be careful, this is my first game out of the newbie forums.

UNVOTE: MagnaofIllusion

VOTE: chihuahua0

because I absolutely did not get what you said in that first line of yours

[AClockworkMelon]

And because I see you too much.

?

[RetroAudio]

VOTE: youngminii

Since I can't see his avatar and is too shady D:

[youngminii]

It's a Zealot man! A very pixelated one

[Mindgamer]

Hello MagnaofIllusion! Hello RetroAudio!
It's always nice to play with people you know.

And hello to Zang! I've been looking forward to your game.

Unfortunately, I can't say hello to my role PM because I don't have it.

Zang, could I get my role PM please?

I'll post some actual content once I have received my role PM.