Kingdom Hearts Mafia - Game Over!

[Gorrad]

I've given it thought. However, I'm not going to say if it actually does relate.

Vote: DisCode

for rolefishing.

[DisCode]

I've given it thought. However, I'm not going to say if it actually does relate.

Vote: DisCode

for rolefishing.

Please explain how it's rolefishing when I asked to think about it as you two and most likely an unknown player are the only ones who can possibly figure out what it means right now.

[Gorrad]

Asking us to think about it is tantamount to asking for our thoughts.

[DisCode]

Why I asked:
You and Plum are mentioned in it. Unless it was an ability activated by one of you, which I doubt hence the unknown player, you two and the unknown player are the only ones who can tell something about it.
As I'm pretty sure it's not just flavour and as I doubt it was a power from you or Plum, it means it can tell us something about the allignment of the unknown player of which you two might know more.
Which is why I want you two to think about what it could mean. Because if it's important, you two and the unknown player are the only ones who can tell.

[Cobalt]

Why are you conjecturing an unknown player?

[RayFrost]

unvote, vote: DisCode

1. claimed he's an alt of mine, he's obv a bm alt

2. too much conjecture on pointless things that makes 'em suspicious

3. what gorrad said

[DisCode]

Why are you conjecturing an unknown player?

As said, I'm pretty sure it's not just flavour. Meaning that it has nothing to do with the mod himself.
I also believe that it's not a power activated by Plum or Gorrad.
Which leaves only option c for me: An unknown player.

(No, there's no comical fourth option that could be applied)

[DisCode]

unvote, vote: DisCode

1. claimed he's an alt of mine, he's obv a bm alt

2. too much conjecture on pointless things that makes 'em suspicious

3. what gorrad said

1. See my first post and note that it wasn't serious. (Not a BM alt btw)

2. Please point them out.

3. Please explain in your own words how it's rolefishing after having looked at my posts including the explanations.

[RayFrost]

unvote, vote: DisCode

1. claimed he's an alt of mine, he's obv a bm alt

2. too much conjecture on pointless things that makes 'em suspicious

3. what gorrad said

1. See my first post and note that it wasn't serious. (Not a BM alt btw)

2. Please point them out.

3. Please explain in your own words how it's rolefishing after having looked at my posts including the explanations.

1. see that my first reason is obv a joke

2. really, conjecture on flavor, regardless of if it is a mod hint or some other thing like that, is pointless. It will give no value to anybody but those mentioned, and it is unnecessary for those not in some way directly related to it being part of the consideration.

3. you are placing huge conjecture based upon gorrad's and pome's roles and, though you aren't directly asking them to say it, are implying a desire to know via the fact you say stuff along the lines of "well, htis probably has something to possibly do with either of your roles, please consider it, as only you and this mysterious other player have something at all to do with it." <--- seriously, this is practically saying right out "consider it and tell us your conclusions" in an indirect way.

role fishing.

'nuff said.

[DisCode]

2. It's not pointless at all. Every post that is not a mod post (Like vote counts and such, so excluding posts with hints if present) can tell us something about a player. And I believe that this is the case with Post 29. It can tell us something about three players, if two of them (Plum and Gorrad) are willing to work with it. Which is why I want them to think about it.

3. First of all, it's Plum. Secondly, of course I'm not asking them to say it as I'm not interested in their roles as of yet. But they might have information due to Post 29. And in that I am interested for reasons stated above.

[RayFrost]

2. It's not pointless at all. Every post that is not a mod post (Like vote counts and such, so excluding posts with hints if present) can tell us something about a player. And I believe that this is the case with Post 29. It can tell us something about three players, if two of them (Plum and Gorrad) are willing to work with it. Which is why I want them to think about it.

3. First of all, it's Plum. Secondly, of course I'm not asking them to say it as I'm not interested in their roles as of yet. But they might have information due to Post 29. And in that I am interested for reasons stated above.

2. it

was

a mod post. you have

no guarantee

that it was anything more than flavor when slicey had

promised

flavor. Thus, it is WIFOM speculation. In addition, you are still (as cobalt said) making the assumption there is a mystery third person that somehow forced the mod to post this. This assumption is in of itself

very

foolish.

3. yeah, yeah, I'm in games with both of them, I'm bound to get them mixed up (I mean, seriously, they are

sisters

). The only real reason you should have "interest" in it is if they state their conclusions. Otherwise, all you are doing is trying to direct them, since you get no information, and nor does the town, really (this in no way means I think gorrad and plum are scum, so don't try that misrep). In addition, focusing

purely

on this single thing is distracting

at best

, since only gorrad, plum, and the potential third person have any information.

The rest of the town considering it will only be a detriment to

actual

scum hunting.

[DisCode]

2. I have two reasons why I think it's not just a mod post. The first has to do with what you say in your post: Flavour. Please note the difference between the flavour of the first post and Post 29. Please come back to this point after having seen the difference. If you can afterwards say that Post 29 is just flavour as Slicey promised and actually believe that, I'll have disproven that you're the alt of Cicero.
I have no intention revealing the second reason, but it will be shown some day.

3. No, I want them to think about it and if they think it's important, it should be looked into. It's not distracting as it gives information about players.
Also, there are a few ways to scumhunt. This is also a kind of scumhunting.

[RayFrost]

2. I have two reasons why I think it's not just a mod post. The first has to do with what you say in your post: Flavour. Please note the difference between the flavour of the first post and Post 29. Please come back to this point after having seen the difference. If you can afterwards say that Post 29 is just flavour as Slicey promised and actually believe that, I'll have disproven that you're the alt of Cicero.
I have no intention revealing the second reason, but it will be shown some day.

3. No, I want them to think about it and if they think it's important, it should be looked into. It's not distracting as it gives information about players.
Also, there are a few ways to scumhunt. This is also a kind of scumhunting.

for one... you are taking the cicero alt claim way too seriously. It's a joke from a GD thread IIRC.

2. For the purposes of the average townie,

it is

just flavor. I will treat it as such, since I lack the information necessary to even consider it as a possible mod hint or otherwise. I'll cede the point that you

may

be right that it is some kind of mod hint or player message or some such. As far as I'm concerned, it's worthless.

3. I suppose that there are ways of scumhunting that I don't know (annoyingly...), then. It is, however, a distraction to the majority of the town, since virtually none of us (Save potential mystery player A and plum/gorrad) have the information necessary to know what it's about.

unvote, vote: cobalt

I have reasons.

[DisCode]

I know it's a joke >.< I don't think we understand each others humour
I'll discuss this point further if needed after more players have given their insights/opinions.

[RayFrost]

I doubt we have similar humor at all.

[joe478]

unvote, vote: cobalt

I have reasons.

Are you going to share these reasons with anyone else or just keep them to yourself?

[RayFrost]

unvote, vote: cobalt

I have reasons.

Are you going to share these reasons with anyone else or just keep them to yourself?

obv, I'm going to keep them to myself.

Read the thread and you might figure it out on your own.

[joe478]

2. I have two reasons why I think it's not just a mod post. The first has to do with what you say in your post: Flavour. Please note the difference between the flavour of the first post and Post 29. Please come back to this point after having seen the difference.

I see your point here, the use of the actual players names instead of characters probably means something but not to you or anyone but those 2 and a potential 3rd mystery person so there isn't much point in you following up on this at the moment but it could be useful when we find out their alignments.

[Shotty to the Body]

Lol @ Whoot and Mufasa being the same person, no wonder Mufasa kept randomly posting in your thread SSK.

2. I have two reasons why I think it's not just a mod post. The first has to do with what you say in your post: Flavour. Please note the difference between the flavour of the first post and Post 29. Please come back to this point after having seen the difference.

I see your point here, the use of the actual players names instead of characters probably means something but not to you or anyone but those 2 and a potential 3rd mystery person so there isn't much point in you following up on this at the moment but it could be useful when we find out their alignments.

I agree with this.

Vote RECKONER

Thanks for the set-up review.

[Sir Chris]

*Yawned*

Well Thanksgiving was good, and lots of early voting, interesting, I guess you guys aren't shy about tossing around votes, that's cool.

I don't like the tone of Gorrad's posts so I am going to say he is scum and vote him, yes, that sounds excellent.

Vote: Gorrad

[RayFrost]

Everybody should be voting cobalt or at least in some way suspicious of cobalt.

My word is the truth.

Obey, my servants!

[Sir Chris]

What a troublesome player you are, RayFrost, a person with more ego than myself. I don't think I'll be obeying you, I am afraid.

[RayFrost]

What a troublesome player you are, RayFrost, a person with more ego than myself. I don't think I'll be obeying you, I am afraid.

What a troublesome player you are, Sir Chris, a person with less ego than myself. I don't think I'll be trusting you, I am afraid.

[Sir Chris]

Pfft, I didn't ask for your trust.

[RayFrost]

Pfft, I didn't ask for you to speak.