Mini 1830 - Game Over

[Square World]

Manuel87

wanna lynch huntress with me?

[Gamma Emerald]

@Manuel: your posts just feel like they're coming from scum. Throwing shade on your entire wagon doesn't help your case at all, FYI.

[CCC]

BUT, I plead to my fellow towns, please lynch square, do I have to quote all the contradictions again? I don't get why people can't see that.

Square is one of my top three scumreads. I wouldn't be totally averse to a Square lynch.

Having said that, he's also the lowest of my top three scumreads right now. Most of his contradictions come from his having re-evaluated the thread from the beginning, and his reads changed over that time.

[gerryoat]

Who are your other 3?

Also to the people wanting Gamma today, can you give me your cases on Gamma?

[CCC]

What he was doing, in this case, was a lack of action rather than an action. Had he not pointed it out, there would have been no discussion of it.

I disagree. Posting without voting can be a good way to start discussion (I've sometimes done that myself), but my point there was that rather than waiting to see who reacted, he presented himself as one who was Doing Something. Meaning, he gave me the impression he was trying to

look

townie rather than actually being townie.

...I don't see how this would be scummy, though. It simply leads to a different sort of discussion.

[Gamma Emerald]

BUT, I plead to my fellow towns, please lynch square, do I have to quote all the contradictions again? I don't get why people can't see that.

Square is one of my top three scumreads. I wouldn't be totally averse to a Square lynch.

Having said that, he's also the lowest of my top three scumreads right now. Most of his contradictions come from his having re-evaluated the thread from the beginning, and his reads changed over that time.

I'm mostly null on Square right now, although he did flood the game with his catch-up that one time. Would not be averse to lynching Square either.

[Square World]

lol there are people wanting to lynch gamma

how many scum are between these people?

[CCC]

@ CCC:

I know you had a slight early suspicion of Manuel, but your recent comments on him seem to be more based on eager's posts about him rather than Manuel's own posts.

I've got some comment's on eager's case on Manuel but I've run out of time for now.

It's more about Manuel's

replies

to Eager's posts at the moment, really.

[Gamma Emerald]

lol there are people wanting to lynch gamma

how many scum are between these people?

What's that supposed to mean? Do you think the people wanting to lynch me are scum? Do you think I'm scum? This post is so vague.

[Square World]

victordeangelo, manuel87

did i forget someone?

[Square World]

lol there are people wanting to lynch gamma

how many scum are between these people?

What's that supposed to mean? Do you think the people wanting to lynch me are scum? Do you think I'm scum? This post is so vague.

you look like a juicy mislynch, why wouldn't scum be on you?

[Square World]

i'd also be willing to consider grendel too

[CCC]

wait what happened to your CCC read, house?

House's "rock solid" "obvscum" cases tend to suddenly vanish without warning or explanation. I think he just massively talks up minor scumleans.

[Square World]

anyone up to hunt huntress?

[Gamma Emerald]

anyone up to hunt huntress?

Will have to re-ISO.

[CCC]

How am I refusing to work with you?

Do a combined ISO of eager and Gamma... Tell me whether you see the blatant scum theater or not please.

...I've taken a look over Gamma/Eager. There's a couple of iffy things in there; but nothing that looks significant enough to change the order of my reads.

[gerryoat]

CCC who are your other scumreads?

[Gamma Emerald]

On Huntress: I can't really see anything scummy in her ISO. Why do you scumread her, Square?

[gerryoat]

he's trying to ML the person who subbed in

[Gamma Emerald]

he's trying to ML the person who subbed in

How do you know it's a ML?

[CCC]

Wow, it took me openly second guessing myself for people to admit that Gamma isn't widely town read. You guys had me feeling like I was seeing things that weren't there.

Is there enough support for a Gamma lynch to push it through today?

UNVOTE:

Gamma's my second-top scumread. I'd be willing to vote for him, though I still think Manuel is scummier.

[eagerSnake]

On Huntress: I can't really see anything scummy in her ISO. Why do you scumread her, Square?

Probably because her reason for voting me is horrible. She claims to have done meta reads, I'd assume she would prioritize those on her scumreads, but I don't think she did, I think she was just trying to look like she was doing something as an excuse for not posting. Anyway, I'll let you guys do the meta read on me, here's the 2 games I drew scum on this site.

3 months ago:
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=67153 (Newbie 1722)
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=94&t=67154 (Newbie 1722 Mafia PT)

Last month:
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=67932 (Mini Normal 1823)
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=94&t=67933 (Mini Normal 1823 Mafia PT)

[CCC]

Calm down, Eager. You're becoming irrational.

I was dealing with someone who is being irrational. That sort of behavior is, well, toxic.

But letting it get at you is no good for anybody.

[CCC]

Who are your other 3?

Also to the people wanting Gamma today, can you give me your cases on Gamma?

My top three scumreads are Manuel, Gamma, and Square.

[gerryoat]

he's trying to ML the person who subbed in

How do you know it's a ML?

because he's maf???? lol. i wouldnt try getting him lynched if i didnt think he was maf