Xite wrote: From what I saw of volkan, he is also kind of scummy. He needs to start posting his ideas and standpoints on players, and of course actual cases, instead of, oh that's not scummy.
I agree with your evidence (I haven't had any strong cases), but I don't agree with your conclusion (that it makes me scummy).
Bit of self-meta: My scum game generally looks more pro-town than my town game. The reason why is that I am naturally skeptical of whether things are town-tells or scum-tells; it makes me ultra-conservative as a player (as in, I am more likely to see many things as null-tells than most people). When I am scum, that natural skepticism can fly out the window, so I can (and Andrius can attest to this) make really awesome-sounding cases which are logical, even though I think they are bullshit.
I had this issue in Mini 987 as well, which is my most recently-finished town game. What helped me there was to do a short paragraph on each player and give them a numerical ranking, so I will do that here.
Xite wrote: The fact that he flipped town just makes you more likely to be scum.
No.
Townies commit 'scumtells' all the time. Townies are legitimately lynched all the time. Being on the wagon of a townie does not make a player more likely to be scum unless there was some defect in the wagon.
