In post 73, ZZZX wrote:I actually got a weird idea.
Here is a question that might give us info
Who were the most people who pushed esp's post as scummy etc?
It was really just Rubicon.
In post 73, ZZZX wrote:I actually got a weird idea.
Here is a question that might give us info
Who were the most people who pushed esp's post as scummy etc?
In post 72, ZZZX wrote:With 2 scum teams I think the common scum hunting methods are not really 100% effective as both scum teams will have to actually to try scum hunt for scum so its actually easier to appear townie.
In post 58, Mr_Ree wrote:Poorly executed,not shit. Sort of opportunistic but made sense with the flow of conversation at the time.He should have voted when he proclaimed Rubicon as scum.
In post 68, Drew-Sta wrote:In post 58, Mr_Ree wrote:Poorly executed,not shit. Sort of opportunistic but made sense with the flow of conversation at the time.He should have voted when he proclaimed Rubicon as scum.
In post 45, BBmolla wrote:Rubi is scum
Err, he did - within two posts. Seemed more like he realised after the fact he hadn't voted, then did.
Some interesting posts now I've worken up and all you lot have had a few things to say.
In post 69, Mr_Ree wrote:That's why I said poorly executed. If you proclaim someone as scum, normally you drop the vote right away, not as an afterthought. After all, they're scum right? Vote them the hell off the island!
In post 77, Drew-Sta wrote:Rubi - in 28 you pick up on an assumed 'tell', but then get quite defensive of that in 51. Your focus then seems to shift almost seamlessly to Molla in 60 and 64 - why the rapid shift? Why not place more pressure on George Clooney (Nespresso)? I might be over reading here, but both your posts appear to be throwing mud, without actually pressuring them. Generating dirt on players that can be used later is... interesting.
In post 80, Espressojet wrote:In post 72, ZZZX wrote:With 2 scum teams I think the common scum hunting methods are not really 100% effective as both scum teams will have to actually to try scum hunt for scum so its actually easier to appear townie.
Oh my god, I never even thought about that!
Like, seriously, this post looks super sarcastic, but I'm actually going to have to go back and reread this thread with this in mind...
In post 78, ZZZX wrote:I have a theory. Blue scum is 50% more likely to pick on that slip since they will believe it is more real (you got what I mean?)
which is really interesting. Since if you were werewolf in another game and you saw something hunting for WW and not mafia and it seemed like a slip the WW will be more likely to notice it.
In post 84, Rubicon wrote:In post 78, ZZZX wrote:I have a theory. Blue scum is 50% more likely to pick on that slip since they will believe it is more real (you got what I mean?)
which is really interesting. Since if you were werewolf in another game and you saw something hunting for WW and not mafia and it seemed like a slip the WW will be more likely to notice it.
that's one of the reasons why I pointed it out. multiball reaction test.
In post 78, ZZZX wrote:I have a theory. Blue scum is 50% more likely to pick on that slip since they will believe it is more real (you got what I mean?)
which is really interesting. Since if you were werewolf in another game and you saw something hunting for WW and not mafia and it seemed like a slip the WW will be more likely to notice it.
If I wanted to make a case against him, I'd point out that the actual vote came after Boon voiced support for the wagon, which would put it at L-1 if he hopped on.
In post 79, Boonskiies wrote:WAIT!!! I actually think cappuccino might be scum.
He wanted to wait the day out longer so if Rubicon were to flip Vengeful Townie, he was definitely gonna venge kill his main suspect, right? If mocha is scum, he might be trying to keep away from the possibility that Rubicon has a lower chance of being scum, as he knows himself and his partner, so by probability, rubicon has a good chance of being a vengeful townie, thus ending Latte's streak.
Coffee, what is your reaction to this possibility?
PEdit: I meant espresso by those various coffee types, just in case you didn't catch on.
In post 89, Espressojet wrote:In post 79, Boonskiies wrote:WAIT!!! I actually think cappuccino might be scum.
He wanted to wait the day out longer so if Rubicon were to flip Vengeful Townie, he was definitely gonna venge kill his main suspect, right? If mocha is scum, he might be trying to keep away from the possibility that Rubicon has a lower chance of being scum, as he knows himself and his partner, so by probability, rubicon has a good chance of being a vengeful townie, thus ending Latte's streak.
Coffee, what is your reaction to this possibility?
PEdit: I meant espresso by those various coffee types, just in case you didn't catch on.
Well, that's some pretty good logic, but where you fall apart is the fact that I wasn't trying to get Rubic lynched in the first place. The only real scumread I have on him is the potential truth in post 78 from ZZZX
-----
@Drew: Your reads list is full of a lot of nothing, why did you bother posting a full list?
In post 69, Mr_Ree wrote:That's why I said poorly executed. If you proclaim someone as scum, normally you drop the vote right away, not as an afterthought. After all, they're scum right? Vote them the hell off the island!
In post 91, BBmolla wrote:In post 69, Mr_Ree wrote:That's why I said poorly executed. If you proclaim someone as scum, normally you drop the vote right away, not as an afterthought. After all, they're scum right? Vote them the hell off the island!
I can't vote all the scum though
In post 89, Espressojet wrote:In post 79, Boonskiies wrote:WAIT!!! I actually think cappuccino might be scum.
He wanted to wait the day out longer so if Rubicon were to flip Vengeful Townie, he was definitely gonna venge kill his main suspect, right? If mocha is scum, he might be trying to keep away from the possibility that Rubicon has a lower chance of being scum, as he knows himself and his partner, so by probability, rubicon has a good chance of being a vengeful townie, thus ending Latte's streak.
Coffee, what is your reaction to this possibility?
PEdit: I meant espresso by those various coffee types, just in case you didn't catch on.
Well, that's some pretty good logic, but where you fall apart is the fact thatI wasn't trying to get Rubic lynched in the first place. The only real scumread I have on him is the potential truth in post 78 from ZZZX
In post 93, ZZZX wrote:In post 91, BBmolla wrote:In post 69, Mr_Ree wrote:That's why I said poorly executed. If you proclaim someone as scum, normally you drop the vote right away, not as an afterthought. After all, they're scum right? Vote them the hell off the island!
I can't vote all the scum though
Why does this feel like a muiltiball slip/miswording to me?
In post 94, Boonskiies wrote:In post 89, Espressojet wrote:In post 79, Boonskiies wrote:WAIT!!! I actually think cappuccino might be scum.
He wanted to wait the day out longer so if Rubicon were to flip Vengeful Townie, he was definitely gonna venge kill his main suspect, right? If mocha is scum, he might be trying to keep away from the possibility that Rubicon has a lower chance of being scum, as he knows himself and his partner, so by probability, rubicon has a good chance of being a vengeful townie, thus ending Latte's streak.
Coffee, what is your reaction to this possibility?
PEdit: I meant espresso by those various coffee types, just in case you didn't catch on.
Well, that's some pretty good logic, but where you fall apart is the fact thatI wasn't trying to get Rubic lynched in the first place. The only real scumread I have on him is the potential truth in post 78 from ZZZX
That's my point exactly. You wouldn't want him to be lynched as a vengeful townie because he would venge kill you.'
In post 77, Drew-Sta wrote:So far:
Mr Ree - post 39 appears like you're attempting to downplay a possible slip (I'd say almost protectively, but others also did the same so I am happy to say it isn't based on others responses), almost like you're setting a precedent for what should or shouldn't be read as a slip. Why?
In post 77, Drew-Sta wrote:Further to this, you seem very interested in the self vote of Nespressojet in 44 - this is curious to me. RVS is, or should be, fairly random. Why does the self vote grab your attention?