Newbie Mafia 17 - GAME OVER -

[Jaguar]

Well, this seals it for me. My investigation of Stimpy came back Mafia, so let's get ths game over with.

vote: Stimpy

[Flying Dutchman]

The town wakes only to find a gun shot through Flying Dutchman's heart. It has been an eventfull night.

Not the bullet, but the

gun

went through my heart!?




Auch............



Well, go town!!!!

[Morpheus]

vote stimpy

obviously since he claimed doc. Stimpy you shouldn't have kiled the other claimed doc when you claimed doc and knew you were lying

[Yoko Kurama]

The two remaining town confront Stimpy....You're mafia....

Nope, I'm the Doc

......The Doc died already.....

Errr Back up Doc

????

Stimpy-Mafia

Dies Congratulations Town you win in a short amount of time!!!!

[Morpheus]

Yeah Go me and Jaguar! Hey Jaguar does this make up for us losing as mafia buddies in Newbie 14?

[Yaw]

Way to go, town!

So it was Cam and Stimpy, eh? That certainly puts Cam's comments about Stimpy on day 1 in a different light.

I followed the game after dying, and there's one thing I still don't understand. FD, why did you quick lynch gslamm, especially

after

saying you didn't think he was scum?

[Jaguar]

Yeah Go me and Jaguar! Hey Jaguar does this make up for us losing as mafia buddies in Newbie 14?

Absolutely I was a little concerned when Stimpy came out and claimed to be the doc, but when he killed FD, he certainly cemented his demise. I almost thought that FD was playing masterfully as scum if Stimpy was indeed the Doc.

In the end I am glad that we had both the cop and doc survive to day 2. I think that was definitely key for the town to win this game.

[gslamm]

~Bah~ I had it figured out before *I* was lynched. Trying to convince the rest of you though was too much for me.

Good job Town!

...and nice try Cam

[Flying Dutchman]

I followed the game after dying, and there's one thing I still don't understand. FD, why did you quick lynch gslamm, especially

after

saying you didn't think he was scum?

Well, I knew he was either townie or scum, he would've said if it was otherwise, and I avoided the risk the doc or cop had to claim on day 1 with this.

[mathcam]

Okay, the continuation of my rant.

Killing me before I got a chance to post was a horrible idea. If I had been the cop, you would have lost the game right there. Suppose Jaguar and Morpheus are the mafia together. Jaguar comes out and says "I'm a cop, I know Morpheus is innocent." FD says "Oh, I'm a doc. It's pretty clear that the other 2 are mafia." And then the town loses. You

always

have to give time for someone to respond, just in case the claimed cop is actually the mafia.

And how did you know Stimpy wasn't the doc? Again, people started claiming FD as a "confirmed innocent." Why? Because he claimed doc first? If that were the case, it would be optimal mafia strategy to always claim doc at the start of day 2.

That said, well done town.

Cam

[Jaguar]

I understand where you are coming from, Mathcam, but I didn't want you to muddy the waters with a defence . If I had been a townie, I sure would have wanted to hear more, but I had additional information in this case and FD and Morpheus voting for you made it easy for me to take the kill shot.

I wasn't 100% sure which one was the real doc, but was leaning towards Flying Dutchman even before he claimed. I figured by getting rid of one mafia scum (you) I could investigate for the last one. Stimpy killing off the doc only confirmed it for Morpheus.

Even if Stimpy had taken out Morpheus on the last night, FD would have known that Stimpy was scum, so I don't think that Stimpy stood a chance after his doc claim. The only chance he had was to have claimed cop instead of doc, muddying the waters for the remaining player. He could have claimed that he investigated someone with an innocent return and then try to accuse me of being the last scum.

[Morpheus]

And how did you know Stimpy wasn't the doc? Again, people started claiming FD as a "confirmed innocent." Why?

I ddn't think he was confirmed. I knew you were scum mathcam and I was pretty sure stimpy was but if FD was then jag would've gotten an innocent result and We would've gotten FD and won anyway. This is what would happen.

Doc protects Jag (cop
Mafia kills me
Cop investigates stimpy
3 people left 2 docs 1 cop
Gos by jags info.
We knew I was innocent and so was jag. Now only the docs. You investigate one and find out both.
And when he killed the doc he practically killed himself.

[Corsato]

Congrats to the town, and compliments to Yoko for his modding.
I was co-modding, but he didn't need me.

[Norinel]

Sorting bump