populartajo wrote:Do you want the real cop to counterclaim? Why?
Because if Coheed's scum then he should die? I'd find a counterclaim several days later to be less believable. Who knows if there's a cop? My complete game here didn't have a cop, which the town only found out once a dead watcher and tracker showed up.
iamausername wrote:Isn't there a chance that we have more than one cop?
I dunno.
iamausername wrote:And even if Coheed is lying, do we actually want our cop (if we have one at all) to out himself immediately?
I guess I'd be more tempted to answer yes if this weren't semi-open, but it'll sure suck if we get to LYLO before someone counterclaims.
iamausername wrote:What about the 8 other players in the game besides yourself and Coheed?
They're below Mellowed Man, obviously. That's why I was voting Mellowed Man before.
iamausername wrote:You know what, Vote: Matt_S. This "I'm going to wait and see how everyone else votes before I commit myself to anything" attitude he's been displaying latey has pushed it over the edge.
You mean the fact that I didn't revote because arguments involving other players could have revealed new info? Or the fact that I'm waiting for responses to someone's claim?