mini #585 - A Tempest Has Formed (Over), Thanks Patrick!!

[Matt_S]

Do you want the real cop to counterclaim? Why?

Because if Coheed's scum then he should die? I'd find a counterclaim several days later to be less believable. Who knows if there's a cop? My complete game here didn't have a cop, which the town only found out once a dead watcher and tracker showed up.

Isn't there a chance that we have more than one cop?

I dunno.

And even if Coheed is lying, do we actually want our cop (if we have one at all) to out himself immediately?

I guess I'd be more tempted to answer yes if this weren't semi-open, but it'll sure suck if we get to LYLO before someone counterclaims.

What about the 8 other players in the game besides yourself and Coheed?

They're below Mellowed Man, obviously. That's why I was voting Mellowed Man before.

You know what, Vote: Matt_S. This "I'm going to wait and see how everyone else votes before I commit myself to anything" attitude he's been displaying latey has pushed it over the edge.

You mean the fact that I didn't revote because arguments involving other players could have revealed new info? Or the fact that I'm waiting for responses to someone's claim?

[iamausername]

it'll sure suck if we get to LYLO before someone counterclaims.

I severely doubt we'll be in lylo on D2 though.

They're below Mellowed Man, obviously. That's why I was voting Mellowed Man before.

OK, but is anyone besides Mellowed higher than anyone else?

You mean the fact that I didn't revote because arguments involving other players could have revealed new info? Or the fact that I'm waiting for responses to someone's claim?

Yes.

[Matt_S]

I severely doubt we'll be in lylo on D2 though.

If a cop claims on day 2, then all they'll have is an investigation with uncertain sanity. If a cop won't counterclaim now, I'd imagine they won't claim until they get different investigation results which could be a while.

OK, but is anyone besides Mellowed higher than anyone else?

Cream.

[CoheedCambria09]

I'm not lying, my claim is true, thats why I wanted Night and why I was getting so p*ssed off, because now I'm screwed if we don't have doc.

And Just a note, I'll investigate someone tonight, and tell what I find out, but I don't know my sanity, so, my proposition is that a normal townie tell me that they are normal townie, and I will investigate them and see what happens. This is all depending on us having a doc.

[populartajo]

Because if Coheed's scum then he should die? I'd find a counterclaim several days later to be less believable. Who knows if there's a cop? My complete game here didn't have a cop, which the town only found out once a dead watcher and tracker showed up.

If you are doubting that there is a cop then why are you expecting someone to counterclaim?

Unvote. Vote : Matt_s

[Cream147]

@Cream : Why am I a worthy alternative?

Ah! Sorry for not explaining this. My basic reason is a notable lack of scumhunting in recent pages. You seem to not be attempting to find scum, instead hoping that we will do it all for you. However, that reason isn't as strong as the reasoning against Mellowed Man, hence my vote is on Mellowed Man. Worthy probably wasn't the word I was looking for, insert 'decent' into that sentence instead.

[iamausername]

my proposition is that a normal townie tell me that they are normal townie, and I will investigate them and see what happens. This is all depending on us having a doc.

Coheed, you are aware that the mafia are allowed to lie in this game, right?

[Cream147]

I'm not lying, my claim is true, thats why I wanted Night and why I was getting so p*ssed off, because now I'm screwed if we don't have doc.

And Just a note, I'll investigate someone tonight, and tell what I find out, but I don't know my sanity, so, my proposition is that a normal townie tell me that they are normal townie, and I will investigate them and see what happens. This is all depending on us having a doc.

there is an obvious flaw with your plan. Any damn person could tell you they were townie. If they come up as guilty, for all you know, that means they actually ARE guilty.

[populartajo]

Yay for activity

[Matt_S]

I'm not lying, my claim is true, thats why I wanted Night and why I was getting so p*ssed off, because now I'm screwed if we don't have doc.

And Just a note, I'll investigate someone tonight, and tell what I find out, but I don't know my sanity, so, my proposition is that a normal townie tell me that they are normal townie, and I will investigate them and see what happens. This is all depending on us having a doc.

That plan backfires if a mafia volunteers.

If you are doubting that there is a cop then why are you expecting someone to counterclaim?

It's called skepticism.

[Cream147]

Yay for activity

I know! I love it like this!

[iamausername]

Yay for activity

I know! I love it like this!

It's great.

HAY GUYS, THERE'S ABOUT 7 OF US HERE, LET'S ALL SPEEDLYNCH ELIAS!

[CoheedCambria09]

True, well, then I'm just gonna investiage someone, if there scum I'll say, If I investigated town I'll keep quiet and try to find scum throughout the day

[Matt_S]

True, well, then I'm just gonna investiage someone, if there scum I'll say, If I investigated town I'll keep quiet and try to find scum throughout the day

Announce all results, even innocents.

[populartajo]

True, well, then I'm just gonna investiage someone, if there scum I'll say, If I investigated town I'll keep quiet and try to find scum throughout the day

No. You tell us everything you get.

HAY GUYS, THERE'S ABOUT 7 OF US HERE, LET'S ALL SPEEDLYNCH ELIAS! Very Happy

It sounds good.

Unvote. Vote : Elias.

[Cream147]

Ok, I'm going to bed now, but I plan on rereading in the morning with a smarter head on me hopefully!

[Matt_S]

Ok, I'm going to bed now

Lol, timezones.

[CoheedCambria09]

Even if its a power roll?

[Matt_S]

Even if its a power roll?

Eh? Cops just get guilty or innocent. No role info.

[CoheedCambria09]

Ok, didn't know that, and are we actually lynching elias, or was that a joke?

[populartajo]

Even if its a power roll?

I bet Matt_s is going to post before but I dont care. Cop is supposed to get only guilty or innocent.

[Matt_S]

Even if its a power roll?

I bet Matt_s is going to post before but I dont care. Cop is supposed to get only guilty or innocent.

lol

I told people in another game that I'd be less active in the summer. Stop making me look like a liar.

[populartajo]

Even if its a power roll?

I bet Matt_s is going to post before but I dont care. Cop is supposed to get only guilty or innocent.

lol

I told people in another game that I'd be less active in the summer. Stop making me look like a liar.

Lol, no problem. Care to join me against Elias?

[iamausername]

Ok, I'm going to bed now, but I plan on rereading in the morning with a smarter head on me hopefully!

You forgot to vote Elias.

[CoheedCambria09]

Vote: Elias

mise as well get on the wagon, nights what i need.