Survivor: Mafia - Game Over, Report to Camp

[Charles Davis]

No. Apparently I'm the unwitting arch-nemesis of Fritzler, so he likes to get me lynched whenever possible. It also doesn't help that I have a bad ending to live down from scumchat mafia and a couple of people apparently feel I should be repeatedly punished for a mis-play. For those of you who understand mistakes happen, thank you for being grown-up. /rant

With that said, I won't mention it again.

It's okay, you can ask Fritz about the time I got him to lynch MoS, the claimed and proven Cop, because I withheld a nightkill and claimed unnightkillable. Ask him, MoS, Pieisgood (That's how I got my sig.. he called me a Mafia God)..

Everyone makes mistakes.. look at the invitational (oops)

ITS NOT OUR FAULT YOU WERE A PANSY AND SUBMITTED A NO KILL. WHY DON'T YOU GROW A SAC AND KILL SOMEONE? AND MOS WASN'T PROVEN. AND WE OBVIOUSLY DIDN'T HAVE A GRUDGE IF WE DIDN'T VOTE UNTIL DRAYGN MAGE TOLD US WE WERE SUPPOSED TO.

[elvis_knits]

Okay. I don't care about your sacs.

vote mark.six

I know this doesn't count, but I want to set a good example. Has he even posted yet?

Is that your reason? Tribal is less than 24 hours old and he's not the only one who hasn't posted. Selective much?

[Monty]

Okay. I don't care about your sacs.

vote mark.six

I know this doesn't count, but I want to set a good example. Has he even posted yet?

Is that your reason? Tribal is less than 24 hours old and he's not the only one who hasn't posted. Selective much?

For now, yeah, maybe later I'll have a better reason to vote for someone, but for now, he hasn't posted and that's good enough to get my vote.

I'll be active and changing my vote when necessary, so its not like this is final. I nearly voted for you based on my random in the camp thread, but didn't because you're participating.

[Yosarian2]

Are we gonna make people own up to their votes? I feel like it takes some of the fun out of this game, but it should help us catch scum. We'll have to pay attention to who says they're voting what and check with the official VC, but it could pay off. We'd also prob have to lynch anyone who refuses to own up to their vote.

(shrug) It couldn't hurt, but I'm not sure how we could enforce it.

Let's say 10 people claim they're not voting for anyone. One of them is lying. How can you tell who it is?

Its information... if we know that one of those 10 people is lying, we also can know that the other 14 are telling the truth... That's better than just going at this blind.

I highly recommend that people post in the thread. We keep an informal tally here, and compare it to the formal tally. Either the scum lie about their votes and risk being exposed by it, or they don't lie and we gain the same voting information we would in a regular game. Sounds like a win/win to me.

Huh...that's really odd...I thought I has posted a response to this, but my message seems to have dissapeared.

Anyway, I agree that that would be useful information to have, but it'll only work if all pro-town people go along with it. Does anyone want to claim their votes? We've already had something like 8 people vote, as of the last count, and all we know is that Fritz claimed he wasn't one of the two who had voted for Dragon Mage early on.

[ziliu]

I'm here. I just wanted to say I agree with that we should make informal votes here. Otherwise I don't have much to add, except that lurker hunting sounds like a good idea.

vote: marc.six

[Monty]

I'm here. I just wanted to say I agree with that we should make informal votes here. Otherwise I don't have much to add, except that lurker hunting sounds like a good idea.

vote: marc.six

Unofficial tally:

marc.six (2) Monty, ziliu

yet to vote - everyone else

[Jeff Probst]

Vote Tally

Blackberry - 1
Harry Potter - 1
Rupert - 2
marc.six - 2
draygn_mage - 3

Johnny Fairplay - 3

*

13 to lynch

*Timestamp rule added to OP, although I hope this doesn't come to a deadline.

[Monty]

Vote Tally

Blackberry - 1
Harry Potter - 1
Rupert - 2
marc.six - 2
draygn_mage - 3

Johnny Fairplay - 3

*

13 to lynch

*Timestamp rule added to OP, although I hope this doesn't come to a deadline.

Interesting...

Johnny Fairplay - 3

* - ???, ???, ???
draygn_mage - 3 - ???, ???, ???
Rupert - 2 - ???, ???
marc.six - 2 - Monty, Ziliu
Blackberry - 1 - ???
Harry Potter - 1 - ???

Yet to vote - 12

so we have 10 people voting who haven't claimed their vote yet. As far as I'm concerned there's no reason for a pro-town player to hide their vote, so anyone doing so is not playing optimally or is scum.

[marc.six]

Woah woah woah!
I'm not lurking, i've only just got back in from college! I didn't post at start of tribal council because i was trying to get to sleep! I'm not on CST time, am on GMT.

I don't really know who's scum yet, Jonny fairplay hasn't made many posts, and apparently he always acts this way.

vote mark.six

And it's marc.six thanks :p Anyway, there's other people who havn't posted yet (i think)

[Monty]

Woah woah woah!
I'm not lurking, i've only just got back in from college! I didn't post at start of tribal council because i was trying to get to sleep! I'm not on CST time, am on GMT.

I don't really know who's scum yet, Jonny fairplay hasn't made many posts, and apparently he always acts this way.

vote mark.six

And it's marc.six thanks :p Anyway, there's other people who havn't posted yet (i think)

That's fine, you were the first on my list. contribute something and I'll gladly move my vote.

[marc.six]

I feel like doing a random vote on Harry Potter because i don't like Daniel Radcliff, but that seems pointless. I'll have a re read and make an unofficial vote methinks.

[BabyJesus]

No. Apparently I'm the unwitting arch-nemesis of Fritzler, so he likes to get me lynched whenever possible. It also doesn't help that I have a bad ending to live down from scumchat mafia and a couple of people apparently feel I should be repeatedly punished for a mis-play. For those of you who understand mistakes happen, thank you for being grown-up. /rant

With that said, I won't mention it again.

I thought you played excellently in scumchat mafia. I will not be voting you for that.

[BabyJesus]

Vote Tally

Blackberry - 1
Harry Potter - 1
Rupert - 2
marc.six - 2
draygn_mage - 3

Johnny Fairplay - 3

*

13 to lynch

*Timestamp rule added to OP, although I hope this doesn't come to a deadline.

Interesting...

Johnny Fairplay - 3

* - ???, ???, ???
draygn_mage - 3 - ???, ???, ???
Rupert - 2 - ???, ???
marc.six - 2 - Monty, Ziliu
Blackberry - 1 - ???
Harry Potter - 1 - ???

Yet to vote - 12

so we have 10 people voting who haven't claimed their vote yet. As far as I'm concerned there's no reason for a pro-town player to hide their vote, so anyone doing so is not playing optimally or is scum.

f'n skimmah!!!! I already said I will always be voting for the vote leader. So my vote is on young Mr. Fairplay at the moment. Get someone else ahead of him, and my vote will follow.

[marc.six]

Will we get much of the Blue Tribe owning up to votes? They are meant to be playing against us.

[Yosarian2]

(shrug) In case it wasn't clear from my earlier posts, I'm not voting for anyone at the moment. If I had to vote, at the moment, it'd be for Jonney, but I think it's best for at least a good portion of the town to hold their votes for the moment.

So, taking a look at the "unnoffical let's catch the lying scum" voteboard:

Johnny Fairplay - 3* - ???, ???, Baby Jesus
draygn_mage - 3 - ???, ???, ???
Rupert - 2 - ???, ???
marc.six - 2 - Monty, Ziliu
Blackberry - 1 - ???
Harry Potter - 1 - ???

Yet to vote - 12 (Yosarian, ???, ???, ???, ???, ???, ???, ???, ???, ???, ???, ???)


If anyone does not want to claim their vote, I would at least like to hear why.

[LoudmouthLee]

I have not voted at this time.

[marc.six]

I havn't voted, i'm still looking for scum, have been reading throught he camp thread, Harry Potter's only made three posts throughout the entire camp, none in here, and has not really said anything of great use. Where's he/she at?

[Rupert]

WE'RE PROBABLY VOTING FOR DRAYGN MAGE.

says the man not in this tribe.

[marc.six]

Well they can vote for us. Anyway, we can vote them in the next tribal council (if we get immunity), the scum is probably in their team too you know.

[Rupert]

okay, this is weird, so we just limited to voting out one tribe or the other but EVERYONE VOTES.

Interesting.

I will not vote
Fairplay or Dragon Mage

I would really love to know who is voting for me...

I am going to cast a vote for blackberry I think.

[Monty]

Johnny Fairplay - 3* - ???, ???, Baby Jesus
draygn_mage - 3 - ???, ???, ???
Rupert - 2 - ???, ???
marc.six - 2 - Monty, Ziliu
Blackberry - 1 - ???
Harry Potter - 1 - ???

Yet to vote - 12 (Yosarian, LML, Rupert, Marc.six, ???, ???, ???, ???, ???, ???, ???)

now we're getting somewhere.

[Yosarian2]

okay, this is weird, so we just limited to voting out one tribe or the other but EVERYONE VOTES.

Interesting.

I will not vote
Fairplay or Dragon Mage

I would really love to know who is voting for me...

I am going to cast a vote for blackberry I think.

Ok...any specific reason you trust Fairplay and Dragon Mage and are suspicious of blackberry?

[draygn_mage]

actually I was voting Rupert. now that he's here and posting, I'll unvote.

[PeaceBringer]

okay, this is weird, so we just limited to voting out one tribe or the other but EVERYONE VOTES.

Interesting.

I will not vote
Fairplay or Dragon Mage

I would really love to know who is voting for me...

I am going to cast a vote for blackberry I think.

Ok...any specific reason you trust Fairplay and Dragon Mage and are suspicious of blackberry?

no it is day one-
Fairplay has been unfairly picked on during the "tribal" division bit.

I didn't like they way charles came out and said we all should vote mage.

That is it. Otherwise it is day freakin' one.

[PeaceBringer]

doh-LOL

Will post again as rupert at some point.