Guild of Dungeoneering Mafia (Game Over)

[Feysal]

Subbing in end-game sucks.

What, so you killed Shazam? He could not have been more obviously town!

Next time why don't you do the town a favor and don't replace in. Even though it may not be fair to expect the same understanding from you as from those who were here from the start, your judgement was extraordinarily terrible.

[DiamondSentinel]

How was Shazam obvi-town? I honestly can't see it.

[Feysal]

Read his day one fight with Oversoul. No one busses like that. Ever.

By the way, it would be nice to have the actions and dead thread released. As it is, it is impossible to tell what the hell happened in this game.

[DiamondSentinel]

Well, I wish someone would have brought that up. I tried reading the first couple days but my eyes glassed over, and I couldn't do it. Those 90 pages were just brutal.

[Skybird]

Congratulations Antihero!

Thanks Dram for hosting! I had fun with the game.

[dramonic]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=63265

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... sp=sharing

have fun trying to make out anything in there <_<

[Antihero]

What, so you killed Shazam? He could not have been more obviously town!

no, i killed shazam

[dramonic]

You both killed shazam.

[DrippingGoofball]

Thanks Dram for a great game!

[Katsuki]

btw DGB I can't remember if I said this during the game or not, but the only reason why I replaced into this game was because I had a townread on you. I was planning on sheeping you til the ends of this world without reading the game but then you kept trying to suggest me being scum. ;_;

[Katsuki]

ebwop: I seriously thought that this might be the game where I read your alignment wrong.

[Shazam]

dgb why would you ever lynch me </3

Maybe because you lied? And got caught lying? And still didn't admit you lied?
I seriously don't get how town could ever do that.
On top of it all, you condemned ME as being scum for telling the truth, which you knew was true.

Perhaps you shouldn't lie about the abilities you steal next time. Just an FYI

You must be seriously ignorant if you still think you're in the right here. I never said a word that was untrue about the abilities I stole. You called it a lie because you have never had a freaking clue about anything in this game.

[Shazam]

Gee, thanks. I'm glad that you have so much faith in me.

Oh, the irony.

[Shazam]

dgb why would you ever lynch me </3

Maybe because you lied? And got caught lying? And still didn't admit you lied?
I seriously don't get how town could ever do that.
On top of it all, you condemned ME as being scum for telling the truth, which you knew was true.

Perhaps you shouldn't lie about the abilities you steal next time. Just an FYI

You must be seriously ignorant if you still think you're in the right here. I never said a word that was untrue about the abilities I stole. You called it a lie because you have never had a freaking clue about anything in this game.

Wow, and the dead thread indicates you KNEW you had Arcane 2. How about you go read Arcane 2 from the role PMs? It never even occurred to you that maybe, just maybe Arcane 2 was the cop ability I was referring to that I had stolen from you?

It's a whole new level of fail.

[DrippingGoofball]

ebwop: I seriously thought that this might be the game where I read your alignment wrong.

Yeah you kept calling me scum for no reason, you really threw me off.

[DiamondSentinel]

Gee, thanks. I'm glad that you have so much faith in me.

Oh, the irony.

Meh, this is my second completed game on site, and forum mafia is way different from chatroom mafia. I'm way better at the latter, but I'm trying here. I'd appreciate if you'd give me half a chance at this stuff, though, without being jerks. Both games I've finished somebody has insulted me, which was completely uncalled for. Antihero and/or Fakegod did it in the game that they MODDED.

[Hippy Love]

Gee, thanks. I'm glad that you have so much faith in me.

Oh, the irony.

Meh, this is my second completed game on site, and forum mafia is way different from chatroom mafia. I'm way better at the latter, but I'm trying here. I'd appreciate if you'd give me half a chance at this stuff, though, without being jerks. Both games I've finished somebody has insulted me, which was completely uncalled for. Antihero and/or Fakegod did it in the game that they MODDED.

diamond you tried and you replaced into a game that was long, drawn out and tough. I think you were fine cos in the end you made the right decision. plz don't get discouraged. you were not the worst player in the game by far.

feysal is just mad cos town was in a sweet spot when we died and it hurts to see all of your hard work fall apart at the seams.

[Shazam]

Gee, thanks. I'm glad that you have so much faith in me.

Oh, the irony.

Meh, this is my second completed game on site, and forum mafia is way different from chatroom mafia. I'm way better at the latter, but I'm trying here. I'd appreciate if you'd give me half a chance at this stuff, though, without being jerks. Both games I've finished somebody has insulted me, which was completely uncalled for. Antihero and/or Fakegod did it in the game that they MODDED.

I wouldn't really call it insults, but the negativity sprang from the fact that you were ignoring a situation that 99.9% of the time would have been town vs. scum, and going after a townie instead. Turns out Katsuki was just ridiculously bad town, but your actions demonstrated to me that you weren't really trying to grasp the points I was making. I do think it's a lack of effort, not a lack of experience or a lack of ability. It's common sense that you don't ignore people who are calling each other liars for role-related reasons, especially when the consensus is that one of them is town. In fact Katsuki was a liar (or else didn't care to know the first thing about his own role and abilities).

Not grasping this led to your final mistake: killing me.

[Katsuki]

ebwop: I seriously thought that this might be the game where I read your alignment wrong.

Yeah you kept calling me scum for no reason, you really threw me off.

That's only because you kept calling me scum for no reason first!

[DrippingGoofball]

ebwop: I seriously thought that this might be the game where I read your alignment wrong.

Yeah you kept calling me scum for no reason, you really threw me off.

That's only because you kept calling me scum for no reason first!

Your lurking was suspicious.

[pirate mollie]

ebwop: I seriously thought that this might be the game where I read your alignment wrong.

Yeah you kept calling me scum for no reason, you really threw me off.

That's only because you kept calling me scum for no reason first!

Your lurking was suspicious.

I KNOW!

cupcake I love yout rolling funny self and I was missing you so I thought you were scum avoiding the game

I KNEW when it became clear when yoyo protected me n1 and there was a missing scumkill that it was most likely anti who tried to nk me but I kept forgetting about it. I am sorry guys I really shld have pushed that read harder.

ty for the game dramalama

grumble grumble that we lost grumble grumble

[T-Bone]

I got way too attached to my semiclear of Anti and scum on DGB so if anything if we're gonna sling shit start with me (but I will fite u irl mmk?).

[Feysal]

Yes, I am mad. During this game I tried to kill two scum, led lynches on two scum, confirmed the last one as scum, and you fools still lost. Diamond may not have been the worst since he has the excuse of replacing in, but he did post the stupidest ideas during the entire game.

Basically, I'm putting my trust in the mod that he wasn't too lazy to make 2 more roles, and decided to repeat a couple.

This thought is intriguing.

I mean, it's pretty logical.

Calling this logical is blasphemy. It is completely wrong on every level.

1. Outguessing the mod.

Setup speculation has its uses, but reading individual players is not one of them, and it is never reliable on its own.

2. Outguessing the mod in a confirmed bastard game.

There was even a specific warning not to do this in the game rules, and the game being bastard was bolded.

3. Outguessing the mod in a confirmed bastard game with conflicting information available.

There was already one pair of dead players who shared the same class but not their alignment.

4. Outguessing the mod in a confirmed bastard game with conflicting information available, then drawing the opposite conclusion.

Which is the lazy option, making more roles or repeating some? Your argument was the mod

not

being lazy, and you believed the lazy option.

...

There are no words for this. This argument was even worse than believing confessed scum could be town in endgame.

[Papa Zito]

There are no words for this. This argument was even worse than believing confessed scum could be town in endgame.

I dunno man, reading a scum player openly being snarky about his upcoming win and somehow just not getting it is p egregious.

if you have a double vote, diamond, i guess use it and gg?

you know... not like there wasn't a public watcher guilty on me since DAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYS ago

well... regardless of what dram said, this town performance was pretty shameful

you should be embarrassed

I mean

how do you read these any other way

[Katsuki]

ebwop: I seriously thought that this might be the game where I read your alignment wrong.

Yeah you kept calling me scum for no reason, you really threw me off.

That's only because you kept calling me scum for no reason first!

Your lurking was suspicious.

ebwop: I seriously thought that this might be the game where I read your alignment wrong.

Yeah you kept calling me scum for no reason, you really threw me off.

That's only because you kept calling me scum for no reason first!

Your lurking was suspicious.

I KNOW!

cupcake I love yout rolling funny self and I was missing you so I thought you were scum avoiding the game

I KNEW when it became clear when yoyo protected me n1 and there was a missing scumkill that it was most likely anti who tried to nk me but I kept forgetting about it. I am sorry guys I really shld have pushed that read harder.

ty for the game dramalama

grumble grumble that we lost grumble grumble

I would've expected DGB to understand my town game of identifying a strong townread then sheeping them to death considering this is what I was known for sitewide.

There wasn't much point of being active in a game I replaced into and didn't bother reading so.


p.s. Shazam you're terrible at this game pls quit mafia thx