At this point I'm leaning Jmj, with Jmj being goon and FarCry being GF with how Jmj tried to reinforce something FarCry said. Though still a bit early on this.MagnaofIllusion wrote:@Charter– If FarCry is scum, who do you think is likely to be his Partner?
I don't disagree, but I don't think he's scum for it.Magna wrote:Not anything remotely looking like questioning there and nothing in the way of an opinion on anyone’s alignment.
1. JMJ is putting forth ‘a lot of fluff’? He’s made 1 post. I could buy that you though he was lurking and only posting fluff but the way you phrase this looks suspect.Andrew wrote:my top suspect list is jmj as he puts a lot of fluff and is reinforcing what everyone else is saying
i also suspect magna cos he voted first for crap reasoning and is also trying to act like a leader
Yeah, this I’m really not fond of.FarCry wrote:I'm posting to say that I'm around. Sorry, I don't have the time today to reply to charter or MoI yet. I will get around to it tomorrow.
Agreed and seconded. In a Nightless environment with 5 players to start a hard D1 deadline makes no sense.charter wrote:Wait, what the hell, our deadline is in less than a week, pretty ridiculous to have a deadline in a vengeful.MOD request removing deadlineor at least extending it by a week or two.
I have not gotten a good read on anyone yet, as there haven't been that many posts since. Why is my indicisiveness scum and not town? I have not commented on everyone, if I am thinking of the same definition as you are. I have said some things on everybody's post, but the only person I ever directly commented on was andrew, when I said his play thus far give me a null read.charter wrote:Vote Far Cry
About 95% sure he's scum with the extreme passiveness in his posting so far. Pretty sure he's commented on everyone so far, but has avoided actually saying anything about everyone. Doing an inordinate amount of active lurking. I find it impossible to believe he's town and posted as much as he has and hasn't formed an opinion on anyone.
How does that post show anything?charter wrote:preview edit. His last post cements it. My vote is only going to move if I can determine the scumteam and who the GF is. At this point, not sure, but I am sure FarCry is scum.
Scum wait until it's safe to act. Town has to be proactive and scumhunt. You fall under the first category.Why is my indicisiveness scum and not town?
Active lurking. I don't care about lurkers.Why do you accuse me of lurking? Why are you not accusing jmj of doing the same? Andrew, hasn't brought much to the table. Why can't he be considered lurking?
Enough has happened that you should have reads on players. Everyone else does.And how does how many posts I've made correlate to my reads and opinions? The point is not how many posts I have made. Just because I have posted more doesn't mean I should have a read on someone.
Page three is about when the scumteam gets officially nailed down in vengefuls, we're already well into day one.See, the problem with your argument is that's there's only a page and a half. If we were well into D1 with a couple pages of posts, it would be more fair to accuse me of sitting on the fence. Now, I believe it's way to early to have a good read on someone.
Playing Magna and Andrew off each other while saying nothing yourself.How does that post show anything?
You’ve made 16 other posts here on MS after this post, several of which involve pictures. You phone posting excuse looks invalid at this juncture and I suspect you are avoiding the thread.jmj wrote:Sorry I haven't been posting, been on my phone for most of the last eel and still on it to post this. Tomorrow, when I wake up, I will post from my computer
When you do get around to posting some content please address the questions at 29 that you have so far ignored.Andrew wrote:yay!
talk more later
If FarCry flips Mafia Goon you are my number 1 suspect for Godfather. You’ve pretty much tunnelled in on FarCry to the extent of ignoring any other players. Your comments on Godfather / Goon distancing take on a new light when looking at your behavior. And your ‘confirmed as Mafia’ quote here reads of leading. Andrew’s constant statements that the hammerer would get Vengekilled has made sure that any Town are going to be hesitant to hammer. If you are already scum on your partner the lack of quick hammer when FarCry is at L-1 is just as likely Town hesitance to lose on a Vengekill as anything else.charter wrote:Someone should vote Farcry and we can see what happens. I bet he gets confirmed as mafia.
I am pretty sure I have commented on everyone and given reads on everyone, perhaps you should read my posts again. You seem to just be remembering my case against FarCry.MagnaofIllusion wrote:You’ve pretty much tunnelled in on FarCry to the extent of ignoring any other players.