Mini 574: Portal Mafia: HUGE SUCCESS

[Gorrad]

No haiku?

FoS: Guardian

Also, M-M, has a very good point. Flameaxe, he's a claimed power role with, I might add, a correct result. Don't vote him day two when there are plenty of other scummy folks.

[Flameaxe]

No haiku?

FoS: Guardian

Also, M-M, has a very good point. Flameaxe, he's a claimed power role with, I might add, a correct result. Don't vote him day two when there are plenty of other scummy folks.

Right, he claimed a power role that is a very easy fake-claim. I fail to see how that could affect my decision. I feel he is scummy, claim or no claim.

[Ether]

Eh? I thought I covered this already: Post 295

Ah. Your timing in 352 was and still is unclear, though 295 is valid.

While I wouldn't oppose a Scotlynch, I'm going to

unvote; vote: Flameaxe

.

[Glork]

"Please note that any appearance of danger is merely a device to enhance your testing experience."
-GLaDOS

[Vote Count:

Flameaxe 2 (Machiavellian-Mafia, Ether)
scotmany12 2 (Incognito, Gorrad)
Sir Tornado 1 (Your Worst Nightmare)
Machiavellian-Mafia 1 (Flameaxe)

9 alive, 5 to lynch

[Guardian]

ywn, can you link us to a site where you and the jester played, and give us your screen names?

[Incognito]

Eh? I thought I covered this already: Post 295

Ah. Your timing in 352 was and still is unclear, though 295 is valid.

Yeah, I should have made the transition clearer.

Mod:

Thanks for granting me the ability to vote for two people. I appreciate it.

Fixed.
-Glork

[scotmany12]

EBWOBBQ: What does the role Devil do?

Where did this come from? With that being said, the one time I encountered a devil, it acted like a rolecop for the mafia, but the mafia did not know who the devil was. Still though, I would like to know where this question of a devil coming from. Unless I am mistaken, you were the first to mention it.

[Incognito]

I think Gorrad mentioned it previously.

[Guardian]

erm, didn't mean to submit just that. whatev. if ywn can do that, I find him pretty cleared. if he can't, um, mucho suspicouso.

scot and flameaxe look the most guilty to me, really because they just don't have much content, they both seem to be actively lurking through the game. gorrad was similarly suspicious to me, but then he claimed a PR and mm also cleared him.

MM looked really scummy to me, but then claimed PR. I still think he might be scum, but letting him give another night of results can only be beneficial.

ywn looked suspicious too, but then Gorrad (who's all but confirmed town) said ywn was not a killer.

flameaxe's vote on MM seems like OMGUS on a claimed power role that imo unquestionably should not be lynched today.

I don't even have an idea of who scot finds most suspicious.

Those are my top two. I'd like to hear good reasons from them on who is most suspicious/should be lynched today.

I have thoughts on the other players that I could share, but I don't see a reason to discuss anything other than what I have at this point.

[Gorrad]

Guardian, that's about where I am too. I might swap my vote over to Flameaxe- this is getting ridiculous.

Also, I mentioned Devil because it's an antitown role without a kill ability. Scotmany has the role correct, although there are, as with any role, variations on it.

[Guardian]

I'd be voting Flameaxe except that would be lynch -1 and force a claim immediately, and I think there's time for discussion and a few things to talk about.

[Flameaxe]

I'd be voting Flameaxe except that would be lynch -1 and force a claim immediately, and I think there's time for discussion and a few things to talk about.

Funny enough, no it wouldn't.

[Guardian]

vote: Flameaxe

okay then.

[Flameaxe]

vote: Flameaxe

okay then.

Kay.

[Guardian]

You haven't responded in any substantive way to my 383. Do you intend to?

[Flameaxe]

Yes, when I'm not exhausted.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

Flameaxe: Since you ignored this question:

You have anything else after your reread/catchup besides an OMGUSy vote on an uncounterclaimed power role?

I assume your answer to that is no. Am I correct?

I'd be voting Flameaxe except that would be lynch -1 and force a claim immediately, and I think there's time for discussion and a few things to talk about.

Funny enough, no it wouldn't.

Yes, when I'm not exhausted.

I see, you must need some time and energy come up with a fake claim.

[scotmany12]

Guardian, I said that I found both Miztef and Incognito suspicous just from rereading. I haven't gotten around to anything on them yet because I have been getting home at 7 practically every night this week. Also, before they both got replaced, both akonas and sir t can have been said as actively lurking.

Why is Gorrad all but confirmed town? He claimed a pr that does not fit the rolename. Also, Gorrad, you never explained your vote on me. It seems that the only reason you voted for me was because I questioned your role, and I did rightfully so. Hardly more than an OMGUS. You didn't even have me as your top three suspicious, or flameaxe for that matter, when you posted your reread.

[Guardian]

Scot, Gorrad scum implies MM scum, and ywn and whomever gorrad investigates tonight town.

Strictly speaking, that's

possible

, but we'll deal with that if and when MM turns up scum. Gorrad shouldn't be lynched unless we're at lylo and MM has already turned up scum.

Well, I get that you're busy, but naming two names with zero justification doesn't help me determine your alignment, or theirs.

[Gorrad]

Scot, both those suspicions occured AFTER the reread. I got tired of Flameaxe's excuses with lack of results, and you, as Guardian said, are making a terrible assumption. I AM all but confirmed.

Also, I KNOW that my role name and ability don't match. If I was fake claiming, they would. I really enjoy the Gunsmith role, and, should it be up to me, I would have it reflect its traditional abilities. I don't make the crazy rules, I just claim them.

[Your Worst Nightmare]

ywn, can you link us to a site where you and the jester played, and give us your screen names?

---------------------------

if ywn can do that, I find him pretty cleared. if he can't, um, mucho suspicouso.

Again the constant obsession with metagaming. And if I can't do this, you'll consider me

mucho sospechoso

? (Sospechoso, and not whatever gibberish you wrote there.) Even after you yourself pointed out that the "all but confirmed town" Gorrad said I wasn't a killer? "OMG he can't link us to other games he has played! Lynch him, for great justice!!1" doesn't make that much sense really...

But if it makes you happy, here: http://www.animeportugal.net/forum/index.php
I'm still Your_Worst_Nightmare, and that other guy is Gaara_of_the_Sand. Assuming he hasn't changed his name yet again...

Where did this come from? With that being said, the one time I encountered a devil, it acted like a rolecop for the mafia, but the mafia did not know who the devil was. Still though, I would like to know where this question of a devil coming from. Unless I am mistaken, you were the first to mention it.

No I wasn't. If I had, why would I be asking what it was?

[scotmany12]

I fail to see where I assumed anything. As well as where guardian said I made an assumption.

If I was fake claiming, they would.

Nice WIFOM btw.

Guardian, if Gorrad is scum, it doesn't clear YWN and who he investigates. I also plan to vote for someone tomorrow. Will most likely be Miztef or Incognito.

[Glork]

Prodding Miztef.

[Miztef]

sorry, I've having trouble posting in my games, school is really busy at the moment. I got the prod and will try to post constructively soon.

[Guardian]

Guardian, if Gorrad is scum, it doesn't clear YWN and who he investigates.

Gorrad can only be scum if MM is the same flavor of scum. So if we lynch Gorrad and MM, and we haven't won yet, either we had 4 of the same scumgroup in a mini, or we YWN and whomever aren't the same flavor of scum as Gorrad and MM.