Scummies Nomination Thread 2017

[Lycanfire]

Perpetual Mylo: viewtopic.php?f=23&t=73659. They were obvtown in another rather toxic environment.

Proof you didn't read the game

[Alisae]

Perpetual Mylo: viewtopic.php?f=23&t=73659. They were obvtown in another rather toxic environment.

Proof you didn't read the game

lol you spent the whole game voting Chara

[Ellibereth]

Perpetual Mylo: viewtopic.php?f=23&t=73659. They were obvtown in another rather toxic environment.

Proof you didn't read the game

Pretty sure you were the only one not townreading them D3 and onwards

[Lycanfire]

Perpetual Mylo: viewtopic.php?f=23&t=73659. They were obvtown in another rather toxic environment.

Proof you didn't read the game

lol you spent the whole game voting Chara

Apparently the game started at d4

[Alisaes French Maid]

Pretty sure you were the only one not townreading them D3 and onwards

lol rekt.

Also I agree with the Chara nom tbh.
Chara is one of the strongest newer player that I believe is regularly improving in a way that fits the title rising star.

I think the top contendor Ali would be more fitting to get Don Corleone cause I don't really see Ali as a consistently rising and improving player the way I see Chara. Also I 100% think Ali deserves Don Corleone as a nom I don't feel like getting into in this post.

Idk I guess my last sentence is something for the judges to decide.

[Lycanfire]

If you don't nom in the form the judges won't care.

[Alisaes French Maid]

yeye i'll do it later when I am not lazy

[fferyllt]

I nominated

Chara

for

Rising Star

. Nomination text copied in full below.

----------------------------------------

Note: Chara used to play under the account Not Chara and uses the latter account in some of the cited games.

I am nominating Chara because of their townplay. I have little experience with their scumplay. However, I feel like the following positive sides of their townplay are 1) the most important elements of good townplay and 2) increasingly rare among players on site.

Chara is obvtown in the vast majority of their town games and is almost never a distraction to the town solving-process. They are, consequently, never mislynched. They are often an integral part of the town-solving block. Their reads are sufficiently good to win the game and they are occasionally the one pushing correct lynches. Even when they are wrong, they don't cause the town to implode on itself.

Citations:

Inception Mafia: viewtopic.php?f=94&t=71602. They were obvtown. They were an integral part of the town block, keeping town together and organizing complex mechanics. Please note that this game was played across multiple threads. You can find them by looking through the topics of the mod.

DBZ Mafia: viewtopic.php?f=54&t=71107. They were also obvtown. Their reads were average, but they were good enough that when working with the rest of the town, they got the win.

Beneath the Mask: viewtopic.php?f=3&t=73578. They were one of the few obvtowns through positive play in a very chaotic and unstable town. They were not a distraction at all unlike the vast majority of the game. Their read accuracy didn't matter because they sheeped their way to a crushing town victory.

Perpetual Mylo: viewtopic.php?f=23&t=73659. They were obvtown in another rather toxic environment. Reads were sufficiently good to win a close game in the end.

I haven't read the other two games, but I was impressed by Chara's play in Perpetual MYLO III. They were unassailably obvtown by Day 3, and on the final game day, the last scum player initiated a 1v1 with them and lost it.

[Alisae]

There is finally a nomination for Hannibal Lecter. I chose Mary Saotome from Large Normal 206, who managed to completely hide that there even was a third party despite the same evidence that caught a mafia member saying that there were no more Mafia left.

BTW information came to us that Mary Saotome is a MariaR/Maki Harukawa alt so yeah I'm 2nding that considering she's kinda really good at this game.

[RadiantCowbells]

'information came to you' because maria alts are

so

hard to detect amirite

[Maki Harukawa]

'information came to you' because maria alts are

so

hard to detect amirite

YOU STILL HAVEN'T FIGURED OUT MY HIDDEN ALT SO HUSH ^_~

[mhsmith0]

'information came to you' because maria alts are

so

hard to detect amirite

YOU STILL HAVEN'T FIGURED OUT MY HIDDEN ALT SO HUSH ^_~

IT'S ME HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[Maki Harukawa]

'information came to you' because maria alts are

so

hard to detect amirite

YOU STILL HAVEN'T FIGURED OUT MY HIDDEN ALT SO HUSH ^_~

IT'S ME HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

...shit

[mhsmith0]

Sekrit alt exposed yo

[skirt skirt]

There is finally a nomination for Hannibal Lecter. I chose Mary Saotome from Large Normal 206, who managed to completely hide that there even was a third party despite the same evidence that caught a mafia member saying that there were no more Mafia left.

if there's no other noms this wins by default and i dont really care because maria is a good enough player but that was not impressive play by any measure. they got extremely lucky with kills and won because of it. and, a mafia member saying there's no members left isn't evidence lmfao what

[Alisae]

if there's no other noms this wins by default

Wrong, I'd assume if there are no other noms or they don't think its award worthy they can just not give them the award

[Alisae]

And even
glgl finding others to award

[Killthestory]

maria is a good player.

[KidAmn]

There is finally a nomination for Hannibal Lecter. I chose Mary Saotome from Large Normal 206, who managed to completely hide that there even was a third party despite the same evidence that caught a mafia member saying that there were no more Mafia left.

if there's no other noms this wins by default and i dont really care because maria is a good enough player but that was not impressive play by any measure. they got extremely lucky with kills and won because of it. and, a mafia member saying there's no members left isn't evidence lmfao what

Yeah, this was literally a win by blind luck which I wouldn't even remotely consider award worthy

[Alisae]

There is finally a nomination for Hannibal Lecter. I chose Mary Saotome from Large Normal 206, who managed to completely hide that there even was a third party despite the same evidence that caught a mafia member saying that there were no more Mafia left.

if there's no other noms this wins by default and i dont really care because maria is a good enough player but that was not impressive play by any measure. they got extremely lucky with kills and won because of it. and, a mafia member saying there's no members left isn't evidence lmfao what

Yeah, this was literally a win by blind luck which I wouldn't even remotely consider award worthy

Okay then fill out an anti-nom

[Creature]

tbh Hannibal Lecter should be syncretized with Don Corleone.

[Ellibereth]

ehh they're fundamentally different.

[Alisae]

There is finally a nomination for Hannibal Lecter. I chose Mary Saotome from Large Normal 206, who managed to completely hide that there even was a third party despite the same evidence that caught a mafia member saying that there were no more Mafia left.

if there's no other noms this wins by default and i dont really care because maria is a good enough player but that was not impressive play by any measure. they got extremely lucky with kills and won because of it. and, a mafia member saying there's no members left isn't evidence lmfao what

Yeah, this was literally a win by blind luck which I wouldn't even remotely consider award worthy

Actually
do you want to explain the luck aspect or?

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Everything's often contextual, and the context now is we've got terrible competition. It’s hard to really justify nominating anyone for Don Corleone or Hannibal Lector considering how bad towns are on this site are.

[Lil Uzi Vert]

I think the requirements for Paragon should also include making players around them better or at least work together and I’m not talking about just screaming to vote someone.